Im starting to think that Tom Aspinall is highly overrated

This is just a frosting cover to your arrogance. You think that anyone who has a differing opinion is dumb or a troll.
Nope. Just you.
This thread has brought out some of the worst posters here on sherdog. You can say I have a bad opinion, I can own that. But when you are so incredulous to believe that a person could have an opposing opinion you relagate it to trolling, it just makes you and some of these other posters look narcissistic.
If you aren't a troll then explain how you say Aspinall is overrated and still unproven against top talent, yet rank Ciryl Gane (who shares Tom's best win in Volkov, albeit a far less impressive performance than Aspinall's) and Renan Ferreira who is a borderline can, above him?

if you aren't a troll then demonstrate some consistent criteria in which to judge these fighters by. If you are going pick through Tom's wins with a fine tooth comb, then do the same for the fighters you rank ahead of him.

Explain your absurd takes like why 50 year old Cheick Kongo better than anybody on Aspinall's record and how to you justify saying he'd be top 10 today if he unretired.

My opinion still stands, You and your kronies here have overrated Tom based on beating tybura, buffalo bills Blaydes, old man Arlovski, exposed pav and volkov.

I still think beating any versions of derrick lewis and JDS absolutely trumps toms list.
It's spelled cronies. You aren't beating those idiot accusations any time soon.

How is Lewis a better win than Pavlovich who absolutely wrecked him? Washed JDS in the midst of a 5 fight losing streak is not a better win than any of Volkov, Pavlovich, Blaydes, or Spivak lmao. You realise that Blaydes beat JDS up and finished him with ease right?

And again. Gane's best win is Volkov, and he went tit for tat with him for 25 minutes. Aspinall went right through him like he didn't belong.

Explain your reasoning instead of just arguing you're allowed a different opinion. Because your opinions are across the board moronic.

Of course, this is futile, because we know you're trolling. Watching you clown yourself repeatedly is quite amusing however.
 
Last edited:
My exact point he ran thru mediocrity. Can you read or are you just argumentative?
The problem though is not just saying that the top 10 is mediocre, (which is an argument to have all on its own) but that it apparently isn't mediocre for Gane. You're explicitly judging their runs under very different microscopes
 
This is just a frosting cover to your arrogance. You think that anyone who has a differing opinion is dumb or a troll. This thread has brought out some of the worst posters here on sherdog. You can say I have a bad opinion, I can own that. But when you are so incredulous to believe that a person could have an opposing opinion you relagate it to trolling, it just makes you and some of these other posters look narcissistic.

My opinion still stands, You and your kronies here have overrated Tom based on beating tybura, buffalo bills Blaydes, old man Arlovski, exposed pav and volkov.

I still think beating any versions of derrick lewis and JDS absolutely trumps toms list.
All of this "differing opinion" shit is YOUR frosting that you can't actually think up troll-y crap to defend yourself because I've explicity shut down those arguments that you spent ONE sentence in this reply recapping without defending. And I've even brought back the "differing opinion" argument to the brass tacks of judging your criteria, so the fact you fell back to repeating "it's my opinion" over and over again without actually defending that opinion and purposefully avoided talking about your criteria means you're not inclined to actually defend your opinion.

Cuz it's a load of bullshit
 
Last edited:
how many GOOD wins at HW does jon have
how many does gane? how many wins against good fighters under 35 does ngannou have?

you can do that with everyone cause HW is a dead division
 
You would have a point if it was describing a one off "fluke" win, somewhat like Conor / Aldo

When a guy is routinely starving everyone in the top 10 in the first round it's because he is so much fucking better than them. That's real skill. He doesn't need 5 rounds to grind them out. He gets them out of there in under 5 minutes due to being vastly more skillful.

Dumb take
He gets them out of there because he has more power, he’s younger and he’s faster. If you pay attention, Aspinall is not defensively responsible at all. Most of the shots he lands, it’s because he has no reason to fear or respect the other person— because he’s confident he’s going to land first. You can say I’m a hater or whatever. But he I’ve watched him not move his head and trade hooks with people on the center line.


Wtf does me saying Tom has a superior ground game to Gane have to do with Jones and Pav other than you being unable to read?

Also could not give 3 fucks less about explaining why they're wrong. Entire fucking thread full of other posters taking care of that quite well.
You said he deserves to be ranked higher because he has a better ground game. Having a better ground game doesn’t necessarily make you a better fighter nor does it mean you should be ranked higher than the actual merit of your wins. You didn’t explain how his actual wins are superior to Gane.
I think Aspinall’s wins are marginally better due to simply having more. But to act like there’s a huge gulf between them is just not true.


Considering that Aspinall is bigger, faster, stronger, a legitimate bjj black belt who hasn't been outgrappled since he was trying to get into boxing, then it's very hard to see Jones as the smaller, weaker guy outgrappling him.
As for your 2nd point, you'd be more impressed if he was to take on a Belal Muhammad point fighting style rather than just walking through guys?
Jones has no option but to go 5 rounds because he has no power. His only way to beat Aspinall is to stay on the outside for 5 rounds and hope he doesn't get caught.
Going into a fight knowing only one guy can finish it is an enormous advantage for that guy.
Good Lord, there’s so much wrong with this post. For starters, what exactly legitimized Tom Aspinall’s black belt for you? Who gave it to him? It was hard for me to see Jones out grappling Cormier. We both know that same Cormier would absolutely ragdoll Aspinall. So if what you’re saying is that Jones skill could have diminished with age at this stage in his career, then you might have a point there.

