Guys like Machida, and WB did traditional martial arts as well as other arts... WB had an extensive Kickboxing record... there's a reason he didn't stick with point karate.
I did point karate for a year as a kid, and I feel like it helps me, and influences my sparring today, that being said I know a lot of guys from that karate gym that never went of their comfort zone and trained at an MMA gym where you ACTUALLY fight. I would literally murder them all today, because point karate is just very different than real fighting, but I bet if you listened to them talk about martial arts they'd sound like the baddest mofos in the world, and then throw a spinning kick to back it up. It's not that they're 100% full of shit, I respect them as martial artists, but these guys never had the ego to actually fight/spar in real environments as you find in MMA gyms, BJJ gyms, Muay Thai gyms, etc.
I have no clue what his background actually is, but him claiming a black belt in japanese jiu jitsu is suspect to me honestly, never seen him in a jiu jitsu gym, or training bjj ever, but he put in 5-10 years to get a blackbelt? Or did he go to some "japanese jiu jitsu" instructor that taught him some basic bs and gave him a black belt after 2 years. I bet he has 2 stripe white belt level skills.
Yeah, MJW appears to have trained pure boxing in the correct way to supplement his traditional martial arts.
Which automatically puts him ahead of most karate guys
Typically the biggest flaw with TKD / karate bases is that they picked up and ingrained very poor boxing habits into their their neural pathways. That doesnt appear to be the case with MJW. Hes smart.
And I'm gonna defer to Rogan here in that he is a very legit kyokushin black belt. I respect Rogan's opinion on anything kick related more than most.
When he says something like, MJW has perfect, impeccable kicking technique, that is a very powerful statement and it would be wise to listen.
Rogan knows what hes talking about.
It's been said that MJW has frequented mma gyms and sparred with many elite guys over the years. Theres video of him with Ben Saunders, Kimbo, obviously he filmed a movie with Josh Barnett, Todd Duffee and a bunch of other mma guys.
JKVD seems to be the type of martial artist you're talking about. Someone who has a strong background but isnt in there actually testing himself and lacks tangible experience.
Conversely, MJW seems like the guy who is very much in there getting a feel for where his skills stack up against legitimate fighters. Why would he not?
I understand it was a movie but if you watch the flow like movement between Machida and MJW, that wasnt choreographed. They were just playing, but you get a feel for how someone like MJW would fight.
Like other traditional martial artists, there is a sense that he would have many similar elements to his style weve seen from guys like Machida, WB, Conor.
Strong distance management, lateral movement, ability to fight off the back foot, countering prowess, difficulty of being hit, strong kicking technique as a means of measuring and keeping distance. That kyokushin point fighting style just creates a fighter who is very difficult to find.
Does that mean we know for certain if he would respond well to taking shots, reactions to being hit and handling pressure? No, but the tools are certainly there on paper.
Assuming that a life long martial artist wouldnt be able to handle themselves in a fight just because they havent competed is just a weird assumption to make. What is the core reason we train? Physical mastery. Ability to defend yourself.
Anyways, that's my feel of things. I respect your opinion tho. I'd like to think I have a very good sense for fighters and talent / potential. At times I feel like I see things others might miss. Called more than a few fighters before theyve truly arrived.
I see MJW as a very different type of martial artist than someone like JKVD or the typical karate guy who hasnt immersed themselves into mma / incorporated well rounded elements to their style.
In terms of his jiu jitsu background, who knows. Dont know enough about japanese jiu jitsu to say how formidable it is. Although, considering his other background, assuming hes a white belt on the mats seems a bit hasty. Presumably it's the weakest aspect of the game.
Though I heard he used to wrestle in highschool as well.