Top 6 GOAT's of MMA

[Noleggeisha]

Honourable mentions - DJ (but didnt move up in weight), Aldo

Roided GOAT - Bones

6.GSP - had a great title reign but ran from the Whittaker fight so ranked lower

5. Anderson Silva - Roided. But jumped up a weight division and fought DC on 2 days notice - clean.

4. Conor Mcgregor - first champ champ, beat Aldo in seconds, went 10 rounds with one of the GOAT's of boxing in his first fight

3. Stipe - most ufc HW title defences

2. Fedor - like to believe he was always clean

1. DC - undefeated (Jon himself admitted to roiding in both fights) champ champ

Mostly agreed.

 

[Sweater of AV]

1. Fedor
2. Saku
3. Big Nog
4. Hendo
5. BJ
6. Mousasi

HM: Shogun could be in there over Mousasi or BJ as well.

 

[wigglestick]

I think throwing DC and aldo in the mix is fine, GSP or fedor is #1 and #2 and Jones is goat of cheaters over anderson.

 

[agibmxmma]

Jones and Silva are cheaters, while McGregor has never defended a title in his life, so they don't make my list.
1 GSP
2 DJ
3 DC
4 Fedor
5 Aldo
6 BJ
* Cruz, Khabib, Tyron, Hendo, Randy

 

[Number 8]

1. Fedor
GSP
Jones
A. Silva

6 is too much.

 

[Perrichet]

GSP

DC

Fedor

MM

*Jones

How the hell is Anderson above GSP???

PED’s maybe?

 

[Gambit MMA]

Fuck you

Fedor
Gsp
Anderson
Jones
Aldo
Cruz

 

[ThunderStruck]

Honourable mentions - DJ (but didnt move up in weight), Aldo

Roided GOAT - Bones

6.GSP - had a great title reign but ran from the Whittaker fight so ranked lower

5. Anderson Silva - Roided. But jumped up a weight division and fought DC on 2 days notice - clean.

4. Conor Mcgregor - first champ champ, beat Aldo in seconds, went 10 rounds with one of the GOAT's of boxing in his first fight

3. Stipe - most ufc HW title defences

2. Fedor - like to believe he was always clean

1. DC - undefeated (Jon himself admitted to roiding in both fights) champ champ

That is one ridiculously shitty list.

 

[Streeter]

Ww platinum Mike Perry
Lw Platinum Mike Perry
Mw Platinum Mike Perry
Lhw Platinum Mike Perry
Fw Platinum Mike Perry
Bw Platinum Mike Perry



Eventually Erik Silva might make list

 

[ThunderStruck]

1. Fedor
2. Saku
3. Big Nog
4. Hendo
5. BJ
6. Mousasi

Someone's been listing his fav fighters.

 

[Sweater of AV]

Someone's been listing his fav fighters.

There are definitely similarities between who I think are the greatest and who I've enjoyed watching the most, which would probably be Fedor, Saku, Shogun, BJ, Big Nog, Wandy.

In terms of who I think are the greatest, I value fighters that don't care about weight, just want to prove they are the best, and have a high skill-level. People who have those qualities and had highly successful careers without failing drug tests etc. are who I consider great.

 

[Typrune Goatley]

Someone's been listing his fav fighters.

The first 5 he listed were all #1 fighters in the world at one point. They were all P4P greats who weren't afraid to fight killers and significantly larger men.

 

[Bend NvR Break]

Fedor, Jones, AS, GSP, Aldo, Cruz

HM: MM

 

[West Linn]

Stipe is nowhere near goat

Fedor
Anderson
GSP
Jones
Aldo
Dan Henderson

BJ Penn, Mighty Mouse, DC honorable mentions

 

[iwhoopedbatman]

Jones
GSP
Fedor
DC
Anderson
Aldo/MM

 

[John makfresshi]

1. Jones
2. Silva
3. Fedor
4. DC
5. Aldo
6. GSP

Move 4,5,6 up 1 and fedor to 6 spot and we gotta match brotha

 

[L.T.]

Not one BJ mention good. If I hear about how fatass Penn fought fatass MW/LHW/"HW" Machida in a completely inconsequential fight in the middle of the Brazilian jungle I'll kill myself. While Machida was still nothing more than a karate point fighter.

 

[Fight Professor]

1-6 top to bottom:

GSP - it does not matter that he is picking fights out of his prime.

Conor - contributions to the sport in terms of popularity, fighters pay and being a phenomenal fighters in 2 weight classes means more than just defenses.

Fedor - not much to say besides that he did not go to fight in the US in his prime. But PRIDE was just as important at the time.

DC - Jones causes him to be outside top 3

Silva - amazing defence record and fighting style. Unfortunately got busted for peds multiple times.

Jones - similar story to Silva but his style is less exciting.

 

[Sweater of AV]

BJ is a great choice for any GOAT list.

 

[gono btw]

Someone's been listing his fav fighters.

Well, guess what...Could be my list too.. SAKU GOAT though...