All 3 judges scores , round by round for JJ v Gus

[DCarf]

Round 1 Gus
Round 2 Jones
Round 3 Gus
Round 4 Draw
Round 5 Jones

DRAW.

That was my scoring although I am not a judge.

 

[ipsc shooter]

I thought Gustafsson won the first three rounds, Jones won the fourth round, and the fifth round was close, but I could have seen it going to Jones. I think Gustafsson should get an immediate rematch.

 

[PurpleDrank]

Someone please tell me how the hell Jones won round 2? Honestly I can't see it.

 

[jackietreehorn8]

5 close ass rounds, 3 judges...that's 15 opportunities for a 10-10, but not a single one was given. Judges hate 10-10 rounds more than anything in the world.

 

[MartyMcFry]

What fight was Lee watching?

He's a Bones fan.

 

[Hans Gercmiov]

The other two judges split rounds 2-3. The only definitive rounds were 1 for GUS and 4 and 5 for Jones. Which I think is an accurate take on the fight. 2 and 3 were really close.

I wouldn't call round 4 definitive for Jones. He landed an elbow.

 

[Momanjabo]

Wonder what Chris Lee was doing during the fight

 

[SODACKER]

What fight was Lee watching?

If you disagree with Lee you must also disagree with Crosby or Bertrand.

This isn't basketball where more points mean more of a blow out.

 

[Winston Wolf]

Yeah I had it the same as Bertrand.

Gus
Jones
Gus
Jones
Jones

Dat spinning elbow.

 

[kpxl1023]

Judge Bertrand knows what's up

 

[MixMartialFarts]

surprised only 1 judge gave Gus the 2nd.

 

[Lappish Shaman]

To be close to finish should be the most important factor, not number of punches

 

[Jonny Bones]

After watching the fight again I think all these scores are feasible. 2 and 3 were razor close and Jon really poured it on at the end of the round making it super difficult to score.

 

[BrainLeakage]

To be close to finish should be the most important factor, not number of punches

Close to a finish: subjective
Number of punches: objective

 

[SeattleFightFan]

All three judges scored the fight differently - puts it into perspective.

well, to be specific, all judges scored 2 rounds differently. and all 3 scored 3 rounds exactly alike.

99% of sherdoggers seem to agree with 2 of those 3 rounds (1&5).

 

[TrailerParkBoy]

Wonder what Chris Lee was doing during the fight

playing with his new toy

 

[Hallzzz]

Gus had his chances to win. He gassed and couldn't win the last 2 rounds

 

[rjmbrd]

well, to be specific, all judges scored 2 rounds differently. and all 3 scored 3 rounds exactly alike.

99% of sherdoggers seem to agree with 2 of those 3 rounds (1&5).

2 of 5 rounds == 40% of the entire fight. It's a big index of incompatibility relatively speaking.

Rounds 1 and 5 everyone seems to agree on. It's those pesky rounds in between where all the controversy bubbled up ; ))

 

[mchestnut]

So what qualifications do these judges need to have to do this job and how much MMA experience do they need to watch in order to judge accurately.

3 judges, all scored differently and only Bertrand scored it right?

 

[Magjee]

Summary:

R1 Gus
R2 ???
R3 ???
R4 Jones
R5 Jones

The judges agreed on that.

Need more 10-10 and 10-8's out of judges.

It still annoys me all three judges scored R1 Lesnar / Carwin 10-9 for Carwin, WTF.