Well, I've wrapped up playing a game that needs no introduction, Cyberpunk 2077 and the DLC Phantom Liberty.
I'm really torn on this one; I sunk a lot of hours in it and feel like I definitely got my money's worth, but there just seems to be a myriad of reasons that prevent me from calling it a great game. It feels to me Phantom Liberty portion is superior in terms of mission design, having decent bosses, and pace.
The good stuff:
+ Phenomenal graphics
+ Night City setting is great, so much attention to detail and care (although not very interactive)
+ Good variety of play styles in terms of melee, net running, stealth, shooting etc
+ Good weapon variety
+ Net running really adds a LOT of uniqueness to the FPS open world genre
+ Good upgrading system
+ Fist fighting missions are fun
The bad stuff:
- Most side stuff like the countless NCPD mini missions feel soulless; would prefer to cut the amount available in half and focus on meaningful side missions
- The countless little reading bits from picking up data disks is annoying. I feel like Horizon Zero Dawn started this and it needs to die
- Hacking mini game becomes boring and rewards get stale
- Quite easy for your character to become really overpowered and beat everything without any strategy
- Uninteresting characters, as character building doesn't work very well, cast is too big versus the depth of caring about anyone
- Up until the very end it feels like most "choices" you make don't impact much of anything
- Driving control is mediocre at best
- Johnny Silverhand gets pretty annoying and overbearing
- Romance options feel half baked, as does buying homes
I feel like Phantom Liberty is very good, maybe a 8.5 / 10, whereas the base game is maybe a 6.5 / 10. (with 5/10 being deemed average). Largely because of its amazing technical aspects. To be honest, towards the very end I started to get bored and mentally checked out of the game, though exploring its many ending was kinda interesting.