Is todays Gane resume better than Aspinal's one?

[Gregoire1]

If we take scoring system:
1 point - average win
2 point - good win
3 point - elite win
-1 point - "good" loss
-2 point - loss
-3 points - bad loss

Gane:
Volk 2 - 2 points (close fight, but with injury)
Spivak - 1 point
Tai - 2 points
Lewis - 2 points
Volk 1 - 2 points
Rozen -1 point
JDS old - 1 point
Ngannou - -1 point (basically draw, but injury Ngannou)
Jones - -1 point (loss to GOAT, but easily)

Overall - +11-2=9 points

Aspinall:
Blaydes 2 - 2 points
Palvo - 2 points
Volk - 2 points
Spivak - 1 point
Tybura - 1 point
old Arlorski - 1 point
Blaydes - -2 points (injury, but not to elite fighter)

(also loss to Stuart is -3 points, but we dont count it here)

Overall - +9-2=7 points

So overalll Gane resume is now better, but if Asp beat him clearly, he gain 3 points and Gane will lose at least 1 point, so Aspinall would have better resume.

 

[mkess101]

If we take scoring system:
1 point - average win
2 point - good win
3 point - elite win
-1 point - "good" loss
-2 point - loss
-3 points - bad loss

Gane:
Volk 2 - 2 points (close fight, but with injury)
Spivak - 1 point
Tai - 2 points
Lewis - 2 points
Volk 1 - 2 points
Rozen -1 point
JDS old - 1 point
Ngannou - -1 point (basically draw, but injury Ngannou)
Jones - -1 point (loss to GOAT, but easily)

Overall - +11-2=9 points

Aspinall:
Blaydes 2 - 2 points
Palvo - 2 points
Volk - 2 points
Spivak - 1 point
Tybura - 1 point
old Arlorski - 1 point
Blaydes - -2 points (injury, but not to elite fighter)

(also loss to Stuart is -3 points, but we dont count it here)

Overall - +9-2=7 points

So overalll Gane resume is now better, but if Asp beat him clearly, he gain 3 points and Gane will lose at least 1 point, so Aspinall would have better resume.

Can you (kindly) fuck off.

Tuivasa 2 points, Tybura 1 point?

Gee, wonder if there's any bias here LMAO? It's not like Tybura finished Tuivasa inside a round. Oh wait...

Oh shit and Spivak too! He finished Tuivasa inside 2 rounds LOLOL!

You clowns have either stopped trying, or have (somehow) gotten even dumber.

 

[HuskySamoan]

Aspinall has just looked so much more impressive. Seems far more athletic and explosive, faster, stronger and generates more power. Far more multifaceted in skillsets and far more dominant in his victories.

Time will tell, theyre fighting anyways but rating these things seems pointless.

 

[Trabaho]

Lol -1 point fof winning vs AA. -2 for freak injury vs Blyades. And +2 for beating Tai. I mean it's whatever

 

[TheTickG]

One guy is 0 and 2 in title fights.
The other guy is the champion.
That's their current fighting resume.

 

[mkess101]

Lol -1 point fof winning vs AA. -2 for freak injiry vs Blyades. And +2 for beating Tai. I mean it's whatever

A win over Tai is as good as wins over Spivac and Tybura combined even though both finished Tai. His scoring is very unbiased and he has no agenda at all.

 

[nonoob]

TTG said:
One guy is 0 and 2 in title fights.
The other guy is the champion.
That's their current fighting resume.

MMA wmath wasn't needed - it has no place here.
Tom wins by another 1st Round TKO, Cereal's dazed "What TF just happened?"

 

[RockyLockridge]

Tuivasa 2 points, Tybura 1 point?

yes obviously, and it doesn't matter that tybura beat him later. Tuivasa at the time was a better win for sure, and in terms of peak in the division tuivasas is higher. Tuivasa was a top 5 win, Tybura has never been a top 5 win at any point

One guy is 0 and 2 in title fights.
The other guy is the champion.
That's their current fighting resume.

Both of them only ever won an interim title. toms has been promoted. Only difference.

 

[Luthien]

Gane saved @Kowboy On Sherdog from a tree once, me and @HI SCOTT NEWMAN @BroRogan were so relived

 

[TheNewGame]

Gane:
-3 points for ducking Blaydes
-3 points for ducking Aspinall (until he had no choice)

 

[BroRogan]

@Luthien that was wholesome/cute next time I'm looking for another place to chill and hang out

 

[Luthien]

@Luthien that was wholesome/cute next time I'm looking for another place to chill and hang out

@HI SCOTT NEWMAN

 

[Leinster Rugby]

The amount of disrespect Aspinall gets on here is weird. Fucker is the future of the HW division and instead of his props he gets this kind of bullshit all the time.

 

[Dionysian]

You multiply their striking by their grappling and arrive at a mathematically accurate rating of their fighting ability. Gane's score is 0 because any number multiplied by 0 equals 0. Coincidentally that is his title win record as well, despite inexplicably getting a title shot every 3 weeks for the last 3 years.

His game was exposed 3.5 years ago... by a kickboxer dominating him on the mat. But here we are acting like that still never happened/like it is a mystery as to why he never fought a grappler during his entire professional career in this WWE org prior to getting multiple title shots.

At least when Tom beats him UFC will start rotating him off the top stage. Squeezed every last ounce of juice out of this reused contender now / fans somehow bought the same narrative three times in a row lol.

 

[TeenageMutantLesnarTurtle]

Volkov was arguably just robbed against Gane. No way is Gane going 2-0 vs Blaydes and Pav either, but the UFC decided somewhere down the line that hes only allowed to lose in title fights, which they keep giving him off the back of doing virtually nothing.

Gane does not have a win on par with Toms steamrolling of Pav, Blaydes and Volkov.

 

[TeenageMutantLesnarTurtle]

The amount of disrespect Aspinall gets on here is weird. Fucker is the future of the HW division and instead of his props he gets this kind of bullshit all the time.

Its just a handful of Jon fans making a lot of noise.

 

[joy2day]

There is no system in the world that will make Gane look more impressive in his fights than Aspinall. Not one that lives in reality anyway.

 

[Leinster Rugby]

Its just a handful of Jon fans making a lot of noise.

Yep. Your peds cheat goat has retired lads. Get over it.

 

[mkess101]

yes obviously, and it doesn't matter that tybura beat him later. Tuivasa at the time was a better win for sure, and in terms of peak in the division tuivasas is higher. Tuivasa was a top 5 win, Tybura has never been a top 5 win at any point

View attachment 1107480


Both of them only ever won an interim title. toms has been promoted. Only difference.

That's ridiculous. You aren't beholden when making lists like this to the rankings at the time (which are arbitrary anyway). You can SEE who the better fighter is. Tuivasa didn't "age out" and get well into his 40's or something. He got exposed. The UFC "ranking" him higher than he deserves because he drinks beer from a shoe and is more popular than someone like Spivac or Tybura doesn't negate the fact that those two easily handled him in ACTUAL FIGHTS.

 

[RockyLockridge]

That's ridiculous. You aren't beholden when making lists like this to the rankings at the time (which are arbitrary anyway). You can SEE who the better fighter is. Tuivasa didn't "age out" and get well into his 40's or something. He got exposed. The UFC "ranking" him higher than he deserves because he drinks beer from a shoe and is more popular than someone like Spivac or Tybura doesn't negate the fact that those two easily handled him in ACTUAL FIGHTS.

I think the guy is talking about specifically the value of the win at the time. Tuivasa was in a title eliminator coming off of 5 straight KO wins. It's pretty obviously a more valuable win at the time it was earned than tybura was or ever has been. Dont be silly now.