No one would pick Renan over a prime Stipe. But you're a fucking retard if you think he's in his prime now.
I like Stipe, but he's a lamb being led to the slaughter... this fight is just a bad joke to take away from Stipe's legacy to prop up Jon's. I am happy that Stipe is at least getting a big bag of cash for this, and there would not be a single person opposed to this fight, myself included, if there wasn't some phony belt attached to it... but the way it stands now, it just makes the title look worthless, and makes Jon look like a bitch for not fighting the legitimate contender.