If GSP and Anderson Silva did fight in their primes - Would the winner be the clear MMA GOAT?

[BFoe]

Hey clown.. Your poll options suck, alright.

Get a fucking grip, man.

Where’s the Silva will never be any kind of GOAT because.. Peds?

Where’s that option. Why make such a rubbish thread?

Is there any specific reason you can’t just politely ask the TS to add more options? There’s no reason to act like an asshole just because you don’t like someone else’s thread or poll. Take an anger management class or something.

 

[VAfan]

was almost undoubtedly the best fight we never got to see. i mean you could easily make a case for either side. GSP would probably have gotten the TDs but anderson was KOing dudes left and right with such ease that you couldn't predict it either way. either silva catches him in the first or second round or GSP does what sonnen did without the unhappy ending and gets the decision. i say GSP gets it done.

 

[Koala]

They should do a tournament
GSP will fight Silva at 185
Emelianenko will go off the ice cream and fight Jones at 205
Both winners will fight at 195

 

[Fioretti]

It would give Silva a smaller edge over Jones in accomplishments, that he'll eventually surpass anyway.

 

[Yellowcrab]

Silva was 41 years old in that fight and Bisping was 37 years old. Not to mention Silva was coming from a bad injury.

GSP beat a 38 years old Bisping when he was 36 years old.

Prime for prime, we all know who would win.

 

[Takes Two To Tango]

Hey clown.. Your poll options suck, alright.

Get a fucking grip, man.

Where’s the Silva will never be any kind of GOAT because.. Peds?

Where’s that option. Why make such a rubbish thread?

Ok I know you don't like my threads. Just go somewhere else than.

It's simple question, with simple poll options to pick from. Doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure things out.

By the way the Silva option doesn't need to be there when there is the Fedor and Jon Jones option. Come on man, it's not that hard to figure out.

 

[Davidjacksonjones]

Ok I know you don't like my threads. Just go somewhere else than.

It's simple question, with simple poll options to pick from. Doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure things out.

By the way the Silva option doesn't need to be there when there is the Fedor and Jon Jones option. Come on man, it's not that hard to figure out.

I enjoy your threads man! Keep it up

 

[Prince Nephilim]

Hey clown.. Your poll options suck, alright.

Get a fucking grip, man.

Where’s the Silva will never be any kind of GOAT because.. Peds?

Where’s that option. Why make such a rubbish thread?

Sorry, there’s no option for soy boys.

 

[pankrat]

GSP would probably have gotten the TDs but anderson was KOing dudes left and right with such ease that you couldn't predict it either way. either silva catches him in the first or second round or GSP does what sonnen did without the unhappy ending and gets the decision.

This ubersimpleton sherbro analysis didnt hold up at first glance, but much less after seeing GSP badly struggling inside Bisping's guard and actually taking more damage than he delivered there

 

[Takes Two To Tango]

I enjoy your threads man! Keep it up

Thank you, most appreciated. : - )

 

[Arm Barbarian]

Is there any specific reason you can’t just politely ask the TS to add more options? There’s no reason to act like an asshole just because you don’t like someone else’s thread or poll. Take an anger management class or something.

I agree with what he said about Anderson being excluded due to more than one PED fail, but yeah, no need to be so hostile. MXT also seems to be a good sport with folks giving him a hard time.

 

[AmonTobin]

As a fan of GSP, I'll be the first to admit that it would be the smaller bleeder vs the bigger non bleeder, and that Jon Jones is better than both.

 

[VAfan]

This ubersimpleton sherbro analysis didnt hold up at first glance, but much less after seeing GSP badly struggling inside Bisping's guard and actually taking more damage than he delivered there

and you just exposed yourself as a total moron. gsp prime was not gsp against bisping, not even remotely close, it's so obvious it doesn't need to be said. he was coming off a fucking retirement. try thinking for at least three seconds first before posting.

 

[Yellowcrab]

and you just exposed yourself as a total moron. gsp prime was not gsp against bisping, not even remotely close, it's so obvious it doesn't need to be said. he was coming off a fucking retirement. try thinking for at least three seconds first before posting.

But obviously, Bisping was even more in his prime than GSP at 38 years old and only seeing with one eye, right ?

 

[VAfan]

But obviously, Bisping was even more in his prime than GSP at 38 years old and only seeing with one eye, right ?

so what the hell does that mean? because bisping was shot means that gsp in his prime would have done worse???

 

[Yellowcrab]

so what the hell does that mean? because bisping was shot means that gsp in his prime would have done worse???

So what's wrong in this message ? : https://forums.sherdog.com/threads/...-clear-mma-goat.4293892/page-2#post-171241073

Because if anything, Bisping was the more washed out fighter among both.

Hence why your prime excuse is irrelevant.

 

[Killer Kadoogan]

It would have helped GSP's claim to the GOAT status, more than Anderson's since GSP would have been going up in weight technically.

 

[suffersystem]

I honestly think GSP COULD have won against Silva, but I would not have put money on it. I thought Bisping was going to beat him and was proven wrong.

 

[VAfan]

So what's wrong in this message ? : https://forums.sherdog.com/threads/...-clear-mma-goat.4293892/page-2#post-171241073

Because if anything, Bisping was the more washed out fighter among both.

wow. some serious comprehension issues here. the problem is that he's trying to prove gsp would have done badly at MW in his prime because he struggled somewhat against bisping when he was old. and those are apples and oranges. why in the world that's hard to understand is beyond me. whatever gsp did against bsiping has no bearing on what he would have done in his prime. his TDs were literally unstoppable and if you don't believe that you need to go back and rewatch the fights.

 

[pankrat]

and you just exposed yourself as a total moron. gsp prime was not gsp against bisping, not even remotely close, it's so obvious it doesn't need to be said. he was coming off a fucking retirement. try thinking for at least three seconds first before posting.

The cheap "prime" excuse doesnt work here, much less vs the older Bisping.

If you dont understand why GSP would have big trouble handling the bigger and longer Silva in the ground you just show a painfully simpleton understanding of this sport which is sad coming from a guy who has been logged in a mma forum for so long.
GSP did understand it, that's why he refused the opportunity of such a boost in money and legacy. And I dont blame him.

BTW, Condit headkicked GSP not in the first nor the second rd but in the 3rd and you dont need to be very bright to understand that the chances Silva lands a definitive blow of that kind are much higher than Condit's, in any round.