- Joined
- Jun 5, 2005
- Messages
- 5,609
- Reaction score
- 0
I think I just found my new sig. If you don't mind that is Cap'n
Awesome
I think I just found my new sig. If you don't mind that is Cap'n
EZA,
I agree in part with your post, however, I have never heard of the book "Children and Sports Training" or the author, Josef Drabek. But I would be interested to hear what his credentials are? I googled his name and the book title but came up with nothing?
Two of my favourite authors on the topic of physical training are Yuri Verkhoshanky and Mel Siff, Well educated, experienced and decades of practicle application ranging from children to elite athletes.
I agree that "building kinesthetic awareness, motor skills and coordination, and reaction timing..." should be the focus of a childs physical training program. But I think strength training should also be incorperated into a childs overall training program.
A well structured, closely supervised resistance training program can benfit a child, and help build a solid training foundation for sports as they grow up.
Lifting weights will stunt young children's growth.
The question many people are missing on here isn't "can a 9 year old lift weights?" but rather "is lifting weights the best thing for a 9 year old to do?" Yes of course they can do it, and obviously kids who work on a farm end up doing forms of resistance training as part of work (just as gymnastics as I advocated requires bodyweight movements and strength as well) but that doesn't mean it's the right thing for them to spend their time doing if they want to improve their long term athletic development and performance down the road. Sure it can be done safely and it won't hinder their growth when done properly, but that still doesn't mean their time shouldn't be spent focusing on other areas of development that they have the capacity to improve in at that time instead.
The question many people are missing on here isn't "can a 9 year old lift weights?" but rather "is lifting weights the best thing for a 9 year old to do?" Yes of course they can do it, and obviously kids who work on a farm end up doing forms of resistance training as part of work (just as gymnastics as I advocated requires bodyweight movements and strength as well) but that doesn't mean it's the right thing for them to spend their time doing if they want to improve their long term athletic development and performance down the road. Sure it can be done safely and it won't hinder their growth when done properly, but that still doesn't mean their time shouldn't be spent focusing on other areas of development that they have the capacity to improve in at that time instead.
From now on, automatic dubs for anyone who says weight lifting is dangerous for kids.
Don't spread stupidity, it does it well enough on it's own.
fo/ky
why would you put a kid on a weight lifting program who wants to train martial arts? Train him in MA and in warm ups and cool downs do bodyweight and light weight training. It's ridiculous to put kids on weight training programs, because unless you have people who know what they're doing who are constantly monitoring him, then he could hurt himself. It's not about stunting growth or any other bullshit because I'm not stupid. This is definitely not the best thing for a child. Skill training is more important. Light weights and bodyweight workouts will do great. Besides, see if he has the determination or even the want to do that, if he just trains he'll be fine.
Well that's the question we deal with as parents every day. "Is this the right thing for my child?" I don't know of any adults who had their growth stunted by lifting; and I have never heard anyone say,"My Dad made me lift weights as a kid and it sucked."
Give a man a fish and he'll eat for a day.
Teach a young child to do a handstand and he'll walk around on his hands like a freak for the rest of his life.