- Joined
- Jun 18, 2006
- Messages
- 80,076
- Reaction score
- 120,557
Two nasty guys that killed only some dozens of people.
Compared to politicians they are almost like murder virgins
Two nasty guys that killed only some dozens of people.
Trump is having relocation of Palestinians discussions with Netanyahu right now, which is an aspect of Genocide.Also Trump is having ceasefire discussions with Netanyahu in the White House right now.
Trump is discussing ceasefire plans, every major news outlet is reporting it as so and that Hamas and Israel are talking because of US-sponsored discussions:Trump is having relocation of Palestinians discussions with Netanyahu right now, which is an aspect of Genocide.
Yes, Genocide is a disqualifier. I don't need to hear "Hitler did good things too" arguments.
The new round of indirect talks between Israel and Hamas began on Sunday, after both sides accepted a broad US-sponsored outline of a deal for an initial 60-day ceasefire that could lead to a permanent end to the 21-month conflict.
Why the fuck would I have to rely on what "major news outlets" are reporting when I can just literally listen to the audio of them talking in which they are openly talking about countries they can send the Palestinians to? It's right on video.Trump is discussing ceasefire plans, every major news outlet is reporting it as so and that Hamas and Israel are talking because of US-sponsored discussions:
Multiple news sources specifically saying Trump is pushing for a ceasefire.
You may want to refresh yourself on the definition of "Genocide" as it applies to the Genocide Convention. This absolutely is a genocide. "They could do genocide faster" isn't a valid argument.You throw around the word "genocide", but what's happening in Gaza is not a genocide. Israel could easily wipe out every Palestinian if they wanted, in a day. The Palestinian population has only grown and continues to grow. I would argue it's closer to an attempted ethnic cleansing (which is still bad). Hamas also still has Israeli hostages. Either way, it's irrelevant to the point at hand, Trump is actively seeking a ceasefire between Israel and Palestine, but since you are so blind you wont even accept what every major news source (who openly hate Trump as well) is reporting.
By “The Party” you mean IsraelThe Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.
George Orwell, 1984
"THEY DONT KNOW WHAT THE FUCK THEYRE DOINGGGGGG!"Pros of second(ish) term:
- Helped normalize relations between Arab states and Israel
- Brokered ceasefire in Israel-Iran
"YOU DIDNT SAY THANK YOOUUUUUUUU!"- Attempting to broker ceasefire in Gaza-Israel
- Attempting to broker ceasefire in Russia-Ukraine war
It's simply not genocide buddy. The fact that you use that word means you don't know what it means. A genocide should see a population in the area that is being killed decrease, not increase. That's what every single genocide in history has had in common: the population of the people are wiped out, not increased.Why the fuck would I have to rely on what "major news outlets" are reporting when I can just literally listen to the audio of them talking in which they are openly talking about countries they can send the Palestinians to? It's right on video.
You may want to refresh yourself on the definition of "Genocide" as it applies to the Genocide Convention. This absolutely is a genocide. "They could do genocide faster" isn't a valid argument.
The Gaza population has not been growing since the assault on Gaza after October 7th you imbecile.
You haven't done the homework to discuss this topic.
The audacity for you to lecture me on knowing what the word "Genocide" means when you go on to prove you don't know what the fuck it means. Let me help you:It's simply not genocide buddy. The fact that you use that word means you don't know what it means. A genocide should see a population in the area that is being killed decrease, not increase. That's what every single genocide in history has had in common: the population of the people are wiped out, not increased.
I'm not a leftest, and when you actually take some time to study the concept of Genocide then we can have a legitimate conversation, because right now you have no clue about what you are talking about.It's not even that what is going on in Gaza isn't terrible, a breach of human rights, crimes against humanity, etc. It's just not a genocide. You can post emotionally about it all you want, words simply have meanings and using them incorrectly hurts your point to serious people. I'm sure a bunch of leftists who can't even point Palestine out on a map might screech differently; when you are ready to have grown up conversations then you should use words as they mean rather than as you wish they mean simply to make your point.
I VOTED FOR TRUMP. Specifically because I thought he would push back on Netanyahu better than those feckless Democrats, and while he is a fraction better, he's still acting like a complete CUCK to Netanyahu. None of these people are hiding the fact that their ultimate goal is to remove the Palestinians from Gaza and take it for Israel. They are saying it right to your fucking face. A "ceasefire" is meaningless.Trump wants a ceasefire and is pushing for a ceasefire. Again, multiple news outlets have reported that Israel and Hamas are talking about a ceasefire. What the results of their negotiations will be is up to the negotiators. But when you said something idiotic along the lines of "Trump is genociding Gaza", it's simply not true. Trump is actively working on ensuring no more killing of citizens of Gaza occurs. Sorry that it hurts your feelings that the big bad orange man can potentially do good things, but the world isn't black and white like in the superhero movies that your geopolitical world view must come from.
There's a difference between killing people in a war and genocide. Again, in every historical genocide to date, the population of that group went down. The population even of the West Bank and Gaza have consistently grown, here's a couple of sources showing the growth in recent years as well: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTL?locations=PS, https://worldpopulationreview.com/cities/palestine/gazaThe audacity for you to lecture me on knowing what the word "Genocide" means when you go on to prove you don't know what the fuck it means. Let me help you:
Article II
In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:
(a) Killing members of the group;
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.
