- Joined
- Oct 6, 2008
- Messages
- 32,883
- Reaction score
- 41,992
The “supplements” should have disqualified from competing.Except that’s just a girl on a bunch of roids prescribed by her doctor. Both were born female here.
The “supplements” should have disqualified from competing.Except that’s just a girl on a bunch of roids prescribed by her doctor. Both were born female here.
That poor girl is learning the difference between men and women.
There's no underlying logic to that position. And such double standard enforcement would still be a blatant case of discrimination by definition.
The story has been done to death but I'll break it down again. Beggs took hormones to transition to being a man, the Texas UIL rules say you have to wrestle in the division of your birth certificate. Beggs said they requested to wrestle the boys and were denied, the UIL said they never received a request and would have made an exception if they had.
I'm genuinely surprised so many people who are concerned about this kind of stuff are unaware of this, it pops up at least once every year and hangs around for a month or so.
Well, yeah.The “supplements” should have disqualified from competing.
He is competing against people of his own biological sex. He's a trans man who wanted to compete in the men's division but wasn't allowed to.Maybe they should update the rules to say you have to compete against people of the same SEX (not gender).
Since you can't change your sex (currently, who knows how confusing it'll get with shit like CRISPR around...)
Exactly correctThe “supplements” should have disqualified from competing.
He is competing against people of his own biological sex. He's a trans man who wanted to compete in the men's division but wasn't allowed to.
Let's also be clear that the UIL rule was adopted after Beggs had started wrestling boys. Beggs was in the boys division, and then UIL put Beggs in the girls division.The story has been done to death but I'll break it down again. Beggs took hormones to transition to being a man, the Texas UIL rules say you have to wrestle in the division of your birth certificate. Beggs said they requested to wrestle the boys and were denied, the UIL said they never received a request and would have made an exception if they had.
I'm genuinely surprised so many people who are concerned about this kind of stuff are unaware of this, it pops up at least once every year and hangs around for a month or so.
That's kind of exactly what happened.Maybe they should update the rules to say you have to compete against people of the same SEX (not gender).
Since you can't change your sex (currently, who knows how confusing it'll get with shit like CRISPR around...)
The story has been done to death but I'll break it down again. Beggs took hormones to transition to being a man, the Texas UIL rules say you have to wrestle in the division of your birth certificate. Beggs said they requested to wrestle the boys and were denied, the UIL said they never received a request and would have made an exception if they had.
I'm genuinely surprised so many people who are concerned about this kind of stuff are unaware of this, it pops up at least once every year and hangs around for a month or so.
Do you have a source for that? I know Beggs wrestled the boys in youth because there wasn't a divide.Let's also be clear that the UIL rule was adopted after Beggs had started wrestling boys. Beggs was in the boys division, and then UIL put Beggs in the girls division.
It's not clear to me that UIL even had a way to apply for exceptions. The first time they mentioned the possibility is when the parents of female wrestlers sued them.
Not really hilarious from the female athlete's point of view.The Texas rule is in place to prevent "Boys" who identify as Girls from wrestling in the Girl's division. We've all seen the hilarity that ensues when that happens.
The girls get destroyed by the transgenders...
He is an ex-woman though. It seems Texan conservatives wanted to ban male-to-female trans from steamrolling girls but shot themselves in the foot.
You need wrestle according to your birth certificate, and that dude who was born a girl said, great.
I'm confused.
So, born a woman, took hormones to transition to a dude, but still wrestles women?
Aren't there steroids in inhalers for people with asthma?Steroids are illegal for high school comp. So she is a cheater.
What a hero.https://www.menshealth.com/trending-news/a33984383/mack-beggs-transgender-wrestler-interview/
In viral clips of his winning matches, you can hear both boos and cheers from the crowd. But Beggs has always kept his game face on. “It didn’t really affect me, because I was like, ‘I don’t care. I won,’ ” he says with a shrug on a Zoom call. “You can’t make people love you at the end of the day.”
---------------------------------------------------------
My question is why is someone who is a freshmen in high school allowed to start sexually transitioning? Shouldn't it be 18 or over?
Ah, that's what I was confused by, since the reg passed after that.Do you have a source for that? I know Beggs wrestled the boys in youth because there wasn't a divide.
Texas missed the mark requiring all trans athletes to compete in their birth gender division. So that’s not necessarily this persons fault.
should be all trans athletes compete in the male division. That way girls just compete against natural girls