Opinion Did Charlie Kirk have extremist thoughts and opinions?

Did Charlie Kirk have extremist thoughts and opinions?

  • Yes.

    Votes: 120 42.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 160 57.1%

  • Total voters
    280
I think the jump from status quo to calling for the death penalty over supposed cooperation is bigger than the jump from the latter to public executions.

Frankly, there isn't that much of a difference between public and private executions in my book. We're just talking the veneer of respectability and public values at that point.

He said prison or death penalty.. it’s intricate but I think it matters to be accurate when you are claiming someone is an extremist.

One could take the claim as one who feels strongly about justice being served in the system.. the other as someone who just wants to see Biden killed.

May seem subtle to you but I think it matters.
 
Which post?
Fuck me "supremely annoying" as you were called decades ago when you were a child strikes again.
The post where I “laughed at (your) rape”
Lady, you have absolutely zero ability to shame me.
 
He said prison or death penalty.. it’s intricate but I think it matters to be accurate when you are claiming someone is an extremist.

One could take the claim as one who feels strongly about justice being served in the system.. the other as someone who just wants to see Biden killed.

May seem subtle to you but I think it matters.
I mean... Do you see leading Democrats calling for Trump to face the death penalty? That should kind of tell you how extreme Kirk's stance is, especially given that the evidence of Trump's corruption vastly exceeds Biden or really any other modern president's.
 
"The clip was taken from Charlie Kirk’s talk radio show, The Charlie Kirk Show, where he can be seen saying, “Joe Biden is a bumbling, dementia filled, alzheimer's, corrupt tyrant who should honestly be put in prison and or given the death penalty for his crimes against America.”"

--

"This isn’t the first time the late conservative influencer had expressed a passion for capital punishment. In another clip, he can be seen advocating for public executions and for children to be allowed to watch them.

"Death penalties should be public, should be quick, it should be televised. I think at a certain age, its an initiation...What age should you start to see public executions?" Kirk asked, adding, “At what age should you start to see public executions?”

Another man replies eagerly, “16.”

“I think you could do it earlier, like maybe age 12. Sixth grade or so,” replies Blake Neff."

That’s not him calling for a public execution of Joe Biden, though. I guess I can understand how you might conflate the 2 points though.
 
The post where I “laughed at (your) rape”
Lady, you have absolutely zero ability to shame me.
So other people who pulled you up on it are just in it for the lulz? Who did you blame for my rape? And why have you repeatedly trivialised it?
 
He said prison or death penalty.. it’s intricate but I think it matters to be accurate when you are claiming someone is an extremist.

One could take the claim as one who feels strongly about justice being served in the system.. the other as someone who just wants to see Biden killed.

May seem subtle to you but I think it matters.
If you think the death penalty should be implemented for treason or sedition (i don’t), it tracks that would be his actual conclusion.

I mentioned it before, but as these kids who are streaming every day eventually venture into politics, are we (not you specifically) going to hold them accountable for every bad take or shitty comment? It’s just going to be more curated suits/actors in politics if we leave out anyone who has sat down with every side of the aisle and actully had tough, crazy, funny, tense conversations
 
I mean... Do you see leading Democrats calling for Trump to face the death penalty? That should kind of tell you how extreme Kirk's stance is, especially given that the evidence of Trump's corruption vastly exceeds Biden or really any other modern president's.
I’m not defending Charlie’s point. I don’t even agree with him. I just am saying that claiming he wants Joe Biden publicly executed is not the same as saying he should pay for his alleged crimes including prison or execution.

Let’s just be accurate about what was said if we are going to be making claims.
 
So pther people who pulled you up on it are just in it for the lulz? Who did you blame for my rape? And why have you repeatedly trivialised it?
Who do i blame for your rape?uh, the person who raped you.
What the fuck are you talking about lol
Quote the post
 
I’m not defending Charlie’s point. I don’t even agree with him. I just am saying that claiming he wants Joe Biden publicly executed is not the same as saying he should pay for his alleged crimes including prison or execution.

Let’s just be accurate about what was said if we are going to be making claims.
We're going in circles here. Is corruption one of the handful of capital crimes we recognize in the US?