And the population in Gaza HAS BEEN DECREASING as a result of the complete obliteration of the strip.
I'm not a leftest, and when you actually take some time to study the concept of Genocide then we can have a legitimate conversation, because right now you have no clue about what you are talking about.
I VOTED FOR TRUMP. Specifically because I thought he would push back on Netanyahu better than those feckless Democrats, and while he is a fraction better, he's still acting like a complete CUCK to Netanyahu. None of these people are hiding the fact that their ultimate goal is to remove the Palestinians from Gaza and take it for Israel. They are saying it right to your fucking face. A "ceasefire" is meaningless.
Your first sentence is complete nonsense. The rules of Genocide apply during war. I'm not even going to bother reading the rest. You've demonstrated to have no clue about the topic.There's a difference between killing people in a war and genocide.
Sad, you let emotions get in the way of logic. One last time, how come in every other recognized genocide, the population of the people being killed went down? And again, you are avoiding the actual topic at hand. I already recognized that what is happening in Gaza is a crime against humanity, probably why Trump is negotiating a ceasefire. I guess I have to use the magic word for you to address the actual topic at hand?Your first sentence is complete nonsense. The rules of Genocide apply during war. I'm not even going to bother reading the rest. You've demonstrated to have no clue about the topic.
Population level is not part of the Genocide Convention. No where is that listed as a criteria, but regardless, the population level in Gaza HAS DECREASED since the response to Oct 7th. It's not fucking growing, do you seriously believe that? Before this recent campaign, the population level increase is attributed to Palestinians trying to crank out kids to replace the deceased adults, which is why over 50% of the population is children.Sad, you let emotions get in the way of logic. One last time, how come in every other recognized genocide, the population of the people being killed went down? And again, you are avoiding the actual topic at hand. I already recognized that what is happening in Gaza is a crime against humanity, probably why Trump is negotiating a ceasefire. I guess I have to use the magic word for you to address the actual topic at hand?
The sources I posted show the population of Gaza, Gaza and Westbank and all of Palestine's populations increasing, respectively.Population level is not part of the Genocide Convention. No where is that listed as a criteria, but regardless, the population level in Gaza HAS DECREASED since the response to Oct 7th. It's not fucking growing, do you seriously believe that? Before this recent campaign, the population level increase is attributed to Palestinians trying to crank out kids to replace the deceased adults, which is why over 50% of the population is children.
You talk about "Israel COULD level Gaza".... NEWSFLASH.... They HAVE leveled Gaza. Trump is wining and dining someone who is committing crimes against humanity as you put it (really Genocide). Just like Genocide Joe, he could end this real fast by stopping to continually arm and fund Israel, Just like he said he would with Ukraine before completely flip flopping on that campaign promise. Trump is using zero leverage, in fact it looks like leverage is being used on him. Complete fraud.
In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such
And none of those numbers have any relevancy to today because they are based on projections PRIOR to Israel LEVELING Gaza.The sources I posted show the population of Gaza, Gaza and Westbank and all of Palestine's populations increasing, respectively.
You didn't fucking read it, read it again. Intent to destroy.... "in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group"..... not the physical location of Gaza, which they actually have already done as well. There is quote after quote after quote proving the intent in this context.The definition you posted above says there needs to be intent to destroy. If you are saying Israel is intent on destroying Gaza, why haven't they done so?
Your source is based on projections that were BEFORE Israel leveled Gaza.Again, they have every capability to do so, but somehow the Palestinians in Gaza's population has been increasing over time, as per my sources above.
No, they are being completely effective at it. What is ineffective is your ability to grasp the concept of "Genocide"........Something simply doesn't add up in your list of assumptions, are the Israelis just so bad at genocide that they can't actually do so? Is that what you are positing? It flies in the face of logic, but I guess who needs logic when you have emotions!
Again, a "ceasefire" is meaningless when the ultimate goal THAT THEY DISCUSSED ON VIDEO is removing the Palestinians from Gaza and shipping them to another country. That is part of GENOCIDE.Trump is hosting ceasefire negotiations between Israel and Hamas to end the killing in Gaza. Sorry if that makes you unnecessarily emotional. The fact that you are saying he is not goes against all news reporting. This seems to be a topic you care about so why not give credit to the one man actively trying to end the killing of the people in Gaza, especially given he seems to be the only person with influence that is willing to do so.
I already explained why.And again, you completely ignore all the other wars that he's ended when you criticize him. I wonder why that is?
The numbers are from the latest year of available data, 2024, from multiple reputable third party sources (UN, Eurostat). The number you are referencing (the 6% population drop) is from the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics (a biased source).And none of those numbers have any relevancy to today because they are based on projections PRIOR to Israel LEVELING Gaza.
You didn't fucking read it, read it again. Intent to destroy.... "in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group"..... not the physical location of Gaza, which they actually have already done as well. There is quote after quote after quote proving the intent in this context.
Your source is based on projections that were BEFORE Israel leveled Gaza.
No, they are being completely effective at it. What is ineffective is your ability to grasp the concept of "Genocide"........
Again, a "ceasefire" is meaningless when the ultimate goal THAT THEY DISCUSSED ON VIDEO is removing the Palestinians from Gaza and shipping them to another country. That is part of GENOCIDE.
I already explained why.