this is clearly not about formalism and you know it.
Point of it was the left is losing daily the moral high ground it used to bash the right on. right now it's no longer about "we would never do that", it's "well, our guys are not as bad as their guys". and that is a fall from grace it's hard to recover from.
Morality was just on the ballot and the American people weren’t interested.
Look, I do understand your point. And there are certainly still plenty of things that we/I wouldn’t do or support: harassing election workers, felony schemes to invalidate millions of lawful votes, discrimination of various sorts, re-classifying thousands of federal workers and firing them all—you get the idea.
The sad truth is that our philosophy of “when they go low, we go high” has resulted in nothing but us getting our asses kicked politically for the past 15 years or so.
The result? Our bills have been blocked or torpedoed, we got fucked out of a billion judicial appointees, had a SCOTUS pick stolen, women’s rights are gutted and they’re hurt and dying because they can’t get healthcare they need, LGBTQ people are being silenced and shamed, their resources stripped away or banned from bookshelves, and on and on.
All of this is happening because
Republicans are willing to use extraordinary means to hurt these people, and we haven’t been willing to use extraordinary means to defend them.
I care about defending those people (as well as the middle class and poor in general) a whole lot more than I care about defending Hunter Biden. But I also understand Joe Biden using extraordinary means to protect his son the same way we need to use extraordinary means to protect other people.
Authoritarianism, cruelty, and vengeance is what America just voted for, whether they realize it or not. And adhering to norms and tradition isn’t going to help us in the face of that.
I don’t even know that I buy the idea that we’ll never recover. Republicans posit themselves as having moral high found all the time, and no one gives a shit when they do awful things. Americans care about he economy and not much else, and this election shows that the economy doesn’t even have to be bad for them to make radical choices, you just have to make them believe that it is.