All Time GOAT poll

dipstickjimmy said:
Another long winded crock of shit served up by you in short order. Good take. Jon is Goat if he wasn't such a cheat in the cage. Roids and eye pokes go against him. Anderson has the roids and losses. GSP has beaten every man he faced. Had the toughest competition and is the GOAT.

You are going to now tell me about all the "Undefeated" WWs in Craplakistan that are so much better but "Marketing" has us all fooled.
Click to expand...

GSP cheated in the cage too buddy. He used to grease.

You have some serious double standards there.
 
ThunderStruck said:
Are you kidding? Was brunson even top 10? Bisping was top 3 in ALL MMA media, number 1 MW in MOST MMA medias.

And it was a WW vs a MW.

And thats not even talking about how Silva VS Brunson was one a big robbery.
Click to expand...

Bisping was the MW champion with the least top wins since Evan Tanner.

Dude was a gatekeeper who fluked an elite fighter.
 
Ufcmaster said:
I don't believe GSP was ever ranked p4p nr.1 I believe. Or maybe just for a few months
Click to expand...
He was for a few months because Andy lost in mid 2013 and GSP and Hendricks fight was late 2013 if I remember. Aldo and jones would be 2 and 3 at that point
 
Claude said:
Bisping was the MW champion with the least top wins since Evan Tanner.

Dude was a gatekeeper who fluked an elite fighter.
Click to expand...

Bisping is so underrated by dummies like you who has nothing but an agenda to make your favourite fighter (Fedor) look better. He was on a very solid win streak against the likes of Silva, Rockhold and Hendo.

Call it a fluke, i call you an idiot.

I get your biased stupid logic though :

Serra vs GSP I, Fluke or not? Your logic : It makes GSP look bad so not a fluke.
Weidman vs Silva I and II : Your logic : It makes Silva look bad so not a fluke of course.
Bisping VS Rockhold II : Your logic : It makes GSP looks good so of course it was a fluke.
Fedor vs Kohsaka : Your logic : A Fluke cause it makes Fedor looks bad (BTW not a fluke elbow was as legit as it gets).
 
Still GOAT St-Pierre.
Never popped, all his defeats avenged in dominant fashion, fought in the deepest division and beat a murder row of opponents like they were children, two divisions champion, etc, etc.
 
morrisondafalln said:
He was scared any other of the top 5 mw would raped him. Lol. Dude refused to defend the mw belt. But is considering fighting a way smaller fighter in kahbib. But let gsp fans tell it lol
Click to expand...
Didn't call him out. Khabib called for that fight. Also, the size difference between them vs gsp silva is way closer
 
ThunderStruck said:
Bisping is so underrated by dummies like you who has nothing but an agenda to make your favourite fighter (Fedor) look better. He was on a very solid win streak against the likes of Silva, Rockhold and Hendo.

Call it a fluke, i call you an idiot.

I get your biased stupid logic though :

Serra vs GSP I, Fluke or not? Your logic : It makes GSP look bad so not a fluke.
Weidman vs Silva I and II : Your logic : It makes Silva look bad so not a fluke of course.
Bisping VS Rockhold II : Your logic : It makes GSP looks good so of course it was a fluke.
Fedor vs Kohsaka : Your logic : A Fluke cause it makes Fedor looks bad (BTW not a fluke elbow was as legit as it gets).
Click to expand...

Silva and Hendo were not even top fighters.

Bisping was gatekeeper with a fluke elite win.
 
Claude said:
Fedor lost after 10 years.
GSP lost in his 2nd and 5th year.

Big difference.
Click to expand...

He lost his 5th pro fight in a lower org.

And if you don't consider Fedor in his prime at 33 years old then GSP wasn't in his prime at 25 years old either.
 
Claude said:
Silva and Hendo were not even top fighters.

Bisping was gatekeeper with a fluke elite win.
Click to expand...

How many top fighters did Fedor beat? I don't even think he beat 10 top 10 fighters.

Nog x 2
CC
AA
Sylvia
Herring?
Rogers?
Schilt?
Old ass Coleman?
Hunt?

Half of those are very fringe top 10.

You know you're a can crusher when you have only 10 top 10 wins in a nearly 20 years career.
 
ThunderStruck said:
He lost his 5th pro fight in a lower org.

And if you don't consider Fedor in his prime at 33 years old then GSP wasn't in his prime at 25 years old either.
Click to expand...

Age =/= prime.

GSP was in his 5th year when he was beaten by Serra. By all means in his prime.

He wasn't in his prime vs. Hendricks.
 
ThunderStruck said:
How many top fighters did Fedor beat? I don't even think he beat 10 top 10 fighters.

Nog x 2
CC
AA
Sylvia
Herring?
Rogers?
Schilt?
Old ass Coleman?
Hunt?

Half of those are very fringe top 10.

You know you're a can crusher when you have only 10 top 10 wins in a nearly 20 years career.
Click to expand...

12 to 15 depending on the rankings.

And no losses to cans while he was #1, unlike GSP.

Cheers.
 
Fedor would have kicked the shit out of GSP in George’s prime. I guess manlets need to have a goat too tho
 
Ufcmaster said:
Did some research to see if GSP was ranked p4p #1 after the Silva loss. Seems Jones was ranked #1 by majority of publications who make such rankings. Poor George was unfortunately never ever ranked p4p #1 ...


Official UFC rankings voted by media

http://www.mma-stats.com/rankings/2013-07-09

Silva was ranked p4p #1 in June of 2013
Jones was then ranked p4p #1 in Juli of 2013 and stayed #1 for the rest of 2013.



Even Sherdog had Jones p4p #1 after Silva lost to Chris lol

https://www.google.com/amp/s/m.sherdog.com/news/rankings/Sherdogcoms-PoundforPound-Top-10-53757/amp




MMA Junkie had Jones #1 after Silva lost

https://www.google.com/amp/s/mmajun...son-silva-still-mmas-pound-for-pound-best/amp
Click to expand...
Wow, that's surprising.

Georges deserved #1 tho, he was dominating fights aside from a few scares here and there, like the Condit head kick. Jones was only champ for 2 years or so at that point
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,280,651
Messages
58,307,761
Members
175,999
Latest member
joshvegas

Share this page

Back
Top