What do you guys think about this top 10 list of all time

JAL

Purple Belt
@purple
Joined
Feb 1, 2019
Messages
1,825
Reaction score
2,375
here is the top 10 list of Tapology. What do you guys think? Would you change something
22DC1906-B8BB-4078-8558-8EB6317F0FC8.png
 
ee3eac8b956dc5855bda66866360c035.gif
 
The only thing I have issues with is Randy being anywhere near that list. Aside from that, it's fine. Might as well put BJ Penn up there too.
 
Losses matter.

Silva and Fedor are too high. Randy is too high. Aldo should be a bit lower
 
Top 5 is about the same as the GOAT poll at the top of the page. Also, they forgot #9...
 
Anyone ranking a fighter with losses over an undefeeated is just mentally Challenged.

1. Jones, Fedor, Silva
2. DC
3. GSP, MM

The rest is your pick.
Ok....? By that logic it should go Khabib, Paulo Costa etc.

Your criteria is dumb and you should feel bad about it.
 
Anyone ranking a fighter with losses over an undefeeated is just mentally Challenged.

1. Jones, Fedor, Silva
2. DC
3. GSP, MM

The rest is your pick.
Fedor and Silva have more losses to lesser competition then DC,GSP and MM combined...

<Dany07>

Edit: this isn't a knock at Silva and Fedor. Both are top 3-5 depending on opinion. He just claims undefeated fighters should be ahead of guys with losses but doesn't rank an undefeated fighter...
 
Last edited:
How come you can cry two times in the octagon and be in this list ?
<30>
 
Great list outside of Randy in the top 10. Randy is an all time great but not top 10.
 
Nah

GSP
Fedor
JBJ
DJ
Aldo
SIlva
Khabib
Stipe
DC
Hendo
 
2 and 3 are drug cheats.

How the fuck do they make the list?

CM Punk is ranked higher than they are, on the basis that he's not a a dirty roiding cheater.

What a fucking joke.
 
Back
Top