250 is extremely large? :icon_neut Are people littler in New York, or something? Unless he's short, that's not that large. I'm sure this comes off as just being sensitive since that's my weight. :icon_chee But I honestly think a guy at 6 feet or taller weighing 250 could very well be a fit dude, even with some belly. People at the gym typically underguess my weight, for example, because I have a lot of mass in my legs.
He said the guy was too big to close his guard around him. My money is on the guy he's talking about being short and round. As I said before, I have a guy who is somewhere in the 265-280 range...but he's only 5'6".