- Joined
- Mar 4, 2013
- Messages
- 6,519
- Reaction score
- 4,325
Most GOAT candidates have problems with their case:
- Losses
- Steroid violations (Jones)
- Weak strength of schedule / fighting cans (Fedor, Jones)
- Not enough title defenses (DC. Khabib)
- Point fighting (GSP)
- Squeaking by with wins / close victories (GSP)
- Rapid decline in career in older age (Silva, Fedor)
- Retired too early (Khabib)
Kamarudeen so far has none of these issues.
Okay, first thing first, GSP and Fedor are my co-GOATs (GSP because of the quality of his opposition, and the fact that he's avenged both his losses; one of them, twice)
BUT as I've been saying for a long time, Usman could become a consensus top 3 GOAT if he defends a few more times.
I actually like Kamaru, him taking the belt from Woodley in such a dominating fashion was fantastic... I wouldn't be mad if he surpassed GSP as the consensus UFC GOAT.
But he does has issues, contrary to what you stated:
He never avenged his loss to "the Fresh Prince of Kendall" , Jose "Know Way" Caceres, (brother of the legendary Bruce Leeroy)

Avenging losses is extremely important; even before Anderson screwed himself over being a GOAT candidate by finally getting caught red handed juicing, there was criticism over him not being willing to rematch those who had beaten him before PRIDE and in it
(he was 28 and 29 when he got tapped out by Takase and Chonan, and was one of Chute Boxe's top guys, he was in his prime despite what AS nuthuggers might say; these guys even like to pretend that he wasn't juiced up before the UFC )
If he gets past Khamzat, the division is pretty clear. He could easily string together 4 more defenses.
At that point he's the GOAT, undisputed.
Israel Adesanya was shaping up to be a GOAT, but then he kinda got son'd by a subpar LHW champ, which kind of sullies his case.
I love Usman, and I dislike Adesanya, so I was glad he lost and that Kamaru was bumped in the P4P rankings, but Isreal didn't get "son'd" by any mean.
He lost a pretty close decision, and he lost, no way around it, but it was still a relatively close fight in which Adesanya won 2 rounds.
He beat Colby, twice. That alone is a huge accomplishment. That's like Jones beating DC, or Fedor beat Cro Cop.