All Time GOAT poll

[TempleoftheDog]

Yes let’s make it simple.

The Stipe that beat Ngannou beats any version of Fedor. Feel free to prove me wrong.

 

[El Fernas]

Jake shields is the GOAT!
View attachment 841902

Has Shields ever stopped someone from GnP? To this day that has to be the softest GnP ever shown by professional male MMA athlete.

 

[MartinGibson86]

7 years ranked #1
7 consecutive title fight wins
7 top 5 wins
7 victories over Pride/UFC champions

@hbombfromhell

Those UFC champs:

Coleman...12 years older than Fedor...literally a style vs style fighter...won the title from Dan Severn

Randleman...finished in 2 of 3 prior to Fedor...never won a meaningful fight after...won the title from Mo Smith and lost in his first defense...only 6 years older than Fedor---but hey, its unfair to compare Fedor go Stipe, Cain, JDS, or DC right?

Nog---interim champ...shouldnt have fought for it in the first place...Mir had already broken Sylvias arm and destroyed Nog when they fought

Mir and Rampage---B league fights dont count...

Sylvia and AA great wins that he deserves all the credit in the world for.

Champions Reem has beaten: Bork, Werdum, Mir, JDS, AA...

Reems list is way better

 

[dipstickjimmy]

Khabib has 29-0

More MMAth for you.
29-0 *155 = 4495

Fedor's 28 * 206 (min weight for a HW) = 5768

 

[dschinghiskhan1]

No. Fedor had some decent wins but also fought a lot of cans. And who were his best wins? Nogueira and Cro Cop? Guys that couldn't get through mir and Schaub? Lol. What else? 100 year old Coleman? Kevin Randleman? uhh...Heath Herring. Two one dimensional wrestlers and a guy who could sometimes land a knee but was otherwise just a random bum.

 

[Barteh]

Not sure who are worse posters on this forum. Fedorcels or GSPcels.

 

[bigwaverider]

7 years ranked #1
7 consecutive title fight wins
7 top 5 wins
7 victories over Pride/UFC champions

@hbombfromhell

I think it's safe to say Fedor has 9 victories over UFC/Pride champs. He beat both Antônio Rodrigo Nogueira and Mark Coleman twice.

 

[mmacrisis]

Its Bruce Lee... someone had to say it...

 

[lsa]

I think you are a goat.

I think you smell like one

 

[Viper2]

Sherdog should have a separate "FEDOR THE GOAT" forum.

Who agrees?

 

[TCE]

No, because he's not.

 

[RemyR]

Fedor

 

[HHJ]

To be fair this forum should be a subforum of the Fedor the GOAT forum

 

[Pizza Werewolf]

Ill agree if its a live stream of an actual goat we all chip in and collectively take care of.

 

[Hellowhosthat]

Just a separate GOAT discussion forum imo, it's just the same people having the same arguments over and over again with the only difference being that sometimes people who got banned before are using new accounts.

 

[Viper2]

Has Jon Jones ever admitted that Fedor is the true MMA GOAT?

 

[dipstickjimmy]

PhD level MMAth for you son:
4495/5768 - 0.50 threshold = 0.78-0.50 = 28% is how much Khabib did better than Fedor.

How did this end up in the GOAT poll thread?

Also what is the -.50 threshold?

 

[mattfin]

Yes let’s make it simple.

The Stipe that beat Ngannou beats any version of Fedor. Feel free to prove me wrong.

Ummm....., surely the onus of proof is on the person MAKING the claim. I mean, the Stipe who beat Ngannou was a guy who had VERY SPECIFICALLY trained to beat a cannon fisted power-puncher with no gas tank and zero grappling ability, which is basically the opposite of Fedor. I have no idea how prime Fedor would do against prime Stipe, so if you have some proof of it one way or the other I'd be very interested to listen.

 

[Epicman1324]

This thread needs to be scrapped and an entirely new one needs to be started. Candidates should be
GSP
Fedor
Jones
Silva
Khabib
DJ
Aldo
Stipe (a lot of people put him over Fedor who is arguably the GOAT and that's the only reason he's on there, he's not in my top 10)
Nunes

 

[Epicman1324]

Europeans are often unfairly biased to fellow Europeans, no shock there