- Joined
- Jul 24, 2016
- Messages
- 13,653
- Reaction score
- 8,060
I've seen all of those fights multiple times and I disagree with you on a couple counts.
First, he did not give Frye, Oleg, or Rizzo all they could handle. He landed a take down, shitty GnP, and a couple glancing shots against Rizzo. Rizzo flatlined him. Guys like Randy, Barnett, etc gave Pedro all he could handle; Tank got beat up and KO'd. Against Taktarov, Tank slopped his way through about 15 minutes of top time and clinch work before getting choked. In this particular instance, yeah, he gave Oleg a long fight, but Oleg was never in any real danger of being finished. Much like Rizzo, Taktarov couldn't wear a punch at all so the superficial facial damage was far worse than it would have been for someone with more durable skin but there was never any doubt who was gonna win this. Well, Oleg was on the Oxygen pretty hard as soon as this fight finished and he got the easiest route to the final via thrown fight, so sure we'll say Tank gave him all he could handle on this one. For the record, I don't consider Oleg to be all that good, but we'll move on. With Frye, he dropped him with a jab right out the gate and landed some pretty decent shots to bust ol' Donny wide open before... falling over from a shove and getting choked out within seconds of it hitting the mat. The entire fight lasted a minute and a half! Tank had his moments there but his one-dimensional style was exposed posthaste and he was sent packing quick. If you want to see what giving Frye all he could handle actually looks like watch his fights with Shammy and Goodridge.
In all these cases, the common element is that Tank lost decisively. He always lost when matched up with good fighters. Always. Hell, he even lost to mediocre fighters, especially on his return from pro 'rasslin. Wins are what really define a fighter's place in the MMA pantheon and Tank has a whopping ZERO wins against top opposition. If laying a whooping on Varelans, Jennum and grinding Yoji freakin' Anjo to a decision impresses you fair enough, but Tank was never anything more than a cartoon character to me.
Against Rizzo, Tank tags the striking specialist in the feet and doesnt allow him to impose his rythm, then takes the fight to the ground with a well executed takedown. Rizzo got back to his feet via standup referee after 7+ minuts of fighting, not by his own. Tank's lack of endurance was clearly what allowed Rizzo to take over, not any other skill.
Against Oleg, I dont think I need to argue why Tank gave him all he could handle. I'd say Oleg was a very good fighter...but a MW.
Againt Frye at his absolute peak, Tank put him in rubber legs several times and got the better of every exchanche. It was a slip what left Tank in a bad position, not any strike or takedown by Frye, who then capitalized very well on Tank's lack of ground skills. I think Frye himself regarded Tank as the toughest opponent going into the Ultimate Ultimate, and I doubt he had a different impression afterwards.
The fact the likes of Couture or Barnett performed better than Tank doesnt tell that much, they are all-time greats and the step below all-time great is not all-time scrub which is what you are making Tank look like.
TS is obiously doing a hyperbole and whoever doesnt acknowledge an evolution in the sport, even at HW, since Tank days is either blind or doesnt have a clue but Tank was definitely a solid opponent, without a doubt by 90s standards, and specially when he had his conditioning on point, or kinda.

