Star Wars Discussion: Obi-Wan vs. Mace Windu

this is a no brainer. mace windu would wipe the floor with obi. Round 1 2:30 KO

mace rivaled master yoda. obi got owned twice by dooky head
 
lol at people thinking Mace would win easily.

Obi Wan would expose that can.
 
Obi Wan would wax that ass. Mace sat on his ass the majority of the movies. Obi Wan was running shit all over the galaxy.
 
Scott Lawlor said:
I always assumed after, I haven't re-watched the movies in some time so I can't recall if he would have known Anakin was going to be arriving.
Click to expand...

He knew he was. Right before Mace and co. showed up he was talking to Anakin via the Force

Yompton said:
It's hard to say. He potentially could have sensed Anakins arrival. At the same time, he had no reserves about immediately attacking Windu and killing his posse. You could make a case that he needed it to be one on one for Anakin to get the shot off. You could also make the case that Taking down Windu at all costs is a major victory, and there was no guarantee that Anakin would have saved him. He took a leap of faith on Anakin, and physically paid for it. All I know for sure is I personally could have written a better trilogy then Lucas
Click to expand...

I was under the impression Palpatine could sense the future in the prequels. The Dark Side was more powerful at the time.

Fat Abbot said:
Question for ppl who think Palps sensed anakin coming, which I agree with. Why couldnt he sense Luke on Endor?

He was one of the most powerful force users ever, he should have been able to sense someone as strong in the force as luke. I think Vaders connection to the force finally overtook his masters as sideous fortold in Revenge of the Sith and that's why he was able to sense it and not palps.
Click to expand...
Palpatine knew he was there. Vader told him a small group had landed and Palpatine says "yes I know" then orders Vader to capture him.
 
I dont really think mace owned Palpatine. Palpatine held back some because he wanted to test anikan to see if he was going to join him.
 
I have to say Windu by whatever he wants.

But people need to realise the Emperor let Windu win on purpose to appear weak and defenseless so Anakin would help and kill Windu thus turning to the dark side.

Sidious tools 4 masters and loses to Mace Windu one on one? No way, he's the emperor.
 
Well with all due respect Obi-Wan did lose to Vader again later on in life and Mace DID beat the Emperor whose probably one of the most powerful Sith ever. Although his sabre skills are very meh.

I still think Obi takes this. He's better with the force, is younger, quicker and he did beat 2 Sith in their prime.

I feel like such a fuckin' nerd now ha ha...
 
KingOfAllWar said:
I have to say Windu by whatever he wants.

But people need to realise the Emperor let Windu win on purpose to appear weak and defenseless so Anakin would help and kill Windu thus turning to the dark side.

Sidious tools 4 masters and loses to Mace Windu one on one? No way, he's the emperor.
Click to expand...

Ya cause Kit Fisto and those 2 other scrubs are "Masters" lol... They were barely out of their Jedi diapers. Sidious is still a badass though. Definitely held his own vs. Yoda.
 
progressmusic said:
got to remember mace had the emperor beat if anikin didn't stab him in the back. The sith lord would have raped Obi wan in a one on one.
Click to expand...

I also think Mace is more powerful than Obi Wan, but the Emperor was playing him to turn Anakin.
 
Hyperglide said:
Well with all due respect Obi-Wan did lose to Vader again later on in life and Mace DID beat the Emperor whose probably one of the most powerful Sith ever. Although his sabre skills are very meh.

I still think Obi takes this. He's better with the force, is younger, quicker and he did beat 2 Sith in their prime.

I feel like such a fuckin' nerd now ha ha...
Click to expand...

Obi-Wan didn't lose to Vader, it was part of his plan.
 
Yompton said:
Fought the emperor evenly? No, he handled Sideous and was killed on a sham. Obi Won has actually been bested three times. Twice with a two on one advantage. Yoda was better against Dooku then Ben, Yoda was even with Sideous. Mace fucking d-bowed Sideous.

It's implied he's powerful. He runs shit. He has a purple(or pimp flavored) light saber. His saber has gold on the handle.
Click to expand...

This about sums it up.
 
A true Form III master was considered invincible, and Mace Windu recognizied Kenobi as "the Master of Soresu" ( form III )
 
Boba didn`t get eaten alive. It was part of his plan, he was scouting new real estate. Eventually he opened up a sand ppl apartment complex in the creatures stomach.
 
Fat Abbot said:
Boba didn`t get eaten alive. It was part of his plan, he was scouting new real estate. Eventually he opened up a sand ppl apartment complex in the creatures stomach.
Click to expand...

there was actually a spinoff of star wars with wat happened to boba after he got swallowed
 
zackryder said:
there was actually a spinoff of star wars with wat happened to boba after he got swallowed
Click to expand...

Tales of the Bounty Hunter or something like that? I remember reading a book years ago that told how he survived.
 
Windu is an overglorified can just like the Pride FC fighters.

If he was so damn great, why didn't he feel the force sooner that the dude was Palpatine.
 
Mace Windu destroys Obi-Wan.

Lest we forget...

Obi-Wan was just a padawan whilst Mace Windu was a full-fledged Jedi master. Windu via experience and going toe-to-toe with the freaking Emperor until Vader stole on him.

Mace Windu wins and it wouldn't even be a struggle.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,282,982
Messages
58,474,341
Members
176,047
Latest member
derpmaster3000

Share this page

Back
Top