• We are requiring that all users add Two-Step Verification (2FA) to their accounts, as found here: https://forums.sherdog.com/account/security Within one week, we will automatically set this up, so please make the necessary arrangements. Reach out to an admin if you encounter issues, and we apologize for any inconvenience.

All Time GOAT poll

Tachycardia said:
With GSP retired now, who do you think is the all time greatest at this time?


GSP





Fedor





Anderson Silva




Jon Jones






Mighty Mouse




Aldo






If your selection for the greatest fighter of all time is not in the poll, feel free to vote for other explain why.
Click to expand...

Travesty that DC isn't on the list.

It's GSP though
 
Clippy said:
That's why I like Fedor cause now-adays he plays it dangerous as fuck
Click to expand...

Oh yeah, going to Bellator and fighting MW's and HW journeymen (and losing mostly) is totally playing it dangerous.

Bisping was a UFC MW champion when GSP beat him. Even if you don't think that's impressive, its certainly more impressive than anything Fedor has done lately
 
welcometohavoc said:
Oh yeah, going to Bellator and fighting MW's and HW journeymen (and losing mostly) is totally playing it dangerous.

Bisping was a UFC MW champion when GSP beat him. Even if you don't think that's impressive, its certainly more impressive than anything Fedor has done lately
Click to expand...

Not more impressive than Fedor's overall career

If GSP hadn't run away then he would be taking losses in his 30th+ fight too
 
Clippy said:
Not more impressive than Fedor's overall career

If GSP hadn't run away then he would be taking losses in his 30th+ fight too
Click to expand...

That's your opinion. What is fact is that Fedor started losing 10 years ago, to a MW among others.
 
welcometohavoc said:
That's your opinion. What is fact is that Fedor started losing 10 years ago, to a MW among others.
Click to expand...

Anybody can get a good punch in - see Fatt Serra

yelling about how he fights at middleweight is bullshit

Hendo's punches are known

<15>

Speaking of Hendo he beat bisping much better than GSP did
 
Clippy said:
Anybody can get a good punch in - see Fatt Serra

yelling about how he fights at middleweight is bullshit

Hendo's punches are known

<15>

Speaking of Hendo he beat bisping much better than GSP did
Click to expand...

Fedor got ragdolled by Bisping.

Hendo went 1-1 with Bisping.
 
Fedor is not even in the GOAT conversation. Let it go people.
 
GiSP said:
Never expected that shit from you.

Ran away? I thought it beneath you.

Really?

tumblr_mh53ch6Q5m1rdutw3o1_400.gif
Click to expand...

I'm a Canadian and a big fan of GSP myself

But I'm sick of the mentality that you lose then you are out of the GOAT discussion. People give Fedor a hard time for having late career losses and disregard his goat run which is bullshit.

I was so shocked when GSP barely won his last fight and then announced he was retiring ... almost spontaneously due to the lackluster performance. GSP was good back in the day but his last fights were never ending jab fest point collecting runs. Fedor annihilated top fighters back in his day hardly ever going to the judges

For these things I hold Fedor higher
 
GSP and Fedor.
if you don't move up and/or get popped you can't be considered the GOAT. imo
 
wilKO said:
Yet he's 2nd in this poll and way ahead of anyone below him...
Click to expand...
Old sherdoggers can't let go of how Pride was not on the UFCs level of more legitimate matchmaking.

That being said. Pride forever.
 
mallen7272 said:
Old sherdoggers can't let go of how Pride was not on the UFCs level of more legitimate matchmaking.

That being said. Pride forever.
Click to expand...

You're right HW now is so much better than in Prides day. Arlovski, Werdum, Hunt, Overeem, Cro Cop, Barnett all still top 15...
 
wilKO said:
You're right HW now is so much better than in Prides day. Arlovski, Werdum, Hunt, Overeem, Cro Cop, Barnett all still top 15...
Click to expand...
Ya pick one weight class that is historically shallow. That's fair
 
Clippy said:
I was so shocked when GSP barely won his last fight and then announced he was retiring ... almost spontaneously due to the lackluster performance.
Click to expand...

You were shocked? Really? Everyone knew GSP was retiring after the fight. He pretty much said so before the fight.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,252,083
Messages
56,497,279
Members
175,249
Latest member
jonnhyxv

Share this page

Back
Top