Season 2 got a little wacky but it made Joe feel less like a sociopath and made cameron and donna better characters. All the shenanigans at mutiny also kept things interesting. I kept hearing cotton hill everytime toby huss talked.
Here are my biggest problems with S2:
1. Joe gets pushed aside for the women. In my view, Joe is THE star of the show. He's the guy we can't take our eyes off of. But in S2, they decide that Cameron and Donna need to be the main characters (which was spurred on largely by one of the writers' wives, from what I understand). Don't get me wrong, I'm fine with Mutiny and I think it's an interesting plot line for the girls, but does it need to be the main focus of the show?
2. They didn't know WHAT the fuck they were doing with Gordon in S2. Everything with him sucks. The cocaine, the illness, the infidelity, all that is bullshit and should've never happened.
3. Donna basically extorting Gordon for money was stupid and made Donna look like a fucking bitch.
But with all that said, I did still enjoy the season overall. It's not that I thought it was bad television--it was still better than most shows that were on--it's just that I thought it was a disappointing follow-up to what I thought was a GREAT first season. It was impossible for me to not miss the dim, fluorescently-lit offices of Cardiff Electric.
Like I said, I think that Season 3 is starting strong though and I'm curious to see where they go with it. Can it match S1? I don't know about that. But I do feel like it's going to be better than S2.