All Time GOAT poll

[Future GOAT]

Fedor, then GSP.

Easily.

 

[I WILL CUT YOU]

proof or gtfo.

https://forums.sherdog.com/threads/mma-boxing-legends-say-fedor-is-the-greatest.3343361/

Here is a start, but honestly are you going to change your mind?

No, you're not. I mean, the whole country of Brazil voted him GOAT over Anderson which crushes your poll, but again, nothing will change your mind.

And that's ok, because GOAT is subjective and personal.

 

[ThunderStruck]

He signed to fight Barnett in Affliction... But Barnett popped for Steroids.

The premise that Fedor fought the best HWs of his era is totally right.

No its not.

 

[ThunderStruck]

Enjoy.

Way to let out plenty of top HWs buddy.

 

[Sinthesized]

Cormier should be an option for sure. He's my overall pick. Never lost to a clean fighter, started his career SUPER late, and always fought with a size disadvantage

 

[Peteyandjia]

 

[BA0701]

Just imagine if Mighty Mouse weighed 155 or 170 pounds

In all honesty, I would have voted for MM, had he not ducked TJ, and actually TJ, IMO, was a winnable fight for him. The GOAT don't DUCK, so DJ did not get my vote.

 

[BA0701]

Another make believe thread.

The MMA GOAT can only be a HW champ.

This is not boxing. Boxing takes more skill so it makes sense to compare skills between weight classes.

This is fighting fighting.

The GOAT is 100% Fedor. And after Fedor it's not GSP or Anderson, it's someone like Big Nog, or Werdum or Cain.

GSP is the WW GOAT without a question. MM is the flyweight GOAT, Aldo is the FW GOAT, LW, MW and LHW are up for grabs, although DC is probably the LHW GOAT, and a strong contender at HW too.

Anderson and Jones just the GOAT cheaters, and that's not a cute nickname, they are the actual GOAT cheaters. Anderson is only second to Jones, and Jones is second to none.

I dunno, I believe Anderson was juicing his entire career, which eliminates all of his accomplishments, imo. So given that train of thought, do you still believe Jones is the GOAT cheater over AS?

 

[danny23]

He had fixed fights against cans, fought mostly part time taxi drivers and kept falling when it got tough for him.
So no.

 

[Peteyandjia]

He had fixed fights against cans, fought mostly part time taxi drivers and kept falling when it got tough for him.
So no.

 

[Magnum1978]

Fedor in the ring under full pride rules, soccer kicks, stomps, etc...(more 'NHB')
GSP in the cage using unified rules, he mastered that environment (more 'sport')

1a/1b for me

 

[Make Sherdog Great Again]

So that's like what, 4 people?



https://www.mmafighting.com/2018/7/...-does-daniel-cormier-stand-in-the-goat-debate
Gsp:4216 votes
Cormier: 2214 votes.

Fedor: 693 votes.

Fedor got the same amount of votes as mighty mouse... lol

 

[Bouboumaster]

At least the two best are 1-2 in the poll.

That I agree with

 

[Bouboumaster]

Chael Sonnen fought Anderson Silva, Jon Jones, Fedor and trained with GSP, and he called GSP the GOAT.

The Bad Guy is right.

 

[cakemuncher]

Others may have more legacy, but Jones beats them all in the cage.

 

[Made of Steel]

Jon Jones is undisputed GOAT.

 

[Barteh]

Cormier should be an option for sure. He's my overall pick. Never lost to a clean fighter, started his career SUPER late, and always fought with a size disadvantage

He almost never fought with a size disadvantage. He basically had a size advantage in most of his LHW fights including the two against his biggest rival who made him cry twice. He outweighed all those opponents.

 

[r-harper-1]

to the gills. and I say that as a huge vitor & mirko fan

Mirko and Vitor are hard not to like

 

[BrazilPitbullUS]

Aldo without a doubt..

 

[bootsy]

Others may have more legacy, but Jones beats them all in the cage.k

Did so many illicit substances that they may never leave his system.