For fucks sake, so many dumb answers.
No, I don't consider Silva the GOAT, but he has the best striking defense ever in MMA.
By far... it is not even a contest.
Until his lost to Weidman, he had:
- 37 MMA fights (that's a lot);
- 4 losses; I may be wrong but all of them didn't evolve losing by striking;
- 16 UFC fights, all wins
- I don't remember having one single round in UFC where he lost due to striking
- I don't remember him having face damage in those fights
Now, the answers here:
- Khabib - lol, most of his fights went to the ground
- Jones - top striking defense, but only 28 fights, 3 of them were controversial wins, his face looked fucked up/destroyed/raped after Gus 1 (I don't remember seeing this in Silva);
- Adesanya - nope, too few fights and he got fucked up in the Gas fight. Also, he lost due to striking in the Jan fight.
- Gane - too few fights
- Poirier - nope, he got finished by striking in his prime
- other dumb answers
Aldo and Moose have top striking but not as good as Silva, though.
It's Silva, deal with it!
And is not a "who is the goat" type of question, it's pretty fucking clear.
It's like asking who is the best bjj guy in MMA at HW. It's not a contest, it's Werdum.
Or who is the sexiest fighter. Not a contest. KTNXBYE
Edit: no homo