• We are currently experiencing technical difficulties. We sincerely apologize for the inconvenience.

All Time GOAT poll

pankrat said:
Sherdog heavies is a great sample.
Claro que sí, par de julianes
Click to expand...
Its an mma community where many people have been watching a decade or more. I don't think its that bad. In terms of people having mma knowledge. Yes, a lot of people here have other issues.
 
Mike said:
Its an mma community where many people have been watching a decade or more. I don't think its that bad. In terms of people having mma knowledge. Yes, a lot of people here have other issues.
Click to expand...

Listen, it's UNDENIABLE that there is a massive crown of GSP fanboys in these boards and particularly from Canada. Poepl who doesnt really know that much about this game, even if they spent the last decade posting on here, because their motivation is to hype up their idol rather than the sport itself.
This is an evidence, if you want to pretend that is none of that, that this is a truly unbiased, leveled sample, fool yourself if you wish
 
pankrat said:
Listen, it's UNDENIABLE that there is a massive crown of GSP fanboys in these boards and particularly from Canada. Poepl who doesnt really know that much about this game, even if they spent the last decade posting on here, because their motivation is to hype up their idol rather than the sport itself.
This is an evidence, if you want to pretend that is none of that, that this is a truly unbiased, leveled sample, fool yourself if you wish
Click to expand...
Oh it is? I've been on here since 2007. Back then way more people favored Anderson or Fedor in those discussions. Gsp was a notch down going head to head with Penn. Both in fights for legacy. Then came the Brock fans, Cain and jds fans. Jones fans. For awhile when he was undefeated Machida gained a large following. And many, many other fighters.

Its changed often through the years, and guys dropped down the ranks when they started losing while their peers were still winning. Or as the perception of divisions changed. For years on here I've argued with Anderson fans, but I never dismissed the entire site as being illogical Anderson fanboys. I'd at least listen to their arguments. Even if I found them flawed and always thought gsp was better.

But its really just objectively false to say gsp has always dominated here, or that its some cabal of Canadian gsp fanboys. Gsp gained fans and support as his accomplishments grew. And if tthere's one thing I've learned on here, it's that sherdog is pretty diverse with people from all over the world.
 
DS7 said:
it's called subjectivity bro
Click to expand...
That goes without saying. But there's a reason the vast majority of fans don't think a guy fighting in a newer weight class that is still developing, is the best ever. Its like saying a wmma fighter is the best ever. And I'm a big MM fan so I'm not trying to downplay him. He's the best flyweight ever for sure.
 
pankrat said:
Listen, it's UNDENIABLE that there is a massive crown of GSP fanboys in these boards and particularly from Canada. Poepl who doesnt really know that much about this game, even if they spent the last decade posting on here, because their motivation is to hype up their idol rather than the sport itself.
This is an evidence, if you want to pretend that is none of that, that this is a truly unbiased, leveled sample, fool yourself if you wish
Click to expand...

And there is isn't a MASSIVE crown of Silva fanboys? Not a MASSIVE crown of Fedor fanboys? Stop playing the victim card just because you get called out on your bullshit constantly by GSP fans.
 
ThunderStruck said:
And there is isn't a MASSIVE crown of Silva fanboys? Not a MASSIVE crown of Fedor fanboys? Stop playing the victim card just because you get called out on your bullshit constantly by GSP fans.
Click to expand...

I o ly get called by the
 
pankrat said:
I o ly get called by the
Click to expand...

By the what?

If you don't consider a sherdog poll valid (mostly because you think GSP shouldn't be winning, you sure as hell would consider it valid if Silva was winning and you would bloat about it). Then surely the latest poll conducted among MMA fighters should be better right?

https://theathletic.com/1856943/2020/06/05/fighters-vote-mma-goat-pound-for-pound-best/

But no, it won't be valid in your mind.... for the sole fact that your favourite fighter isn't winning.
 
ThunderStruck said:
By the what?

If you don't consider a sherdog poll valid (mostly because you think GSP shouldn't be winning, you sure as hell would consider it valid if Silva was winning and you would bloat about it). Then surely the latest poll conducted among MMA fighters should be better right?

https://theathletic.com/1856943/2020/06/05/fighters-vote-mma-goat-pound-for-pound-best/

But no, it won't be valid in your mind.... for the sole fact that your favourite fighter isn't winning.
Click to expand...

hahahaha
 
ThunderStruck said:
You're a sore loser.
Click to expand...

The fact is wh often found ourselves discussing in GSP vs Silva related threads. And you can see me discussing with plenty of guys with "Location: Canada"...yet I dont see you discussing with Brazilian people. I just dont see you. And I see you around a lot. But I dont see you.

Yet the sherdog poll is reliable.....LOL. Keep pretending kiddo.
 
pankrat said:
The fact is wh often found ourselves discussing in GSP vs Silva related threads. And you can see me discussing with plenty of guys with "Location: Canada"...yet I dont see you discussing with Brazilian people. I just dont see you. And I see you around a lot. But I dont see you.

Yet the sherdog poll is reliable.....LOL. Keep pretending kiddo.
Click to expand...

I just posted a poll conducted among mma fighters in 2020. You don't even read posts you just reply some random bullshit.

You lose, again.
 
ThunderStruck said:
I just posted a poll conducted among mma fighters in 2020. You don't even read posts you just reply some random bullshit.

You lose, again.
Click to expand...

That poll means just as much as me searching for another and paste it here. Remind that Silva was ahead og GSP in p4p standings by most pundits during theuir championship runs so I can bring ton of links.
In the link you bring, they dont say the name of the guy they are asking to ¡¡!! Its absurd. And some of them even admit to not following the sport back in the day LOL. Its so absurd but that the W you can take I guess to I enjoy it kiddo.
 
pankrat said:
That poll means just as much as me searching for another and paste it here. Remind that Silva was ahead og GSP in p4p standings by most pundits during theuir championship runs so I can bring ton of links.
In the link you bring, they dont say the name of the guy they are asking to ¡¡!! Its absurd. And some of them even admit to not following the sport back in the day LOL. Its so absurd but that the W you can take I guess to I enjoy it kiddo.
Click to expand...

Go on and find another poll conducted among pro fighters and post it here. Ill wait. And of coruse they dont ask for the name of the fighters, its an anonymous poll.

And if you were following mma back then the difference between Silva and GSP was extremely close and it wasn't widely in favor of Silva like you keep claiming like the mma newb that you are.


Don't bother replying until you post a fighter poll, kid.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,280,218
Messages
58,267,400
Members
175,988
Latest member
xindispider

Share this page

Back
Top