Movies SUPERMAN (Dragonlord's Review, post #1)

If you have seen SUPERMAN (2025), how would you rate it?


  • Total voters
    116
People don't appreciate what we have on television.

They focus on what isn't working and ignore moments like this.

That's a sad way to live, in my opinion.


Coincidentally I saw this clip a few days ago. It just popped in my YouTube feed. This scene was very well done.

I watched the first episodes of the show and stopped around episode 2 or 3. I checked out the series finale and didn't like it except for the emotional epilogue.

Since you and @PRIDEWASBETTER recommending it hard, I will give it another chance and start from the beginning. I was thinking that this is like Agents of Shield where people dismissed it because of the TV show campy quality but missed out on a great series if they watched the first 4 seasons.
 
Coincidentally I saw this clip a few days ago. It just popped in my YouTube feed. This scene was very well done.

I watched the first episodes of the show and stopped around episode 2 or 3. I checked out the series finale and didn't like it except for the emotional epilogue.

Since you and @PRIDEWASBETTER recommending it hard, I will give it another chance and start from the beginning. I was thinking that this is like Agents of Shield where people dismissed it because of the TV show campy quality but missed out on a great series if they watched the first 4 seasons.

I never recommended it hard, I saw flaws and knew it wasn't for everyone.

For me, the highs were fantastic, but for a lot of people the show on the whole will be middle of the road at best.

I have never recommended Smallville for the same reason. I never missed an episode but so much was so boring the juice just wasn't worth the squeeze. They'd do something really good every few episodes and once a season they MIGHT do something great. Considering the raw tonnage of contrived teen drama, it just wasn't worth it.

Superman and Lois was a lot better but never felt good enough to recommend.
 
I never recommended it hard, I saw flaws and knew it wasn't for everyone.

For me, the highs were fantastic, but for a lot of people the show on the whole will be middle of the road at best.

I have never recommended Smallville for the same reason. I never missed an episode but so much was so boring the juice just wasn't worth the squeeze. They'd do something really good every few episodes and once a season they MIGHT do something great. Considering the raw tonnage of contrived teen drama, it just wasn't worth it.

Superman and Lois was a lot better but never felt good enough to recommend.

I do recommend TalkVille on YouTube. Great rewatch podcast with Rosenbaum and Welling.
 
I do recommend TalkVille on YouTube. Great rewatch podcast with Rosenbaum and Welling.

How well do you know Smallville?

There's a brief scene that landed imagery so iconic it's seared into my memory.

Clark has lost his powers and it seems all hope is lost until he stands up, blue jacket and red shirt, with a sledgehammer in his hand. It was just a few seconds, but the music and zoom were so perfect I'll never forget the image.

I haven't seen this in many years so I may have the context wrong, but I'll never forget those seconds.
 
How well do you know Smallville?

There's a brief scene that landed imagery so iconic it's seared into my memory.

Clark has lost his powers and it seems all hope is lost until he stands up, blue jacket and red shirt, with a sledgehammer in his hand. It was just a few seconds, but the music and zoom were so perfect I'll never forget the image.

I haven't seen this in many years so I may have the context wrong, but I'll never forget those seconds.

Hmmm... was that in the episode Mortal? It's been a while for me as well, but I think I remember something like that in that episode.
 
Hmmm... was that in the episode Mortal? It's been a while for me as well, but I think I remember something like that in that episode.

Yessir.

Found the episode online and captured this gif. Man, Welling was a big guy.

Smallville%20502%20%202.gif
 
I like this version of Superman, but the story is meh. I didn't like how they portrayed Lex, and found his general plan a bit ridiculous/underwhelming for a guy who can create pocket dimensions, create and control metahumans and all the rest.
But I'm open to another entry, the themes/tone/etc all work for me, hopefully the next villain is better, or even if Lex comes back, having been humbled and exposed changes him
 
i'm on my fourth day of trying to finish this movie. i feel like i'm being pranked, it's so bad.
Superman being hysterical in a discussion with Lois. completly looking like a douche that throws a tantrum and slams the door on his way out.
EVERYTHING having that cartoony cgi look and feel. every line of dialogue sounding like they're written either by CHatgpt or by a highschool movie project team. that absolute embarrassment of "where's my dog" scene.

this is one of the dumbest movies i have ever seen.
 
