PJ Stock, George McPhee, Stan Jonathan or Wendel Clark - Out of these 4, who's the best fighter?

[Takes_Two_To_Tango]

All 4 are not even 6 feet tall.

Out of these four who's the best scrapper?

Btw this is not about who the best fighter in the NHL of all-time. This is about whos best out of these 4 I mentioned, that are under 6 feet tall.

 

[Ponchik]

Zdeno Chara

 

[Takes_Two_To_Tango]

Zdeno Chara

Chara is a beast, but he has terrible balance. And he's 6'9", huge height advantage. Kinda overrated as a fighter imo.

 

[yamahacrasher]

Pound for pound, Wendel may be the best fighter to ever play. Especially considering he could actually play the game too.

 

[Takes_Two_To_Tango]

Pound for pound, Wendel may be the best fighter to ever play. Especially considering he could actually play the game too.

Definitely wouldn't disagree. Do you live around Toronto?

 

[MichiganMMA1978]

Why is Clark on here when Probert whipped his ass?

As a wings fan, my vote goes to Probert

 

[Takes_Two_To_Tango]

Why is Clark on here when Probert whipped his ass?

As a wings fan, my vote goes to Probert

lol out of those guys I mentioned. Probert is probably the best fighter ever. Although you got to say Clark pound for pound is up there.

 

[MichiganMMA1978]

lol out of those guys I mentioned. Probert is probably the best fighter ever. Although you got to say Clark pound for pound is up there.

Bob wasn't even really a hockey player, he was an enforcer lol

 

[Takes_Two_To_Tango]

Bob wasn't even really a hockey player, he was an enforcer lol

lol enforcer or goon, whatever name you want to associate them with. : - )

 

[MichiganMMA1978]

lol enforcer or goon, whatever name you want to associate them with. : - )

As a fan, I'll go with enforcer. Though I can see why others would say goon lol

 

[newms84]

Im definitely biased but gotta go with Stan Jonathan

 

[Takes_Two_To_Tango]

Im definitely biased but gotta go with Stan Jonathan

No, it's not being biased at all. He was tough af and held his own well against Behn Wilson. One of the best fighters of all time.

 

[HARRISON_3]

Doug Glatt

 

[AFanNotAFighter]

Georges Laraque was a beast.
Tie Domi was only 5'8" and could rock and roll. He even looked psycho.

 

[Yoel Bromero]

Bob wasn't even really a hockey player, he was an enforcer lol

Wtf are you talking about? Wasn't a player?
Motherfucker was an all star in 88. He was third on derroit in scoring and led deteoit in playoff scoring that year. He averaged close to 40 points for most of his career with full seasons. The wheels came off at the end and his days in chicago were pure goonery but to say he wasn't a player is just fucking dumb.

 

[Yoel Bromero]

Georges Laraque was a beast.
Thai Domi was only 5'8" and could rock and roll. He even looked psycho.

Met Tie a few times, funny guy. His head and hands belong on a much larger man. Bowling ball head and lunch boxes at the end of his wrists.

 

[MichiganMMA1978]

Wtf are you talking about? Wasn't a player?
Motherfucker was an all star in 88. He was third on derroit in scoring and led deteoit in playoff scoring that year. He averaged close to 40 points for most of his career with full seasons. The wheels came off at the end and his days in chicago were pure goonery but to say he wasn't a player is just fucking dumb.

My memories of him are all fights lol

 

[Yoel Bromero]

Probably Wendy, he was a force and was almost always punching up.

Shout out to pj stock and his enormous set of balls. He held his own against lots of guys he had no business fighting. Honey badger.

Miss those types of players big time.

 

[Sweater of AV]

That's a pretty random list. There are quite a few great fighters under 6 ft. Not sure why only those four are being compared.

 

[Yoel Bromero]

My memories of him are all fights lol

2 of his best fights, first one is his first nhl fight and he brought the heat.



Rematch



For bonus, here is Coxe taking on kocur same game after the second probert fight....flipping the bucket off everytime, coxe was fuckin nuts lol