Just read :
- Tehzibu'l-tehzib traduction if you are reallly interested ( I doubt you are, you probably just want to believe what suit you .. )
You are guilty of the same things you are accusing me of. Why are you pretending like if there is something that can convince you that Islam is just the ramblings of schizophrenic Arab who lived a long time ago?
You choose to believe in Islam because it "suits you."
Yaqub ibn Shaibah and most importantly the famous Malik ibn Anas who was the student of hisham ibn urwah talked about hisham ibn urwah being senile at 71 years old and decided to left medine for irak.
- Mizanu'l-ai`tidal also mentions ibn urwah having a very bad memory etc
I deal with senile people. Some of them can't remember most things, and others can clearly remember what happened in the early days of their lives, and they only have problems with new information.
For example, if a World War 2 veteran tells me that he joined the military when he was 17 years old, I wouldn't doubt it, because it something that many of them did.
This is why asked you to provide me with a source of Islam scholars who doubted that Aisha was 6 when she married Muhammad and 9 when he consumated the marriage. I am asking about this specific example.
When we have arguments in Sherdog, often people will dismiss posters they don't like with statements like "he is just an idiot," "he is clueless," and etc. Is this true? Why should anybody accept these claims?
there is only one source for aicha being 6 years old at the wedding, and it is an old 71 senile dude who lived almost a century after the muslim's prophet lived ... this senile dude was respected during his youth, this is the reason his story became famous in Irak.
Now it is up to you if you want to actually dig into the subject, or just believe what other incels have said on some weird ass forums ....
Muhammad was the only source for his "revelations," and yet you believe him. Therefore, having one source of information should not be a limiting factor for you. So, don't use it as an excuse.
Why is the information of Aisha being married at 6 and sexed at 9 in authentic hadiths? Did anybody who lived when this statement was made say that it was false, and then provided a real age for Aisha?
Or is this apology being done only today because the world as changed, and Muslims need an apology with this action of a so called "perfect human being?"
If I shouldn't believe a person who lived 100 years after Muhammad, then why should I believe any Muslim apologist living today?