Brandon Routh's take on the new Superman movie

Routh: “It was a lot of fun. I really enjoyed it. I think David [Corenswet] is fantastic. I cried no less than three times.”

“I see this in a different way. I come at it from a different perspective. I really got into it as I’m watching him navigate those tricky Superman moments in the first conversation with Lois and Clark in the apartment. And then all of the family stuff for me really hit. It’s a big movie. There’s a lot in there. I have to go see it again.”

“I really am excited for the potential for the DC Universe. A successful launch with this is just good for everybody who wants more of what DC has to offer. There are a lot of great properties that can be explored.”


 
I watched it for the 3rd time and it grew on me even more. I do think they went way too hard in the "animated series style scifi" thats not really explained and we just accept it. If this is a new DC world we need to build to that a little bit without it feeling so jarring for the average viewer. It didnt bother me too much but my GF was a little confused and put off by it.

I dont think Im going to like James Gunns take on Batman at all and I really hope he leaves that character up to someone else. Or maybe dont bring him into this world at all. I dont think he really fits into it.
 
I dont think Im going to like James Gunns take on Batman at all and I really hope he leaves that character up to someone else. Or maybe dont bring him into this world at all. I dont think he really fits into it.

I think a Batman would fit in well with this universe because Mister Terrific's role in the Superman film was basically Batman.

Mister Terrific was the brains of Justice Gang. He is portrayed as being too serious at times. He gave commands on how to take down the kaiju. He helped Lois track down Superman. He was a one-man army against LuthorCorps' goons. He understood the pocket universe and tried to stop it. He lets Lois borrow his airship. Now imagine all of these scenes done by Batman. It fits, right? More or less you get a live-action version of the Justice League animated series.

justice-league-unlimited-2000-36e4d5a420f2499d808708f00128b10d.jpg
 
I think a Batman would fit in well with this universe because Mister Terrific's role in the Superman film was basically Batman.

Mister Terrific was the brains of Justice Gang. He is portrayed as being too serious at times. He gave commands on how to take down the kaiju. He helped Lois track down Superman. He was a one-man army against LuthorCorps' goons. He understood the pocket universe and tried to stop it. He let Lois borrow his airship. Now imagine all of these scenes done by Batman. It fits, right? More or less you get a live-action version of the Justice League animated series.
I suppose I could see that. I agree it fits into the Justice League version of Batman. I will say that I would prefer a season 1-2 version of the animated series batman then the justice league version. I like a more butthurt type of Batman. Hes supposed to be pissed off but doesnt use that against the people he cares out, just the bad guys.
 
Just FYi my son, who earlier said he loved it, just told me he went back and watched Superman Returns all on his own. He likes it too, but said it's not on the same tier as the new one. Also, he is a baseball kid through and through, that's all he really does so he knows jack squat about comics.
 
Coincidentally I saw this clip a few days ago. It just popped in my YouTube feed. This scene was very well done.

I watched the first episodes of the show and stopped around episode 2 or 3. I checked out the series finale and didn't like it except for the emotional epilogue.

Since you and @PRIDEWASBETTER recommending it hard, I will give it another chance and start from the beginning. I was thinking that this is like Agents of Shield where people dismissed it because of the TV show campy quality but missed out on a great series if they watched the first 4 seasons.
I was a pretty big fan of the show. Far from perfect, rocky in the beginning and in the final season, but Season 3 was really good, imo. The emotional epilogue had more punch when you see full picture.
 
Back
Top