• Xenforo Cloud is upgrading us to version 2.3.8 on Monday February 16th, 2026 at 12:00 AM PST. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

NFL QB Talk

Top 10 NFL QB's today

1.Tom Brady
2.Joe Montana
3.Peyton Manning
4.Aaron Rodgers
5.Drew Brees
6.Brett Favre
7.Big Ben
8.Dan Marino
9.Matthew Stafford
10.Drake Maye
 
I expect.....

Stafford to look like what he is a future Hall of Famer
Darnold will have a few bad plays
Maye will get by but nothing .....wow
Stidham will crash and burn, poor guy in that position

How will young Mendoza deal with losing and he will as a Raider. He does appear a bit fragile/sensitive, that will not work in pro football.

Don't like to see grown men wimpering around something he does, not a good sign, hell THE SNAKE, THE MAD BOMBER, now bohoo boohoo, hmmmm?
 
Last edited:
Drake Maye in the MVP discussion, heading to a Superbowl, led the NFL in comp% and passer rating, all before 24.

Anyone STILL not geting this?

So he has beat playoff teams

Bills
Panthers
Chargers
Texans............MONSTER D FUCK THE 85 BEARS
Broncos..........MONSTER D FUCK THE 85 BEARS

The whole thing to me is the cat is only 23 years old, think about that,

Imagine the guy at 28ish, he;ll still have his wheels.

I first started noticing my jets were cooling around 32, that burst that acceleration simply wasn't the same.

We have had Olympic 100m champs at 30ish, and I hit my prime 26-28ish. But by then I was done sprinting now just flag football,

As long as the kid doesn;t pull a Jaxson Dart and think a QB can take on a linebacker, he'll be ok.
 
Last edited:
Drake Maye vs Matthew Stafford 2025

Maye in the SB Stafford nope!

Maye 14/3 Stafford 12/5

Stafford more passing yards and TD;s, Maye a better Comp %. passer rating, QBR

Maye 450 rusking yards and 4 scores, Stafford 29 and 0

A very real case can be made for Maye as the MVP, he had more wins, more accomplishments, their combined yards about the same.

Stafford had the better receivers.
 
Last edited:
Maye had a 72 comp% to go with a 113 passer rating at 23
Mahomes at 23 a 66 and 113
Dan Marino at 23.............64/108
Peyton......62/90
Staubach....still in the navy
Russell at Wisconsin
Brady and Rodgers still sitting the bench

How about....

Drew Brees............60/76


John Elway?

Are you kidding me........47/54........what the fuck?

My hero Joe Montana.......56/81....come on Joe

When he was in high school he broke the national high school record for the javelin throw, the cat had a strong arm and could zip a football, but he made bad decisions and lacked accuracy, talking 4 time SB winner Terry Brashaw,

How about.................54/59

Ya know it is looking like no 23 year old NFL QB ever had a higher combined comp%/passing rating in history than Drake Maye.


Doubt Slingin; Sammy, Otto, Johnny U, Frantic Fran compare.

I got it.......Brett Favre, be right back.

Nope..............64/85

Yep, Drake Maye the greatest comp%/passer rating combo ever seen by a cat only 23.

HOLD IT, how about Broadway Joe Namath?

Nope......49/62

Toss in Maye won more road games in a season than any QB in history regardless of age.

And......a 72 comp % is something most QB;s have never accomplished.

Aaron Rodgers in his long career.............71.4
Tom Brady and Russell Wilson at 68ish

Gotta be Mahomes,

Nope, a few 67;s

So we just saw a 23 year old kid put up an historically great NFL season, ending up in the Superbowl.
 
Last edited:
Good to see you've come to your senses and realized Patrick Mahomes is a can.

{<redford}

Patrick Mahomes is the most talented QB the world has ever seen, so.................????

Over 5000 passing yards twice, over 40 TD passes twice, multi SB winner, NFL MVP

Who does that?

Compare what he has done vs anyone else at the same stage of the career, you really can;t.

Speaking of careers....

Tom GOAT Brady comp% 64.3 passer rating 97.2
Mahomes 66.2/ 100.8

Now who compares to Mahomes career numbers above, well? Now add his rushing yards.
 
Last edited:
Patrick Mahomes is the most talented QB the world has ever seen, so.................????

Over 5000 passing yards twice, over 40 TD passes twice, multi SB winner, NFL MVP

Who does that?

Compare what he has done vs anyone else at the same stage of the career, you really can;t.

Speaking of careers....

Tom GOAT Brady comp% 64.3 passer rating 97.2
Mahomes 66.2/ 100.8

Now who compares to Mahomes career numbers above, well? Now add his rushing yards.

Stop yelling.

It's your list, not mine.
 
So If Maye does win the SB he will have beaten

Seahawks
Broncos
Chargers
Texans
Bills

This season, yep,,,,a stud
 
Last edited:
Talking Cam Newton

Thinking number three all time in QB rushing
Won the National JC title while at Blinn in Texas
Won the NCAA national title at Auburn
Also won the Heisman
Won the NFC while a Panther
Won the NFL MVP

i like his TV gig, good stuff.
 
After this season where he put up some big numbers Matthew Stafford is in the top 10 all time in TD passes and passing yards,

The last of the great pocket passers.
 
Top 10 Black QB's

1.Patrick Mahomes Texas Tech/Cheifs
2.Russell Wilson Wisconsin/Sahawks
3.Warren Moon Washington/Oilers
4.Donovan McNabb Syracuse/Eagles
5.Lamar Jackson Louisville/Ravens
6.Randall Cunnigham UNLV/Eagles
7.Cam Newton Auburn/Panthers
8.Dax Prescott Miss St/Cowboys
9.Steve McNair Alcorn/Titans
10,.Michael Vick Virginia Tech/Falcons

Honable Mention

Jalen Hurts, Daunte Culpepper, Doug Williams, Geno Smith, Kyler Murray, Tyrod Taylor, Kordell "Slash" Stewart,
 
Last edited:
Back
Top