All Time GOAT poll

noc said:
Maybe most people don't know shite, Serra beat him fast.. he can't be the GOAT
Also Hughes submit him in the first round, that's like Fedor losing to Coleman by sub in their first fight
Click to expand...
Nah that's dumb. You can pinpoint tons of shit like that.

Jones lost his last 2 fights and lost to Gus, also PEDs

Silva lost to Chonan and some dude in pride who had a losing record, also PEDS.

GSP is the most consistent IMO, and he won two belts and dominated the toughest division at the time.
 
The-AxeMurderer said:
Nah that's dumb. You can pinpoint tons of shit like that.

Jones lost his last 2 fights and lost to Gus, also PEDs

Silva lost to Chonan and some dude in pride who had a losing record, also PEDS.

GSP is the most consistent IMO, and he won two belts and dominated the toughest division at the time.
Click to expand...
? Jones have never lost. Silva can't be the GOAT either
 
Ube said:
Who else gets TKO'd and taps to strikes against Matt Serra in their athletic prime and still be considered for goat contention? Who else get's TKO'd by Tsuyoshi Kohsaka and still gets to be considered for goat contention? huh?

Remember: Anderson KO'd Rich Franklin twice, finished Dan Henderson, played around with Damian Maia, front kicked a roided Vitor's face for a spectacular KO, made Forrest Griffin look absolutely retarded, submitted Chael with an injured rib after losing for 4 rounds, so on and so forth. AND a lot of the people he fought one time or another popped for PEDS
Click to expand...
Are you seriously comparing a flash KO loss to Matt Serra to a one-way drubbing from Daiju Takase? Really? Cool. Good analogy.
 
It almost appears as if people who actually followed Silva's pre-UFC career don't think he's the GOAT because they saw him fight and lose multiple lackluster scraps against total losers. And they're right. But noobs and teens only know Anderson as a legend and god.
 
Alphakennybody20 said:
Jon Jones and silva would both kick his ass though

I don't get how he is goat out of those 3
Click to expand...


Stronger opponents overall, didn't cheated, never ducked anyone but during his 30 days MW Championship reign, cherry picked opponents only when he cleared his division (Nick Diaz, and Michael Bisping later), dominant af, etc
 
Bouboumaster said:
Stronger opponents overall, didn't cheated, never ducked anyone but during his 30 days MW Championship reign, cherry picked opponents only when he cleared his division (Nick Diaz, and Michael Bisping later), dominant af, etc
Click to expand...
Jon Jones fought 10x better competition, Silva had a longer championship reign, and they both had the capability to beat the shit out of the "GOAT" I just don't get it.
 
Alphakennybody20 said:
Jon Jones fought 10x better competition, Silva had a longer championship reign, and they both had the capability to beat the shit out of the "GOAT" I just don't get it.
Click to expand...

Jon Jones competition was good, but it wasn't the Death Row GSP went trough lol
They could both kick his ass, but P4P, GSP is much more skilled then them...
If it's just about kicking ass, then Ngannou is the GOAT
 
Bouboumaster said:
Jon Jones competition was good, but it wasn't the Death Row GSP went trough lol
They could both kick his ass, but P4P, GSP is much more skilled then them...
If it's just about kicking ass, then Ngannou is the GOAT
Click to expand...
Yes it was he fought more world champions than GSP, easily too.

More finishes, and he's actually undefeated
 
Alphakennybody20 said:
Yes it was he fought more world champions than GSP, easily too.

More finishes, and he's actually undefeated
Click to expand...

GSP didn't fought a lot of world champion, because he was at the top all this time, and before him, it was Hughes. He fought the best of the beast at WW, tho, which is a much, much more deeper division than LHW.

GSP has also only two defeats (one before his prime) and avenged both of them.

Less finish, but IMO, more domination in the fight, and of course, no cheating.

If it wasn't for his cheating, I would have Jon Jones at either #1 or #2. I think he's an incredibly skilled fighter, but the cheating, IMO, disqualified him.

That's my humble opinion.
 
Bouboumaster said:
GSP didn't fought a lot of world champion, because he was at the top all this time, and before him, it was Hughes. He fought the best of the beast at WW, tho, which is a much, much more deeper division than LHW.

GSP has also only two defeats (one before his prime) and avenged both of them.

Less finish, but IMO, more domination in the fight, and of course, no cheating.

If it wasn't for his cheating, I would have Jon Jones at either #1 or #2. I think he's an incredibly skilled fighter, but the cheating, IMO, disqualified him.

That's my humble opinion.
Click to expand...
LHW had a very good level
 
Last edited:
Bouboumaster said:
Didn't said anything against it.
But the WW saw some all-time great going there at that time, and GSP humiliated most of them.
Click to expand...
That was the best period of LHW in history.. with the Pride fighters. And then he had to beat Black Fedor that defeated assasins
 
The-AxeMurderer said:
Most people seem to agree that GSP is the GOAT.
Click to expand...
Wrong. Most people seem to agree tgat either Jones, DJ, Aldo, Fedor, or 'other' are the GOAT. GSP has well under half of the total votes cast. Not saying he is or isn't (I voted Fedor, but GSP has a strong claim).
 
For me Jones & not even close if its about who has best ability to win, undefeated for so long, fought so many good fighters, around 12 defences but looking way more beatable last few fights.
 
We all know there is only one real undefeated fighter and champion - Chael Sonnen
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,280,897
Messages
58,326,172
Members
176,000
Latest member
Markooz86

Share this page

Back
Top