Technically speaking, GSP is the most complete fighter, imho.
This. Nice try TS, but, GSP has already won poll after poll asking this same question
"Who is the most complete fighter/champion in MMA?". Need proof? It's right here on Sherdog courtesy of MicroPoll.com.
That said, let's bring up some obvious weaknesses for Jones and his competition as well.
- Jones has shown no actual KO power in his standup. Not even his helicopter spinning elbows have knocked anybody out on the feet, nor have his kicks, punches or knees.
- Jones has questionable BJJ defense (suspect BJJ defense). Please see the Vitor Belfort fight. We was in trouble more than once in that fight and nearly had his arm broken (bicep damage was sustained and his arm was popped, Vitor let go thinking it was over).
- Jones' boxing game, honestly, is horrible. He doesn't put together/string together punches well at all and the concept of boxing and combination punching to him are still very new. He's also yet to really demonstrate that he can even have decent boxing for MMA. That punch he dropped Machida with looked terrible and the angle he landed it at, the position of his body (head turned away), is absolutely a technical textbook failure of technique. He countered Machida's very predictable left straight with a right hand (which, again, was horrible technique that left him open badly). His angles aren't too good either, he can't cut them too well because his lack of footwork limits this (already covered his footwork above).
- Jones' movement is awkward and his footwork is almost non-existent. He's pretty flat-footed, again, unlike GSP.
- Jones' chin hasn't been tested enough yet. Tonight, Gustafsson will certainly test it. Let's see if he has a good beard on him.
- Jones' striking defense leaves A LOT to be desired. He more or less completely relies on his huge 85" wingspan (and the reach that comes from having this) to always strike at a distance and control the range. When this is negated (like Lyoto was successful at doing in the 1st round), Jones' striking defense is downright awful. He was running away from Machida and getting punched while looking awkward as hell.
Against Rampage, when Rampage went in for the kill and threw big hooks at him, he ran faster than Forrest Gump.
Ever seen Tito vs. Wand for the vacant UFC LHW belt (back in Japan) many years back? Tito ran from Wanderlei's punches much like Jones was against Rampage. Both had no answer (that answer being good striking defense and/or counters). :icon_idea
- Jones hasn't fought anybody very skilled AND his size yet (which will change tonight). We'll see within just a few hours how he does against a big, dangerous striker that's very skilled in Gustafsson.
- Not only has Jones had a ton of size over all of his opponents since fighting for the LHW belt and defending it, he's also been fighting all of these former champions that have been on the decline and/or are far out of their primes (or MW's like Chael and Vitor that don't belong at LHW in the UFC today). When GSP was fighting the best guys in the world, and he still is, he was fighting them in their absolute primes, unlike Jones.
The most well-rounded fighter in the world is St-Pierre. He has no weaknesses and not finishing in years isn't a defensive weakness/hole. St-Pierre has the most guard passes in the UFC, he has the most takedowns landed, the highest takedown accuracy, the best double-leg takedown in the sport, and the most significant strikes landed (not to mention the longest reigning champion currently in the UFC still, most title defenses etc). Jones may only need very few significant strikes to finish a fight but he won't be able to finish everybody so efficiently once he starts fighting guys that can take it and/or avoid it, bigger guys for example.