Social Asian American rejected from 16/18 colleges despite 4.2 GPA and 1590 SAT score.

LOL. Check the statistics I've shared. Relative to Asians, it's both, but blacks are afforded an even more profound bias. It varies from school to school.

Furthermore, for the very reason apologists of affirmative action have tried to raise in this thread, that the overall value of an applicant's resume as universities judge is complex, with test scores and GPA being the most important, even someone whose test scores are in the 99.9% percentile will lose a spot to this racist preferential treatment. Because there are only limited spots for universities to afford. There will always be candidates who fall at the very bottom of the cutoff between acceptance and rejection. Affirmative action consumes spots, and so this cutoff is shifted to make room, and those who are lost due to this shift are the victims of affirmative action-- of racism. This ladder from top to bottom isn't linearly assigned according to test scores and GPA, though the correlation to a candidate's ranking will be more closely tied to that, generally, than any other applicant statistic. Anyone who loses a spot is the victim of discrimination, and for Asians in this group, there are likely candidates of all races ahead of them to which they unfairly lost their candidacy. And stolen they are as the data I've shared demonstrates via mathematical proof. Per spots stolen by an specific racial group, it doesn't matter if it is many spots or only a few spots we are discussing that are robbed. Just a little racism isn't okay.

LOL at this hilarious shift to "just a little racism isn't okay" and throwing around "apologists of affirmative action." You couldn't be a bigger donkey if you tried.

Stick to your guns, numbnuts. No one is making apologies for anything. We're simply asking you to prove your own claims.

Still waiting for anyone, especially @Madmick, to provide any realistic demographics model they want for student applications that would lead to someone in the academic top 0.1% being rejected based on racism with a resulting black student population of 0.75%.

black-man.gif
 
its not very intelligent to look at a single case when data for many thousands are available.

SATs and GPA arent the only things colleges look at. Im sure you could find many asian americans with the same or worse stats in those two fields that got accepted into the same schools he applied to this year.

Im asian, had like a 3.3 and like a 1400 SAT and got into like 5 of the schools listed. The personal statement portion and applying on time are other very important factors.

some of these schools indeed implement a system that inherently discriminates for less represented populations, and therefore must discriminate against overrepresented populations, but the effects are no where near as severe as this single case would suggest.

Exactly. Drawing sweeping conclusions based on a single case without even looking at all the potential factors is idiotic.

It's not surprising that the people who actually went to university have an unbiased and realistic viewpoint of the situation.
 
LOL at this hilarious shift to "just a little racism isn't okay" and throwing around "apologists of affirmative action." You couldn't be a bigger donkey if you tried.

Stick to your guns, numbnuts. No one is making apologies for anything. We're simply asking you to prove your own claims.

Still waiting for anyone, especially @Madmick, to provide any realistic demographics model they want for student applications that would lead to someone in the academic top 0.1% being rejected based on racism with a resulting black student population of 0.75%.

black-man.gif

So the fact he was rejected from 16/18 schools despite being in the .0001% of all high school graduates academically isn't proof enough that racism exists against Asian American students ? Being a cynical troll isn't getting you very far in this thread. You're rightfully getting taken to the woodshed for your views.

It's been fun and sad watching you try and justify racism against Asian Americans.

https://www.highereddive.com/news/a...dmissions-disadvantage-white-students/690152/
 
Last edited:
So the fact he was rejected from 16/18 schools despite being in the .0001% of all high school graduates academically isn't proof enough that racism exists against Asian American students ? Being a cynical troll isn't getting you very far in this thread. You're rightfully getting taken to the woodshed for your views.

It's been fun and sad watching you try and justify racism against Asian Americans.

https://www.highereddive.com/news/a...dmissions-disadvantage-white-students/690152/

I knew you were upset but couldn't actually form any arguments. Now that your racism claim has been debunked for this particular student, and your thread has been proven idiotic, you're trying to speak up to save face.

<36>

Now you can enjoy being taken to the "woodshed."

Answer the simple question. Provide any realistic demographics model you want for student applications that would lead to someone in the academic top 0.0001% being rejected based on racism with a resulting black student population of 0.75%.

Do you have copies of his applications? Any other info besides his test scores and GPA? Nope.

Enjoy being a donkey and a ridiculous troll. LOL.
 
Our own justice department has found that Yale discriminates against Asians and whites on the grounds of race.

Ample examples of evidence have already been provided in this thread substantiating that the most likely culprit this student's application fell below any given university's cutoff was due to his race. No other reasonable explanation rooted in evidence has been offered.
 
Admission to universities, especially the best ones, is based on more than high school marks and SAT scores. I'd need to see his applications before judging. I wouldn't be all that surprised if he gave zero effort on things like essays etc.

