All Time GOAT poll

[Mike]

so you guys won't put Cormier on the same level as Jones, GSP, Silva?

How can we when he doesn't have the resume for it?

 

[Mike]

Are you trolling?

That or he's only been watching a few years. Woodley isn't in the conversation at all lol.

 

[TGArthur]

In before 500 pages of yelling

You are the wizard

 

[Takes Two To Tango]

GSP according to the sticky All Time GOAT poll is considered the best on here. But I'd like to see where everyone else ranks him though.

 

[EVIL WAR GOD]

#1 Jon Jones

#2/3 GSP/Fedor

 

[Get To Da Choppa]

Accomplishment wise, behind Jones and Anderson.

Overall reputation, record, legacy and the admiration of Sherdoggers, probably top 2 along with Fedor

 

[hoevan]

# 1


isn't even arguable unless you're braindead honestly, steroid cheats are disqualified from the discussion.

Mighty Mouse.

 

[MartinGibson86]

Not more impressive than Fedor's overall career

If GSP hadn't run away then he would be taking losses in his 30th+ fight too

Fedor's 18th professional fight was against a winless fighter.

 

[hoevan]

lol okay.


nice AV.

What's funny? Its not a fair point to bring MM into the conversation, especially given that he too was/is a clean fighter?

 

[Bouboumaster]

GOAT St-Pierre still in the lead, as he should be.

 

[BBJ]

Since they all have amazing achivements. I am going for Anderson on the shere fact, that he did things in the octogon that where at the time consideret impossible. None of the other GOATs have blown my mind away as Anderson

 

[Gearc10]

Having Johnson over Aldo is dishespetchful. He beat mainly men equivalents of soccer moms.

Having both over Conor is a joke. He killed FW in spectacular fashion, won LW belt and won twice at WW.

 

[Adamant]

Fedor is easily #1 all time.

Then:

GSP
Jones
Silva
Khabib

 

[Mike]

What's funny? Its not a fair point to bring MM into the conversation, especially given that he too was/is a clean fighter?

It's fair, but most people just aren't going to think a champ of a young and developing division is the goat. Coming from a big MM fan.

 

[hoevan]

It's fair, but most people just aren't going to think a champ of a young and developing division is the goat. Coming from a big MM fan.

Doesn't matter. He is the most well rounded fighter of the sports inception. He is P4P GOAT.

 

[Mike]

Doesn't matter. He is the most well rounded fighter of the sports inception. He is P4P GOAT.

Being well rounded isn't the only metric to consider though. He is incredibly well rounded tho. Like I said, I've been a MM fan for years

 

[GOATtalks]

1. GSP
2. Jones
3. Silva
4. Fedor
5. Khabib
6. Johnson
7. Aldo
8. Cormier
9. Adesanya
10. McGregor

Not bad actually. I have it

1. Jones
2. GSP
3. Silva
4. Johnson
5. Khabib
6. Stipe
7. Cormier
8. Fedor
9. McGregor
10. Cejudo

 

[Steve08]

Fedor

 

[Jack Bauer]

is there any rational arguments that GSP fans can say that justifies putting him above Silva and Jones?

He didnt get caught taking PEDs like the other two. Jones in particular had unusual results (really low testosterone, indicating he was masking) before getting caught. Record wise they are all very comparable and i have no issues with fans finding Anderson or Jones more impressive. But they both got caught while GSP fought for better drug testing, did it on his own, and came back after 4 years under USADA and won the belt.

 

[ThunderStruck]

is there any rational arguments that GSP fans can say that justifies putting him above Silva and Jones?

Yes, many.