What do you guys think about this top 10 list of all time

[cheesus]

Anyone ranking a fighter with losses over an undefeeated is just mentally Challenged.

1. Jones, Fedor, Silva
2. DC
3. GSP, MM

The rest is your pick.

All of those guys aside from Jones fought bigger opponents. The only reason Jones is undefeated is because he refuses to test himself.

 

[TheToqueville]

All of those guys aside from Jones fought bigger opponents. The only reason Jones is undefeated is because he refuses to test himself.

So where does GSP ducking Silva for years, but jumping at the opportunity to fight the weakest, one eyed champ at MW ( then "getting colitis" when real MWs starting challenging him) fit into your narrative?



Were you saying that GSP "refused to test himself" when he was ducking Silva? Or is that only reserved for fighters you already don't like for other reasons?

Also , Jones has never lost at his own weight class, where GSP has...and also tapped to strikesLOL from a midget....

 

[pick999]

Dumb

 

[cheesus]

So where does GSP ducking Silva for years, but jumping at the opportunity to fight the weakest, one eyed champ at MW ( then "getting colitis" when real MWs starting challenging him) fit into your narrative?



Were you saying that GSP "refused to test himself" when he was ducking Silva? Or is that only reserved for fighters you already don't like for other reasons?

Also , Jones has never lost at his own weight class, where GSP has...and also tapped to strikesLOL from a midget....

You make a solid point. Though GSP was nowhere as dominant in regards to physical size and length compared to Jones. Only guys I can recall matching Jones for size would be Gus, OSP & Bonnar.

 

[POWER2]

The only thing I have issues with is Randy being anywhere near that list. Aside from that, it's fine. Might as well put BJ Penn up there too.

Let's be honest.

BJ Penn sucked for most of his career.

 

[Stevanchez]

1)GSP
2)Fedor
3)Silva
4)Jones
5)Aldo
6)Big Nog
7)Cormier
8)Henderson
9)Hughes
10)Penn

 

[TheToqueville]

You make a solid point. Though GSP was nowhere as dominant in regards to physical size and length compared to Jones. Only guys I can recall matching Jones for size would be Gus, OSP & Bonnar.

Santos was pretty big too. Not as tall, but solid.

 

[Taric]

no offense to couture, but what the fuck is he doing there lol

 

[Joseph_McBride]

I would put Nunes in at 9 or 10. She's done some very impressive work.

 

[Pequeño Corey]

1.jbj
2.fedor
3.anderson silva
4.gsp

I coulda got behind something similar to this

These 4 in almost any order are a lock for 1-4. Things gets messy after that.

 

[Azure]

Anyone ranking a fighter with losses over an undefeeated is just mentally Challenged.

1. Jones, Fedor, Silva
2. DC
3. GSP, MM

The rest is your pick.

Anyone ranking fighters that figured out how to take PED's and get away with it is as well.

 

[JAL]

no offense to couture, but what the fuck is he doing there lol

lol

 

[Tyler Durden]

2 and 3 are drug cheats.

How the fuck do they make the list?














CM Punk is ranked higher than they are, on the basis that he's not a a dirty roiding cheater.

What a fucking joke.

A little emotional today?

 

[Mixfight]

Fedor is #1 Unlike GSP who lost multiple times in his prime , got KOd in his prime by a can and tapped to strikes in his prime to can and also got submitted in his prime by a wreslter Matt Hughes. Fedor only lost when he was 5 years past his prime in 2010 and got submitted by a world champion BJJ guy, not some wrestler. Fedor and only got knocked out 11 years into his career and got knocked down for the first time 16 years into his career. During his prime he was flawless and didnt even lose a single round unlike GSP who took KO, tap to strikes and submission losses to wrestlers in his prime.

Fedor is #1 Unlike Jones who ducked the HW division while being 6'4 235lbs on fight night and got caught with steroids 3 different times and resorts to using pussy ass eyepokes and knee stomps because his hands are trash. Fedor was everything Jones wishes he was. Humble, versatile, went for the kill and never fought like a pussy or ducked HW.

Mighty Mouse is a joke being anywhere near a top 5 OAT list considering he beat nothing but 125lb bums. Its literally a joke that anyone would put a man who is the size of some women as a top 5 all time fighter. Seriously laughable.

 

[Natural Order]

Prime Fedor steamrolls every name on the list, ergo Fedor is clearly #1.

You ladies can squabble about the other 9.

 

[Fesaine]

Here’s a list based on who beat who and how they did it. Completely skill and talent based list:

1 Jones
2 GSP
3 Anderson
4 DJ
5 Khabib
6 DC
7 Stipe
8 Conor
9 Fedor
10 Cejudo

Israel, Usman, Ferguson and Volkanovski are all 1-2 fights away from making top 10 too

Fedor is way too high.

But great list nonetheless.

 

[POWER2]

Fedor is #1 Unlike GSP who lost multiple times in his prime , got KOd in his prime by a can and tapped to strikes in his prime to can and also got submitted in his prime by a wreslter Matt Hughes. Fedor only lost when he was 5 years past his prime in 2010 and got submitted by a world champion BJJ guy, not some wrestler. Fedor and only got knocked out 11 years into his career and got knocked down for the first time 16 years into his career. During his prime he was flawless and didnt even lose a single round unlike GSP who took KO, tap to strikes and submission losses to wrestlers in his prime.

Fedor is #1 Unlike Jones who ducked the HW division while being 6'4 235lbs on fight night and got caught with steroids 3 different times and resorts to using pussy ass eyepokes and knee stomps because his hands are trash. Fedor was everything Jones wishes he was. Humble, versatile, went for the kill and never fought like a pussy or ducked HW.

Mighty Mouse is a joke being anywhere near a top 5 OAT list considering he beat nothing but 125lb bums. Its literally a joke that anyone would put a man who is the size of some women as a top 5 all time fighter. Seriously laughable.

Matt Serra is a can? Are you smoking crack today?

 

[Pakman]

Losses matter.

Silva and Fedor are too high. Randy is too high. Aldo should be a bit lower

Fedor is #1 lol @ too high. and Aldo is right around where he should be.

 

[Bork Neslar]

I don't see Artem.
That list sucks.

 

[ostlerrage]

here is the top 10 list of Tapology. What do you guys think? Would you change something
View attachment 719425

1 lols at jones the career cheat.
2 randy was a trt pioneer before it became illegal
3. massive fan of andy but he popped as well. shame as it was probably to help heal his leg.
4. surely royce gracie deserves credit. a lw winning hw fights.