Oh, one hundred percent without question. What happens if Aspinall doesn’t finish the person in the first round? We don’t even know what he looks like in the second round. I’m past the point where front runners impress me. Anyone can look amazing while going one hundred percent. And if you can get the guy out of there, more power to you. But there’s going to come a time where you fight someone that won’t lay down like that.

I disagree. Jones has more finishes than Aspinall has wins. So statistically, that makes no sense. Jones is confident enough in his skill and stamina that he doesn’t have throw caution to the wind and rush to get them out of there.

1) If you go into a fight with Jones thinking he can’t finish you, you’re crazy.
2) How did that work out for GSPs or Mayweather’s opponents?
 
He gets them out of there because he has more power, he’s younger and he’s faster. If you pay attention, Aspinall is not defensively responsible at all. Most of the shots he lands, it’s because he has no reason to fear or respect the other person— because he’s confident he’s going to land first. You can say I’m a hater or whatever. But he I’ve watched him not move his head and trade hooks with people on the center line.

I do agree with this. Its the one clear weakness hes shown so far. BUT, (specifically referring to the bolded) he did go in there with a fully prime 31 year old Pavlovich who had a ton of momentum going into that fight and who had looked like one of the last people you could afford to stand and trade with.

I think Aspinall’s wins are marginally better due to simply having more. But to act like there’s a huge gulf between them is just not true.

I wouldnt say huge gulf, but theres definitely a clear difference. They have two common opponents and Aspinall handled both more impressively. If you look at the exclusive wins each guy has Pav, Blaydes and Tybura > Rozenstruik, Tai and Lewis, especially considering they present a more mixed stylistic threat. Its easy to shit on Pav now after his downfall but I dont think Gane has beat anyone whos stock was as high as Pavs was when Tom beat him.
 
He gets them out of there because he has more power, he’s younger and he’s faster. If you pay attention, Aspinall is not defensively responsible at all. Most of the shots he lands, it’s because he has no reason to fear or respect the other person— because he’s confident he’s going to land first. You can say I’m a hater or whatever. But he I’ve watched him not move his head and trade hooks with people on the center line.
OK, cool story, but this is the post of yours I replied to:

"First round KO’s don’t really mean anything to me. What I’ve come to realize is that it’s easy to be better than someone for one round. Real skill is being better than someone for five rounds."

I don't care to argue a different point about whether his game is perfect or infallible. Not even Jon, GSP or Fedor at their peak were perfect.

Tom absolutely butt fucking everyone (bar what, one guy) in under 5 minutes is far more impressive than not being able to finish anyone and having to grind out a win through greater endurance or whatever

Tom is exceptionally skilled in this heavyweight era. The fact he blasts out nearly everyone in under a round demonstrates this
 
OK, cool story, but this is the post of yours I replied to:

"First round KO’s don’t really mean anything to me. What I’ve come to realize is that it’s easy to be better than someone for one round. Real skill is being better than someone for five rounds."

I don't care to argue a different point about whether his game is perfect or infallible. Not even Jon, GSP or Fedor at their peak were perfect.

Tom absolutely butt fucking everyone (bar what, one guy) in under 5 minutes is far more impressive than not being able to finish anyone and having to grind out a win through greater endurance or whatever

Tom is exceptionally skilled in this heavyweight era. The fact he blasts out nearly everyone in under a round demonstrates this
I don't mean to hate on him, but just playing devil's advocate about his grappling. We saw Ngannou starch everyone quickly with KO's until he ran into Stipe with actual grappling. Aspinall might be great, but he also could be pretty below with TDD. That's a huge hole in his game.

That said it's clear right now either Aspinall or Jones is on top of HW division rn.
 
I can definitely buy that he's not been "fully tested", not really had to deal with long fights or pressure that much and he has looked "hittable" so the potential for upsets maybe there,

Skill wise though I think he's clearly a level above anyone else we've seen break though at HW in recent years, probably since Francis first appeared.
 
His combination of extreme agility, speed, punching power, ability on the ground (his dad is a long time BJJ coach) makes him the outstanding prospect to be a long standing HW Champion.

No one else I can see right now is on his level, Jones excepted, but he's basically taking the piss at this point.

His record so far shows you that the most likely outcome is a KO win in the first or second round. It's not even just that, it's the ease at which he does it. Quite simply, it's absurd.
 
Last edited:
As we know every fighter is overrated and a hype train. When are we gonna learn?
 
"Pavlo was exposed" maybe he had a bad day, injury, bad training camp? who knows?

Man City lost to Brighton so now this mean they suck right?
In reality they will most likely win PL and CL

People are so stupid xD
 
Why? Gane has beaten better fighters lol.
Who?
Volkov, Spivac, Lewis and Tai. Since his title shot he has fought Tai and Spivac.

Tom has Volov, Spivac, Blaydes and Pav, all by first round finish with a defence of his interim title thrown in.

The guy needs to fight Jones or if Jones doesn't want it, strip him and Tom can be the undisputed champ.
 
Back
Top