The case for a #1 contender fight

Usman had a very good performance against khamzat that he should have won (According to me and many others)

That is one good performance against a top tier fighter.

Shavkat has wins over neal, magny and wonderboy
Ian Garry has wins over neal, magny, and MVP
Jdm has wins over burns and Holland

Imo these three have a similar resume.

Shavkat haven't found since 2023 while Garry and jdm have remained active. Imo they should fight each other for the #1 contender
Borz has a ZERO case for a TS.

Except that Dana said “the winner of Borz/Usman was next”.

They expected Borz to blow through late replacement, Usman.

If Borz beats Whittaker.. I think he will have earned a TS at MW.

Whittaker by decision, or late stoppage.
 
Same with me and MVP. I don't know why anyone is sold on him being a top fighter when his highlights are all pretty low level. How someone can have the confidence to say he's on a similar level to the consistently proven Wonderboy is incredible to me.
Me either he's a glorified can crusher. Especially compared to WB. and Garry looked like crap against him, part of why I'm not very high on Garry. What's he going to do when he fights another decent striker that doesn't have trash grappling like mvp? If he was going to go grappling there he needed a sub not a fitching.
 
18-0 all stoppages
Vs
3 fight losing streak and no wins in 4 years

Case dismissed

Nothing to see here.
 
MVP and WB share a ranking in the same ballpark. Hafez isn't anywhere near the conversation. I could have brought up JDM's split to Holland but I didn't, because Holland is at least in the same ballpark. That would be disingenous. There are levels and JDM is on the bottom tier.
They might be ranked close together, but you can't tell me you think they're close in skill or accomplishment level? I mean, come on lol.
 
They might be ranked close together, but you can't tell me you think they're close in skill or accomplishment level? I mean, come on lol.
Holland is incredibly inconsistent. Kevin managed to beat ranked Chiesa to get a number and MVP was fortunate to get him after JDM while there was still a number next to his name. MVP is up there by happenstance and needs to defend being up there. Wonderboy is up there by proof.

It's so incomparable, the mind boggles to imagine calling them the same
 
Holland is incredibly inconsistent. Kevin managed to beat ranked Chiesa to get a number and MVP was fortunate to get him after JDM while there was still a number next to his name. MVP is up there by happenstance and needs to defend being up there. Wonderboy is up there by proof.

It's so incomparable, the mind boggles to imagine calling them the same
Holland being a ranked win is actually wild to consider, given how mid he is. Nothing against the guy but yeah. This is why people value the number of ranked wins. Lots of guys can get one or two getting the right matchup at the right time. Very few fighters that are not elite have a lot of ranked wins.

And it's why padding doesn't matter to me. If you're undefeated but have like 5 ranked wins you are not a goat contender, sorry.
 
They might be ranked close together, but you can't tell me you think they're close in skill or accomplishment level? I mean, come on lol.
MVP and WB? You can make an argument for it. MVP beat Holland and he didn't even have to go to a split to do it.
 
MVP and WB? You can make an argument for it. MVP beat Holland and he didn't even have to go to a split to do it.

<36>


Also... do you think WB beat Holland by split or something? Because that is.... not correct.
 
<36>


Also... do you think WB beat Holland by split or something? Because that is.... not correct.
No, WB finished Holland. My point is illustrating JDM is a not so great fighter because he went to a split with the #60 guy and a split with Kevin Holland. If Holland is mid how shit is JDM?
 
WB didn't split decision Holland, he was up 39-36 when he finished him
Great, you might even convince yourself JDM isn't elite and I don't have to do it.

Remember the other day, you told me it's arguable Hafez won the first and second round against JDM? I do.

<36>
 
No, WB finished Holland. My point is illustrating JDM is a not so great fighter because he went to a split with the #60 guy and a split with Kevin Holland. If Holland is mid how shit is JDM?
Because you were talking about comparing MVP and Wonderboy. Stay on target here please.
 
Because you were talking about comparing MVP and Wonderboy. Stay on target here please.
What are you main points of discontention? The obvious is that MVP didn't join UFC until recently and the 2 people who beat MVP also don't fight for the UFC. How do you want to go about comparing them?
 
Great, you might even convince yourself JDM isn't elite and I don't have to do it.

Remember the other day, you told me it's arguable Hafez won the first and second round against JDM? I do.

<36>
What an incredible non-sequitur. JDM also finished (no decision necessary) Burns who beat Wonderboy. And Wonderboy, according to you (because of how well MVP beat Holland or whatever dumbass math you're doing) is equal to MVP. So you see where your pick and choose bullshit falls apart?

It's all nonsense


What are you main points of discontention? The obvious is that MVP didn't join UFC until recently and the 2 people who beat MVP also don't fight for the UFC. How do you want to go about comparing them?
The exact opponent they both fought that you just mentioned and ignored us comparing?

Or maybe the very fact that he can't be compared, because he was fighting in another organization that had people nowhere near as good beating him is exactly why you shouldn't be calling them equal. You're sitting here saying they can't be compared, neglecting the one place they can be compared, and then comparing them anyway. YOU are at fault here to your own point. What do you not get? I understand your hateboner for JDM is so strong that you need to come up with whatever cockamamie math you can, but you're off the fuckin reservation, mate
 
What an incredible non-sequitur. JDM also finished (no decision necessary) Burns who beat Wonderboy. And Wonderboy, according to you (because of how well MVP beat Holland or whatever dumbass math you're doing) is equal to MVP. So you see where your pick and choose bullshit falls apart?

It's all nonsense
You're so confident, you shouldn't have any problem proving MVP and WB aren't comparable. Let's see it.
 
You're so confident, you shouldn't have any problem proving MVP and WB aren't comparable. Let's see it.
A) You just implied they weren't. B) I also did JUST compare them. In multiple ways

What do you not get? You are an absolute brick wall.
 
A) You just implied they weren't. B) I also did JUST compare them. In multiple ways

What do you not get? You are an absolute brick wall.
MVP is up there by happenstance and needs to defend being up there. Wonderboy is up there by proof.

It's so incomparable, the mind boggles to imagine calling them the same


That's your quote. Here's another

And Wonderboy, according to you (because of how well MVP beat Holland or whatever dumbass math you're doing) is equal to MVP. So you see where your pick and choose bullshit falls apart?

It's all nonsense



Pick one and stick with it.
 
No, WB finished Holland. My point is illustrating JDM is a not so great fighter because he went to a split with the #60 guy and a split with Kevin Holland. If Holland is mid how shit is JDM?
<AckbarTrap>
 
What's even more hilarious about this is that Mr Bandito literally told me the other day in ohe of his rage fits that Hafez actually does have an argument for winning rounds 1 and 2 against JDM.

{<jordan}
 
What's even more hilarious about this is that Mr Bandito literally told me the other day in ohe of his rage fits that Hafez actually does have an argument for winning rounds 1 and 2 against JDM.

{<jordan}
I don't think any of it matters that much if we all agree on the order at least.
 
Back
Top