Why is Tom #8 pfp?

TS seems to have a twisted view of how P4P works. It's not a hypothetical of if a lighter guy were the same size as a heavier guy & who would win if they fought.

It's a comparison of how well they do vs the other guys in their division.

Per the reason Tom isn't higher on P4P is justified since he's only 3 significant wins into his run... (truly top level gate keepers) one of which he had to get back after a loss.

I get the hype behind him, & look forward to seeing how long he can remain at the top, but atm he's only just arrived.
 
P4P is so insanely subjective there's no real point arguing it. For me it's about who is the most skilled fighter who is also at their peak.
 
Because the current P4P system is a popularity contest.
 
TS seems to have a twisted view of how P4P works. It's not a hypothetical of if a lighter guy were the same size as a heavier guy & who would win if they fought.

It's a comparison of how well they do vs the other guys in their division.

Per the reason Tom isn't higher on P4P is justified since he's only 3 significant wins into his run... (truly top level gate keepers) one of which he had to get back after a loss.

I get the hype behind him, & look forward to seeing how long he can remain at the top, but atm he's only just arrived.
That's a significant factor, but not a conclusive factor... the concept extends to how a fighter’s skills and performance would translate hypothetically if size differences were neutralized. It’s about assessing the overall greatness and skillset at that time, not just success in a specific division.
 
I wonder why Dana cares so badly about JJ being #1. I wonder if he truly believes that, or if he wants that more as a way to fire JJ up to keep fighting...
 
I mean, the concept of pfp is more philosophical when it comes to lighter guys like Islam. It's not realistic. It is a ohh if Islam had that size and that ability, he could... It's just a, idk, way to show who seems more dominant overall, even knowing that Islam Makhachev would get totally destroyed by Alex Pereira and Jon Jones.... And Tom Aspinall, and Jiri Prochazka... And DDP too, you name it.

But Alex Pereira is #3 and JJ is #2 ... Why is Tom Aspinall #8? If he's the most likely guy to take on JJ, why #8? It doesn't matter if he's fighting in HW, because so is JJ. So if Tom Aspinall and JJ is the biggest fight, then Tom should be way closer to JJ than Alex Pereira... The ranking means pretty much that Jon Jones would have a harder time going to LHW and defeating Alex than defeating Tom.

But that's not the case, right? I mean, whoever does the pfp list is weighing on how Tom Aspinall is very dominant, how he KO'd two monsters there, and all... Tom Aspinall is the biggest threat...

But one knowledgeable MMA nerd and hardcore spectator/fan/follower had once told me --- I don't remember when --- "when fighters of similar weight are very close in the pfp, it means something. Nothing just ever happens in politics, just as in pfp if they are fighters that are the same weight and size, naturally". That's interesting...

I'm starting to weigh in on the possibility that Tom may be having been built up intentionally to a point, as well as Anakalaev, also with odds wise helping it, or Dana too, when saying JJ would pick Alex apart... Just as a way to build up what they seem as pretty much guaranteed as the last fight. But they may want to make more money with events before getting into that biggest of all fights... so maybe ""deceiving"" opinions on who's the toughest for this guys is part of it... Like, to make them have even bigger PPV events, so the final fight is not only even bigger than before, but also, done after the "best" fighters have given as much $ as they wanted...

Idk, I don't even believe this that much, it's more like a sudden thought in this week off that is giving me more free time than I should have lulz... I think that, from a most fact based approach, it may be nonsense, but.... We can only have perceptions shaped by what we see. I think it can be argued or theorized that an organization that still wants ultimately profit, wouldn't want us to see some things they already see.

We get it you like Jon Jones.
 
What a bizarre and pointless thread.

If Jones wants to vacate the HW belt and fight Poatan, whatever.

If he wants to hold onto the HW belt he has to fight Tom.

I don’t think anyone really cares either way. The only, unacceptable, situation is Jones fighting Poatan for the HW belt without a unification with Tom. That would just be ridiculous.
 
Back
Top