Which GOAT win was the best between these 2?

Whos win was better?

  • Total voters
    333
ThunderStruck said:
Yeah right first account :rolleyes:
Click to expand...

Lets do an imagination exercize.

Imagine i'm telling the truth and this is really my first account.

How the fuck do you think you look?

Yep, like a fucking weirdo.

You should be ashamed of being like that.I could prove you by speaking other languages but i don't like playing games with retards.

Keep on with the lies, fatty.I think you cry everynight screaming on your pillow "WHYYYY GEORGE? WHY DIDNT YOU GET MORE FINISHES?"
Then you wake up and you come here to post that shit.
 
killakillakilla said:
and you claiming that the gsp/Fitch fight was so entertaining for you lol. That’s a lie unless you are a fan of super boring fights.
Click to expand...

This post got me curious and I googled.

GSP/Fitch won FotN over J-Mac/Maia... wtf.

We need a thread for this.
 
SKITZADACTYL said:
fitch, as much as i love okami he came into that fight terrified already. okami was on a 3 fight streak and fitch was on a 16 fight streak.


GSP GOAT.
Click to expand...

Okami started the fight fully focused, following his game plan and even was in his route to edge the 1st round.
It was a solid lead head kick with 10 seconds left he didnt saw coming what missed with his confidence and turned him hesitant of opening up in the slighest.

Anderson was making Yushin look real bad, in the same over hesitant mode, in their first encounter back in 2006, and that was in Hawai not in front of Brazilian audience. Do you think it's coincidence?

One the one hand, we had seen Okami taking shots from power punchers just fine many times before; on the other hand we saw that same fear reaction in plenty of Silva's opponents after realizing they could take a solid accurate shot without see it coming from almost any direction with any limb.

Only GSP fanboys in sherbro take the credit away from Silva in such phenomenon and instead use it to downplay his competition and performances. But dont make mistake mate, fellow fighters and the mma community credited Silva for that and knew about this special talent of him.
 
interesting, because fitch was unbeatable, but I think a lot of people had GSP going into that fight. Okami had no chance from what I recall and at the time, nearly impossible to finish, both expected outcomes.

I think I give it a tie because fitch was a slightly higher level guy, while okami was actually finished.
 
bjpenngoat said:
Here we go time to myth bust...

Dan hardy
Serra
Koscheck X2
Alves
Condit
Almost 40 hughes
Lw bj penn

This is not an elite schedule for a ww champ. Its one of the weakest assorment of pedestrian and averags fighters aside from two legends one almost 40 ajd the other out of weight class.
Click to expand...
quit rewriting history, all those fighters had a moment of greatness
 
Beating Fitch at the time was a GOAT win...Okami was a pretty forgettable win, just a typical title defense.... not even comparable. I probably even take Alves as a bigger win than the Okami win, he was considered a killer at the time.
 
def fitch. fitch and royce had the win streak record in the ufc, which was 8 in a row i believe, until other guys came around and broke it. fitch was the #2 welterweight and was entrenched in that spot for 5 years pretty much.
 
bjpenngoat said:
Here we go time to myth bust...

Dan hardy
Serra
Koscheck X2
Alves
Condit
Almost 40 hughes
Lw bj penn

This is not an elite schedule for a ww champ. Its one of the weakest assorment of pedestrian and averags fighters aside from two legends one almost 40 ajd the other out of weight class.
Click to expand...
Lmao, this man retarded.
 
gono btw said:
ITT, you´ve already admitted that Okami didnt really loose vs Shields... So which one is it?
Click to expand...

I think it was a draw. How did you score it?

You know you're reaching when you praise a fighter for his draws and UD losses (Franklin). That is what Pankrat is doing.
 
chardog said:
interesting, because fitch was unbeatable, but I think a lot of people had GSP going into that fight. Okami had no chance from what I recall and at the time, nearly impossible to finish, both expected outcomes.

I think I give it a tie because fitch was a slightly higher level guy, while okami was actually finished.
Click to expand...

Fitch was unbeatable? The streak he was riding included a split with and undersized Sanchez and a gross robbery vs Jeff Joslin which should be an L. No other top5 wins in that run other than Sanchez.
Fitch was definitely a legitimate contender but unbeatable?
Was Okami more beatable riding a 20-3 run in which he was barely been seen in trouble at any point not even in extremey competitive fights with top5ers Franklin, Shields (at WW) and Marquardt?

Fitch would not be favoured at that point - and if that not by much - vs Okami at 170 let alone at 185.
Even if you want to argue Fitch was the slightly superior fighter, there is no way you can claim he was in a different league than Okami to the point it justifies claimng a decision is a superior performance than actually finishing your opponent after outclassing him in a flawles performance.

If Okami looked as he had no chance of surviving 25 minuts with Silva is a testament of Anderson's greatness, not an excuse to downplay his opponent/performance.
 
pankrat said:
Fitch was unbeatable? The streak he was riding included a split with and undersized Sanchez and a gross robbery vs Jeff Joslin which should be an L. No other top5 wins in that run other than Sanchez.
Fitch was definitely a legitimate contender but unbeatable?
Was Okami more beatable riding a 20-3 run in which he was barely been seen in trouble at any point not even in extremey competitive fights with top5ers Franklin, Shields (at WW) and Marquardt?

Fitch would not be favoured at that point - and if that not by much - vs Okami at 170 let alone at 185.
Even if you want to argue Fitch was the slightly superior fighter, there is no way you can claim he was in a different league than Okami to the point it justifies claimng a decision is a superior performance than actually finishing your opponent after outclassing him in a flawles performance.

If Okami looked as he had no chance of surviving 25 minuts with Silva is a testament of Anderson's greatness, not an excuse to downplay his opponent/performance.
Click to expand...

Fitch beat Okami while being 3 years older. Not sure what you're trying to argue there but that doesn't look good for you.
 
ThunderStruck said:
I think it was a draw. How did you score it?

You know you're reaching when you praise a fighter for his draws and UD losses (Franklin). That is what Pankrat is doing.
Click to expand...

Who looked to you as the superior fighter and who would you favour in a inmediate rematch?

I give ton of credit for Fitch for his fight with BJ. I would even if it was scored a SD for BJ or a UD I dont give a fuck, I have eyes, brain and criteria which I dont expect from a fight-finder-rat fansissy to cultivate or even care about.
 
I don't think finishes always indicate superior opponent mastery to non-finishes.

Sometimes clinical shutout domination for 25 minutes is more indicative of mastery than a finish.

It doesn't apply in this case because Silva/Okami 2 was extremely one-sided as well, but I would choose a good number of "destructive damage-ladden shutouts" over a meaningful number of finishes, especially if the finish took place in a reasonably competitive fight.
 
TheAmericanGazelle said:
I don't think finishes always indicate superior opponent mastery to non-finishes.

Sometimes clinical shutout domination for 25 minutes is more indicative of mastery than a finish.

It doesn't apply in this case because Silva/Okami 2 was extremely one-sided as well, but I would choose a good number of "destructive damage-ladden shutouts" over a meaningful number of finishes, especially if the finish took place in a reasonably competitive fight.
Click to expand...
Who was more dominant....GSP over Fitch or Silva over Sonnen? (in the first fight lol). Not that I want to turn this into a Silva vs GSP war because that's not what this thread is supposed to be about.

Finishing fights is overrated by the just bleeders. I love watching a good finish don't get me wrong but the win is the most important thing for your legacy.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,281,039
Messages
58,336,987
Members
176,003
Latest member
HeneryH

Share this page

Back
Top