- Joined
- Jun 1, 2007
- Messages
- 34,205
- Reaction score
- 55,431
you’re swinging at straw men, not the actual points I made.I never said no value, learn to read
Its value comes from demand, and its demand is inflated by people who are seeing Bitcoin as an investment, which as you pointed out, its not an investment.
So what happens when the people who see Bitcoin as an investment decide to cash out?
No, it doesn't, unless you are being stupid enough to compare the entirety of traditional banking system with the entirety of BTC network which would be like me saying that candles are a more efficient source of lighting than electricity because you are comparing the entirety or electrical illumination to candles.
Because Bitcoin uses orders of magnitude more of energy than traditional electronic systems like a million times more.
The US dollar is valuable precisely because its centralized and precisely because the Fed is an extremely respected institution which has a mandate to keep the price of the US dollar stable.
BTC is not money.
Dismiss what exactly? i merely stated that its a ponzi scheme where more people put money than people take out money and you got your jimmies rustled over it.
Bitcoin is an investment for some and a monetary hedge for others, just like gold, real estate, or even the U.S. dollar. The fact that people buy and later sell doesn’t invalidate because that’s literally how markets work.
You’re right that its value comes from demand, but that applies to every form of money. The dollar only holds value because people trust that the Fed will maintain some degree of stability. That’s not some magical intrinsic quality for it. Its value is based on collective belief, just like Bitcoin.
As for the energy argument, measuring Bitcoin’s cost per transaction is stupid.
It’s not just a payment network. It is a decentralized monetary system securing hundreds of billions in value without any central authority. Comparing that to a centralized electronic system is like comparing the cost of running your local Excel file to the cost of securing the entire internet.
And if Bitcoin’s a Ponzi, who exactly is running it? Where’s the central orchestrator making promises or payouts? There are none. It’s a free market with buyers, sellers, and a predictable monetary policy — that’s the opposite of a Ponzi.
Look, it’s fine not to believe in Bitcoin — but calling it a scam while defending a fiat system that’s lost 98% of its value in 100 years is… a stupid ass take.