I can tell you are highly passionate about what constitutes good footwork and that’s just like your opinion man.
Maybe I meant to say was fighters who have quick feet, move a lot, and rely on their movement and feints to fight. If it’s not subtle, efficient footwork like you claimed. Someone like Amir Khan.
As it was said before, some of Willie Peps footwork and patterns was adapted to mma. Not directly translated.
But I think people with quick feet and movement have great footwork, even if it’s not the most efficient. It’s highly effective for a lot of people’s unorthodox styles.
Quick, active, feet and movement is very hard to deal with, yes it does takes a lot of athleticism and conditioning. I consider it great footwork. You call it what you want.
He has the most title fight wins in BW history and is one of a very very few UFC champs ever to regain his belt and defend successfully in his 2nd title reign.
It was definitely effective. He ruled a very athletic division over a decent time period.
It was also very polarizing, and I think that is reflected in the comments here, with some people imo letting their emotions get the better of them.
In my opinion, he changed the game, and that is worthy of note. He brought a lot of attention to mma footwork and use of angles on entry and exit and demonstrated how to use these things as a form of effective defense.
I think TJ began the evolution by taking elements he picked up while mimicking Dom in TAM camps and then adapting it into his own much more offensive version.
eventually I HOPE we wind up seeing something along the lines of a "Lomachenko of MMA" where someone truly masters how to use footwork defensively (like prime Dom) and offensively, like TJ showed flashes of...
I think the potential is there for something beautiful to come along.
*TJ trained with Lomachenko too, so he had at least some exposure to that style of boxing footwork, but not that insane long term footwork foundation that Lomachenko's dad instilled in Loma and Usyk. Particularly the cross training, the dance, etc
I wouldnt say it "random nonsense" - I mean he knew where his body weight was shifted so he react of that impulse in a seemingly instinctive style. Kind of like feints with his feat keeping opponents guessing where his shifts are at. i remember seeing a guy break down Cruzs dart strategies and it was anything but random. Im not even the hugest Cruz fan and alot of his looping hooks were Not good but it wasnt just 'meaningless that anyone could do either'
Cruz himself said he used approximately 8 segments or patterns, which he then mixed up and combined.
A chess board has 8 squares up by 8 across, and literally millions upon millions of possibilities, so much so that even with computers tracking millions of games all over the world for years, each game reaches a point, often fairly early on, where that exact combination of moves has never been played before in recorded history and a "new territory" is reached.
Point being even within set of just 8, it is easy to quickly attain exponential combinations
So... for arguments sake, even if Cruz was "random" with the way he combined his 8 movements, he is still doing something effective by creating a situation in which there is a level of "chaos" and "unpredictability" where he is moving 3 dimensionally, providing exceptional natural defensive head movement simply by way of a "randomly" moving target in a 3 dimensional plane
AND
He has a natural advantage because within that chaos he created, HE knew where he was going.
even if he only knew it a split second before it happened, that is a split second where he knew where he was going to be and his opponent didn't.
The result of this?
During his prime he was the statistically least hit fighter in BW history.
Of course there were tradeoffs.
1- I maintain he gave up most of whatever power he may have had.
( later in his career he did KO Mizugaki, he dropped Faber several times and busted up Mighty Mouses jaw, so maybe there was more power than he gets credit for)
2- heavily taxing on his body
He rode it till the wheels came off.
And the wheels came off early, shortening his prime and leaving his peak physical years riddled with major knee and foot I
injuries, multiple ACL tears and plantar's facsciitis