Where do you rank Mir and Lesnar amongst Heavyweights?

Trabaho said:
He fought Derick becausw they offered him a huge sum of money to save a card while he qas injured. Derick is a easy fught for him

HW is harder than LHW.

Prime JDS Reem ect.

Well similar LHW had Gus Jones Rumble.

What was he supposed to do. Fight Cain ? Even that fight is hard. But they are friends. Close friends.
Click to expand...
You just listed a bunch of guys he could have fought. JDS, Overeem, Werdum were all options. He dropped to LHW without facing any of the top guys.
 
Kyojiro Kagenuma said:
It's literally the other way around. Brock has no striking and AA has some of the best takedown defense in the heavyweight division. Andrei would smoke him.
Click to expand...
You are underestimating Brock. It is tighter than you are making it out to be. Prime Arlovski struggled with retro fighters like Sylvia that would have not been able to handle the caliber of fighters that Brock did for sure.
 
markg171 said:
DC top 3 HW of all time???

For beating Monson, Bigfoot, Barnett, Mir, Nelson, Stipe, and Lewis???

<36>
Click to expand...
DC beat all those guys when they were at their peak or at least very close to it. Not only did he beat them, he beat them all convincingly, usually by finish.
 
NoSmilez said:
Mir should be ranked higher than Nog or at least the same.

Lesnar is ranked lower even though he can beat both men.
Click to expand...
I'm not so sure Lesnar would win over a prime Big Nog. Big Nog was able to beat a prime Bob Sapp that was 350lbs and juiced out of his mind.
 
filthybliss said:
You are underestimating Brock. It is tighter than you are making it out to be. Prime Arlovski struggled with retro fighters like Sylvia that would have not been able to handle the caliber of fighters that Brock did for sure.
Click to expand...
What, you mean like Frank Mir? Lol no I'm not. Arlovski could have beaten anyone Brock beat, and he coukd have lost to them too, but against Brock? No.

Arlovski was way better than Brock.
 
JKS said:
LOL, how? Big Nog had such a stronger career overall. It’s not really comparable.

The only argument is he beat him 2x which doesn’t even hold up cause there is more to it than head to head. We gonna place Hellman over Hughes? Or Bigfoot over Fedor?
Click to expand...
The head to head match up doesn't hold up well when the rest of the resume isn't up to par. Bad matchups exist, plain and simple.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JKS
filthybliss said:
He beat champions for the belt so he made it to the top, you make it sound like he just got the belt for stepping into the cage and not rag dolling the scariest men on the planet. He was fast tracked but he still beat prestigious comp.
Click to expand...
He didn't make it to the top, he was brought in and inserted at the top.
 
Kyojiro Kagenuma said:
What, you mean like Frank Mir? Lol no I'm not. Arlovski could have beaten anyone Brock beat, and he coukd have lost to them too, but against Brock? No.

Arlovski was way better than Brock.
Click to expand...
He is way better than Brock but you don't think he could of achieved the same success as Brock in his position. That sounds contradictory, no?
 
filthybliss said:
He beat champions for the belt so he made it to the top, you make it sound like he just got the belt for stepping into the cage and not rag dolling the scariest men on the planet. He was fast tracked but he still beat prestigious comp.
Click to expand...
Lol just stop. He got a title shot with a 1-1 record. That's completely ludicrous and wouldn't have happened for anyone else in the sport. He got Dana White privilege via being a famous WWE guy.

Had he been forced to work his way up and earn a title shot the normal way he probably would have run into someone like Cain, JDS, or Werdum before ever getting to the title.
 
blaseblase said:
Lol just stop. He got a title shot with a 1-1 record. That's completely ludicrous and wouldn't have happened for anyone else in the sport. He got Dana White privilege via being a famous WWE guy.

Had he been forced to work his way up and earn a title shot the normal way he probably would have run into someone like Cain, JDS, or Werdum before ever getting to the title.
Click to expand...
did he or did he not beat belt holders for the belt?
 
filthybliss said:
He is way better than Brock but you don't think he could of achieved the same success as Brock in his position. That sounds contradictory, no?
Click to expand...
Brock beat Heath Herring, Randy Couture, Shane Carwin, and Frank Mir. He also lost to Frank Mir.

All of those guys are retro, and Sylvia was on the same or similar level as most of them. You're seriously overestimating Brocks resume.
 
Kyojiro Kagenuma said:
Brock beat Heath Herring, Randy Couture, Shane Carwin, and Frank Mir. He also lost to Frank Mir.

All of those guys are retro, and Sylvia was on the same or similar level as most of them. You're seriously overestimating Brocks resume.
Click to expand...
Resume, Arlovski wins. I can get with that sentiment. Prime for Prime is a different story and it is certainly not one-sided.
 
JKS said:
JDS is a no question top 5 HW in my opinion in the rankings. You got Fedor, Stipe, Big Nog as a pretty solid top 3. And then I would have Werdum and JDS.
Click to expand...
People overlook JDS because of the Cain fights. What they fail to remember is that he still has the best run up to the HW title. The guy made his debut against Werdum ffs and never had a freebie win or softball match up in the UFC.
 
Kyojiro Kagenuma said:
It's literally the other way around. Brock has no striking and AA has some of the best takedown defense in the heavyweight division. Andrei would smoke him.
Click to expand...
AA TD isn’t good enough to top Brock takedowns and his GNP. I also invision Alrovski having some trouble getting back on his feet with Brock on top of him he does not have wrestling credentials of Randy Couture or Cain for that matter to keep fight standing for very long. I’m a huge fan of AA but his glass chin wouldn’t be good against Brock.This fight would go like Mark Hunt or Heath Herring a massive beat down stylistic matchup nightmare for AA here.
 
Chillez said:
AA TD isn’t good enough to top Brock takedowns and his GNP. I also invision Alrovski having some trouble getting back on his feet with Brock on top of him he does not have wrestling credentials of Randy Couture or Cain for that matter to keep fight standing. I’m a huge fan of AA but his glass chin wouldn’t be good against Brock.This fight would go like Mark Hunt or Heath Herring a massive beat down stylistic matchup nightmare for AA here.
Click to expand...
Yes, it is. His takedown defense was like 90 something percent. Brock stands up to punishment even worse than AA, dude. He would crumble.

You're way off on this.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,282,999
Messages
58,475,517
Members
176,048
Latest member
gibberish

Share this page

Back
Top