No one is going to read this, but I must say it!
Gears of War is my favorite gaming franchise of all time. I consider Gears 3 the greatest game of all time. I read ALL of the Karen Traviss books which are excellent by the way. I have a Gears hat that I got as a pre-order bonus that I swore I’d never wear (but do when I’m working around the house). I’m (or was) an above average MP player (I never figured out how to wall bounce, but I had strategies that worked well and almost always had me at the top of the leaderboard). The Gnasher is the second greatest MP weapon of all time (behind the M1 Garand in Battlefield: 1943).
Gears 1: Excellent game, Incredible worldbuilding, great action, characters that I was immediately drawn to. The MP was terrific if lacking in stats. Played it for hours and hours.
Gears 2: MOTS. I didn’t love the changes to MP. The story was a typical middle chapter. Co-op was fun
Gears 3: Only Elden Ring has ever challenged it as the greatest game of all time in my mind. The story capped perfectly. Emotions galore. Perfect end to the series (or should have been). The MP was sublime and is probably still my most played ever. The maps were brilliant. The weapons were brilliant. The level progression and unlocks were brilliant and ALL of the skins were included and attainable by just playing the game. The character movement was perfect. The weapon balance was perfect (and even the double barrel shotgun which veterans whined about to no end was fun to use some times).
Gears 4. The MP beta was outstanding and I was pumped. Whatever changed from the beta to go live, largely ruined the MP for me. The movement was wrong. The hit detection was wrong. The maps were wrong. Everything was wrong. I still played quite a bit, but my days of dominating matches were suddenly over and it wasn’t skills fade. The shift in story off of Marcus made sense, but it doomed the franchise like killing Optimus Prime doomed the transformers (1986). The hook at the end though was well executed. And locking all the skins behind random loot boxes was the worst decision ever made in the franchise.
Gears 5: Just. Terrible. MP. JUST TERRIBLE. They fixed things that didn’t need fixing to make it ‘more accessible’ and gutted the fanbase. SP focused on a character no one cared about with Marcus tossed in as an afterthought. Never finished it. May try ahead of Gears 6, but my hopes are very low for that game too