You're completely forgetting that a huge factor in how hard a person hits is how solid the structure and foundation behind the punch is. Two things that make that structure more solid are technique and thick bones. So assuming a smaller guy and bigger guy both have the same level of technique, the bigger guy has mass AND bone structure over the smaller guy who only has speed.
Saying technique won't get you far is really hard to argue with. That's just plain wrong. I'd love to know where you got that technique is only 20% of speed. I'd be willing to bet if you had two groups of people and had one group do only speed exercises while the other group only practiced punching technique, the technique group would improve both speed and power at a much higher rate than the speed exercise group. And for the record, when measuring punching power, speed isn't how many punches you can do in half a second. It's how fast the fist is traveling at the moment of impact. Besides, no matter how high that velocity is, it's worthless without the proper balance and alignment of the body that comes from technique.
The bigger guy doesn't need to do some ridiculous amount of speed exercises to be able to punch as hard as a smaller guy. His punches are going to have more weight and, more importantly, a more rigid structure supporting the transfer of force.
And by the way, you shouldn't need to say "I know this more than anyone here". If that was true, the knowledge contained in your post would be proof enough.
I am comparing someone who is in the same ratio of weight, eg a 2m guy who is 150kg and a 5'7 guy at 95kg
If they are the same ratio they can be compared, if the person is not the ratio, then even if he has more speed, he wont be a harder puncher, however my punches are harder than most heavyweights in our gym because they don't do enough speed exercises and only hitting the heavybag..
What you don't understand is that your limited with technique, you have to get faster than your own technique by adding speed weighted exercises in punching, parachute runs, etc. This will surpass any technique. Do you really think mike Tyson did none of this, he used weighted vests uphill, he did do weights and neck shrugs even though he didn't claim it, anyone in the heavyweight will because to train 5 days a week means youll lose your weight no matter how much cals you intake.
He did speed exercises and wouldnt punch anywhere near his level if he didn't do them.
True, more bone is better for protection, but it doesn't do much in terms of punch damage. We have tested that and what you've got to understand is I have guys with small frames and small bones that can punch as hard as mike did. They can ko in the first round against a guy who is 60 pounds heavier, and that has nothing to do with being naturally gifted. It isn't proven and is false. bigger hands are actually weaker in damage and its been tested. The area is spread more and the push force is big but the damage isn't.
Taller guys and very heavy guys will always have slower hard punches in comparison to a guy who is the same weight ratio, not at their weight exactly, but has more speed.
If the weight ratio isn't even, the heavier guy will win, but if they are even, and the one lighter can punch faster. He will ko the heavier guy because his punches will be like mike Tysons.