All Time GOAT poll

[Rudeboyben84]

Fedor is like a lot of people's first love. Remember more with feelings than facts.

Prime Brock would have been a handful for anyone. It is unfortunate he had health problems.

GSP probably has the most timeless style or lack of style. He was extremely well rounded.

Fedor has crazy hand speed and accuracy. Brock didn’t cope well with being hit on the feet. I could see prime vs prime Fedor unleashing a combo and Brock turtling up. Prime vs prime Fedor has to be favorite. Also I voted Fedor but honestly after some thought he’s 3rd begind Jones and GSP. I’d still rank him over Anderson though.

 

[Alphakennybody20]

When did all this talk of GSP being the GOAT begin to catch fire.

If you consider GSP the GOAT at what moment do you believe he took the title of "Greatest MMA fighter of all time"?

Edit: I don't think he's the goat personally

 

[MyFavSport]

What the Fuck???

Who gives a damn???

 

[chinarice]

When he made his MMA debut.

He's always been the GOAT

 

[DS7]

The 170 GOAT u mean? probably when he broke Hughes defense record.

 

[Alphakennybody20]

What the Fuck???

Who gives a damn???

I care

 

[Blanqa Blanqua]

 

[TheAmericanGazelle]

If he's the GOAT, it isn't by much and probably ebbed and flowed in-and-out among the top spots while he was fighting.

 

[JustOnce]

When did all this talk of GSP being the GOAT begin to catch fire.

If you consider GSP the GOAT at what moment do you believe he took the title of "Greatest MMA fighter of all time"?

Edit: I don't think he's the goat personally

Trick question, cuz he never did.

 

[Alphakennybody20]

If he's the GOAT, it isn't by much and probably ebbed and flowed in-and-out among the top spots while he was fighting.

I don't ever think he came close to grabbing the title at any point in his career though.

 

[accolyte1022]

This should be entertaining.

 

[chinarice]

I don't ever think he came close to grabbing the title at any point in his career though.

You're entitled to your incorrect opinion, sir. Carry on.

 

[Ares Black]

When Anderson Silva popped for steroids.

 

[Alphakennybody20]

You're entitled to your incorrect opinion, sir. Carry on.

Your first response to the thread brought nothing to the table so nize up.

 

[chinarice]

When Anderson Silva popped for steroids.

That just means he always was and it just took some longer than others to find out.

Others are still living in Fantasy Land.

 

[accolyte1022]

When Anderson Silva popped for steroids.

He was 137 and had four broken bones, cut the guy some slack.


Also, dick pills.

 

[Ares Black]

That just means he always was and it just took some longer than others to find out.

Others are still living in Fantasy Land.

Exactly

 

[chinarice]

Your first response to the thread brought nothing to the table so nize up.

The first reply on this thread /threaded your thread. No further responses are required.

GOAT St Pierre bless.

 

[SecondToNone]

Around the time he beat Bisping. At this point Jones and Silva had both popped for steroids, with Silva also losing a bunch of fights, Fedor had gone on the three fight losing streak and the farce vs Maldonado, Aldo had been KO by Conor, DJ had yet to beat anyone with a real resume, and anyone else didn't have a record as good as GSP.

In short, everyone else continued to not be good enough, or made fools of themselves. GSP didn't, choked out Ping, and was declared GOAT.

 

[BFoe]

When our universe split into a parallel universe where Fedor was never born.