Also not sure if you saw the other poster's elaboration...
"The clip was taken from Charlie Kirk’s talk radio show, The Charlie Kirk Show, where he can be seen saying, “Joe Biden is a bumbling, dementia filled, alzheimer's, corrupt tyrant who should honestly be put in prison and or given the death penalty for his crimes against America.”"

--

"This isn’t the first time the late conservative influencer had expressed a passion for capital punishment. In another clip, he can be seen advocating for public executions and for children to be allowed to watch them.

"Death penalties should be public, should be quick, it should be televised. I think at a certain age, its an initiation...What age should you start to see public executions?" Kirk asked, adding, “At what age should you start to see public executions?”

Another man replies eagerly, “16.”

“I think you could do it earlier, like maybe age 12. Sixth grade or so,” replies Blake Neff."

 
Would you be fine with the tyranny of the majority eliminating the freedom of religion clause in the 1st Amendment? If that’s what the majority wanted. Just because it may be something the majority wants doesn’t mean it can’t be extremist.

No I'd think it's retarded amd completely against what i thought the country stood forbut my belief would be the extreme one since it wasn't widely held any longer. That is exactly what extreme means. An opinion that is way out there from everyone else.
 
If you think the death penalty should be implemented for treason or sedition (i don’t), it tracks that would be his actual conclusion.

I mentioned it before, but as these kids who are streaming every day eventually venture into politics, are we (not you specifically) going to hold them accountable for every bad take or shitty comment? It’s just going to be more curated suits/actors in politics if we leave out anyone who has sat down with every side of the aisle and actully had tough, crazy, funny, tense conversations

Sounds like you are describing cancel culture. The answer to that is yes. People do hold them accountable for things they’ve said deep into their past.
 
Sounds like you are describing cancel culture. The answer to that is yes. People do hold them accountable for things they’ve said deep into their past.
I’m not disputing that it happens, it’s just funny that the same people who want “relatable” candidates will get up in arms with a streamer for a joke or flippant comment in a 4 hour conversation.

If you recorded anyone for hours a day, for years, you’re bound to find tons of dumb shit. I’m honestly surprised that after talking on campuses for a decade the left only has like 5 “smoking gun” clips of Charlie
 
I’m not disputing that it happens, it’s just funny that the same people who want “relatable” candidates will get up in arms with a streamer for a joke or flippant comment in a 4 hour conversation.

If you recorded anyone for hours a day, for years, you’re bound to find tons of dumb shit. I’m honestly surprised that after talking on campuses for a decade the left only has like 5 “smoking gun” clips of Charlie

I think that’s very true for most people.. however when your political based show revolves around you talking about your own personal political/religious/social beliefs, that’s not the same as just an off handed remark during normal conversation over the years..

You are literally making a living sharing what you believe in, so I actually think it’s valid to bring up what you may have said.
 
I think that’s very true for most people.. however when your political based show revolves around you talking about your own personal political/religious/social beliefs, that’s not the same as just an off handed remark during normal conversation over the years..

You are literally making a living sharing what you believe in, so I actually think it’s valid to bring up what you may have said.
(((I’m agreeing with you bud)))
 
Why not? If you’re pro-choice why wouldn’t you want to know about a massive corporation like that?
Because my concern is mostly in regard to overly restrictive policies regarding this topic. Planned Parenthood doesn't pass laws so I dont care. My biggest concerns are allowing doctors to perform emergency procedures without fear of legal action, ensuring victims of rape are not forced to have their rapist's child, and proving easy and affordable access to multiple types of contraceptives.

If the org has issues then then something better should replace it.
 
Because my concern is mostly in regard to overly restrictive policies regarding this topic. Planned Parenthood doesn't pass laws so I dont care. My biggest concerns are allowing doctors to perform emergency procedures without fear of legal action, ensuring victims of rape are not forced to have their rapist's child, and proving easy and affordable access to multiple types of contraceptives.

If the org has issues then then something better should replace it.
They’re some of the biggest donors and lobbyists in politics.

speaking of, any updates on those stories?
 
Back
Top