To immediately make it about race without using any form of critical thinking is par for the course on Sherdog though.

<36>

He could come apply to some of the state schools where I live. They'll take you with a 14 ACT score lol. No SAT even required.
 
Our own justice department has found that Yale discriminate against Asians and whites on the grounds of race.

Ample examples of evidence have already been provided in this thread substantiating that the most likely culprit this student's application fell below any given university's cutoff was due to his race. No other reasonable explanation rooted in evidence has been offered.

Try hitting the reply button to quote me directly. I know you're a bit timid now after this discussion but you can at least try to muster some courage.

Still waiting for anyone, especially @Madmick, to provide any realistic demographics model they want for student applications that would lead to someone in the academic top 0.1% being rejected based on racism with a resulting black student population of 0.75%.

wink-obama.gif
 
Seeing as how I'm Asian American

Ah, so here it is.

Hey bud, posting on your 25th Sherdog account isn't going to get you out of McDonald's and into university. Neither is crying about a student in the academic "0.0001%" being rejected from schools with large Asian populations.

Learn some critical thinking and maybe you'll pull yourself out of your unhappy situation ;)
 
Ah, so here it is.

Hey bud, posting on your 25th Sherdog account isn't going to get you out of McDonald's and into university. Neither is crying about a student in the academic "0.0001%" being rejected from schools with large Asian populations.

Learn some critical thinking and maybe you'll pull yourself out of your unhappy situation ;)

Just admit you're fine with being a bigot. It's a trait leftists have long embraced. You're getting all worked up and defensive. Just accept who you are, and what you've chosen to support.
 
Just admit you're fine with being a bigot. It's a trait leftists have long embraced. You're getting all worked up and defensive. Just accept who you are, and what you've chosen to support.

Ah yes, when you're an idiot and have no argument for anything you throw around "bigot" and "leftist." No one said racial preference doesn't exist, dumbass. We're talking about this specific case and the lack of information provided.

Why are you unable to answer a simple question?

Provide any realistic demographics model you want for student applications that would lead to someone in the academic top 0.0001% being rejected based on racism with a resulting black student population of 0.75%. Oh and keep in mind the Asian student population is 14%.

<36>

Lol at being this upset that you're a complete can.
 
Ah yes, when you're an idiot and have no argument for anything you throw around "bigot" and "leftist." No one said racial preference doesn't exist, dumbass. Lol at being this upset that you're a complete can.

You are clearly gotten to. You're just throwing personal insults at this point because the facts aren't on your side. Looks like you're the one who's upset, kid. LOL
 
You are clearly gotten to. You're just throwing personal insults at this point because the facts aren't on your side. Looks like you're the one who's upset, kid. LOL

Uh huh. "Gotten to" is running in here crying and calling people "bigots" because you realized your thread is stupid ;)

When someone starts throwing around "kid" without being able to answer any questions you know it must be a rough day flipping burgers. LOL.
 
Uh huh. You ran in here crying and calling people "bigots" because you realized your thread is stupid ;)

When someone starts throwing around "kid" without being able to answer any questions you know it must be a rough day flipping burgers. LOL.

giphy.gif
 


Just admit you're fine with being a bigot

wink-obama.gif


Stay mad forever.

<36>

Don't forget to try and constructively contribute to your own thread.

Provide any realistic demographics model you want for student applications that would lead to someone in the academic top 0.0001% being rejected based on racism with a resulting black student population of 0.75%. Oh and keep in mind the Asian student population is 14%.
 
Just admit you're fine with being a bigot. It's a trait leftists have long embraced. You're getting all worked up and defensive. Just accept who you are, and what you've chosen to support.
Your thread got dunked on m8. Lol
 
It's obvious, particularly from the responses of most universities in the wake of the recent SC ruling, that discrimination-based-on-raced is a generally-accepted practice among college admissions boards. Those who deny racist practices are integrated into the admissions process, are willfully ignorant(however much they want to cling to the "they don't interview well" argument).

The real question is, as a society, do we think the ends justify the means. That is, is having a more equitable society worth the ethical cost of eliminating opportunities from many deserving students.

And as another poster pointed out; legacy admissions are inherently not fair/meritocratic, and unlike AA, there is no rationale based on a lack of background advantages, historical oppression, or the pursuit of a more equitable society, to be made for them. It's a practice that we should be past, as a society.
 
Last edited:
Admission to universities, especially the best ones, is based on more than high school marks and SAT scores. I'd need to see his applications before judging. I wouldn't be all that surprised if he gave zero effort on things like essays etc.

To immediately make it about race without using any form of critical thinking is par for the course on Sherdog though.

<36>
Damn those asians ,making everything about race all the time while making 0 effort.
 
Back
Top