Question for
@Jack V Savage and any other baseball nerds that care about this stuff.
I have had regular conversations with older Yankees fans (for those that don't know I live in NY and there are obviously tons of fans) and I continually hear things along the lines of "we should be playing more small ball" and it is making me mental. I push for a clear definition and as I understand it, it means utilizing bunting, sacrifice flies/ground balls to advance runners and stealing bases to generate runs (and I checked the internet and it agrees with me). My view is that would be a ludicrous strategy for a team like the Yankees who is one, willing to lead the MLB in highest payroll and two, play half their games in a park with a short right field porch (and not particularly deep anywhere else in the park). I also point out that the Yankees have been (and currently are) consistently one of the best teams in baseball not by playing small ball but by hitting home runs primarily, and obviously with good pitching. I even push for an answer with something like - should the Yankees replace Judge, who has 60 home run potential and plays a good outfield with a speedy 10 home run guy that can bunt? The answer is always an obvious no. I also get a lot of squirming over the definition "well I don't mean bunting...". As if the Yanks should steal more bases with a lineup full of big guys that hit bombs.
So the question is, am I wrong? One of the best push packs I have gotten is that you generally face top notch pitching in the playoffs and teams reduce the number of starters so you effective face aces regularly and that small ball can help you win in the play offs. I push back with the fact that 22 home runs were hit last world series and both teams had great pitching. My argument is this is pure nostalgia for a game past, but I do acknowledge teams like the As, Royals, etc. and more so in the National league have salary constraints (or a pitcher that has to hit 3-4 times a game) can benefit from that style of play. I just think it's crazy for the Yankees, Dodgers, Cubs, Red Sox, etc.. I'd say the Mets too but they just blow lol.