Do you think all constitutional protections extend to foreigners?
I think AOC's point is that our priorities are fucked to protect real estate speculation that drives up the cost of living but also ignore millions of students who come out of college with a mortgage payment and no house.
Really? That's the stance you want to take? OK.
1. Do all constitutional protections extend to foreigners?
I don't know. Who should decided which constitutional protections should extend to foreigners and which should not? Should AOC and her crew decide? Should the Supreme Court decide? Should the President of the US decide? Are you sure you want to go down this rabbit hole? Because my guess is that ultimately, it's going to be the Supreme Court that decides. And do you think the current make up of the SC will look favorably at taking foreigner's properties?
2. Aside from the legal constitutional viewpoint, do you think it is moral to take foreigners' properties?
Do you want to live in a country where foreigners are discouraged from investing any money because all of their US properties can be taken away at any point on the whim of the US government? Do you think it is right to say, "Hey, since you're Chinese, all of your houses in America are now the property of the US government?" Any money they have in American banks, all US govermnent's. What about European investors? What about African investors? You don't think there's anything wrong with that?
3. Who has been raising the cost of colleges?
Has the US government been raising college tuition? Last I checked, it was the colleges themselves (both private and public) that have been raising their costs. They claim it's for research and whatnot. But we all know the truth. It's to pay professors and administrators. My own college professors had salaries in the quarter to half million dollar range. Are you complaining about that?
4. Cost of living increases driven by foreigners?
Despite foreign real estate speculation, do you really think that foreigners are the main reason cost of living and housing has been going up? What percentage of US residential properties are owned by foreigners? What about US citizens who own homes? Should they be looked down on because they saved up to buy a home but now their home is worth more?
5. Who is forcing students to go to college when there are "no jobs" available for them?
First off, it seems that reports indicate that unemployment is at an all time low. Secondly, who is forcing these people to go to college and earn degrees that do not translate into career opportunities upon graduation? Did people force these students to get a bachelors in gender studies? Or was it their choice? And shouldn't people have the freedom to choose? Instead of majoring in fields where salaries and job opportunities are low, did they work to get degrees in STEM fields? Or if they don't want to, they can go to trade colleges. Who is forcing these people to go to college?
6. AOC's point that we are protecting real estate speculation over people is a false dichotomy.
She wants you to believe that there is an imaginary corporate elite group trying to keep people down while they only enrich themselves. Look at Amazon as an example. AOC lambasted Amazon and demanded that they renegotiate an agreement that the company, city, state, and local citizens all agreed on. She ignores or denies the fact that Amazon was going to bring in about 25,000 jobs (mostly high paying high tech jobs) and only focuses on some imaginary $3B that Amazon was supposedly getting from NY.
What about the jobs that graduating college students could have used? I'm sure many graduating students from NYU, Columbia, and local colleges would have loved to get a six figure salary there to help pay for their educational debts.
But yeah, keep dreaming that AOC is for the little people.
Edit: And since AOC is suddenly so concerned about "details," I would love to hear how she plans on funding free college for all. If she explains the details in a feasible fashion without taking away any of our liberties, I would gladly consider her proposal. Heck, I don't want my kids to have to pay for something if they don't have to.