All Time GOAT poll

[RicardinhoPT]

Asking this right after someone retires, not subjective at all...

 

[MR.HUNT]

St.Pierre got my vote,

 

[Perrichet]

lols at jones, a proven cheater on the list.
why is gracie not there. won the openweight title as a lw.

Anderson shouldn’t be on the list either tbh although he has got so little votes it probably doesn’t make a difference

 

[ChangeIsComing]

Had to choose between Fedor and GSP...and went with Fedor.

 

[Sour Dieselnoi]

GSP might be considered goat on paper, but he ducked Anderson Silva, who was considered the p4p best fighter in the world during his legendary win streak in the UFC.

I personally consider Fedor, Jones, Silva, & Aldo above GSP.

 

[Perrichet]

lol Anderson lives rent-free in your head.
Get a life

 

[Greg House]

Crazy how low Anderson is. 10 years ago this place was all about Anderson-GSP-Fedor for this discussion.

Fedor haters: Bad quality of opposition
GSP haters: Doesn't finish fights and is terrified of the superfight with Anderson
Anderson haters: He lost to some bums in japan before coming to the UFC.

Fast forward 10 years and most of Anderson fans have obviously jumped ship to either GSP or Jones. I wonder why, Anderson is adding losses to his career, but so is Fedor and it doesnt seem to matter for him. Anderson beat more ranked fighters than Jones and Fedor and was ranked P4P number 1 the mayority of the time of GSP's reign.

Poor Anderson. History has forgotten him :/

 

[Taric]

GSP didn't retire at 32, he retired at 37. He just took a long ass break.

I mean, Michael Jordan retired like 6 times....

A huge part of having a great career is knowing when to quit.

Also, GOAT is career spanning and not just primes. The whole thing gets factored in.

The problem with this mindset is that you are giving GSP credit for not competing... Let me say that again. GSP has literally increased his stock value in your eyes by not fighting at all... Not winning. By not even competing... That is absurd.

Please tell me all the other sports on this earth where an individual or team not competing is considered a good thing.

 

[Perrichet]

This poll just proves how many bias Canadians are on Sherdog. Pro fighters confirmed Fedor and Silva to be the GOATs.

Lol

 

[I WILL CUT YOU]

Tj is the p4p goat.

 

[I WILL CUT YOU]

Imagine being this pathetic

Strawman and dancing around grammar.

 

[I WILL CUT YOU]

Sarcasm, because posters think Jon Jones is only good because he is tall with reach.

Grove and Roop are tall with reach, yet are not GOAT candidates, showing that it is Jon's skill at using his length, and not just length, that makes him GOAT material.

This backfired spectacularly for you, kid.

How gotten to are you, that you are scouring my post history for anything that can erase the sting of you calling TJ P4P GOAT a couple months ago?

Lmao lame stuff dude. Lame, lame stuff.

 

[I WILL CUT YOU]

It's called taking words out of context and strawman. You intentionally mistranslate what I said because you can't make a valid argument, it doesn't take a genius to know how pathetic that is and it shows you that you already lost the debate.
When I said tj is the p4p goat, I mean that he's the most skilled fighter of all time. Even the thread titled "Tj is the closest to a perfect fighter"
You lost and got destroyed, get over it.

So the most skilled fighter of all time, got ko'd by Dodson and beat by Cruz?

What's next, you gonna tell me to go back to grade school?

 

[I WILL CUT YOU]

Strawman again, pathetic and sad

That's not a straw man. You're arguing TJ was P4P goat, and I'm saying he isn't based on losses.

I'm directly countering your argument, I'm not inventing a new argument that you didn't say.

You don't even know what a straw man fallacy is, you've just seen people use it and thought it was cool. Like the term "GOAT". Because if you knew what GOAT meant, you'd stop calling Dillashaw the GOAT.

 

[L0ki]

I mean, Michael Jordan retired like 6 times....


The problem with this mindset is that you are giving GSP credit for not competing... Let me say that again. GSP has literally increased his stock value in your eyes by not fighting at all... Not winning. By not even competing... That is absurd.

Please tell me all the other sports on this earth where an individual or team not competing is considered a good thing.

I sure didn't.

Where I do give him credit on, is winning.

He beat every fighter he ever fought, which goes a pretty long way in determining GOAT.

 

[MusterX]

Lmao at Jones fanboy still lurking in this thread, talking shit and pretending Jones is relevant in the GOAT talk..

Jones is running 3rd All-Time right now, amidst a PED scandal. Not only is he relevant despite the PED's, I think you are going to be shocked when you realize that every title fight he wins is going to act to push him higher over time.

 

[gunsblazingmode]

/thread

 

[Irishhandbomb]

just got GSP to 666

 

[Costacurta greece]

Where is my boy elias theodorou

 

[Todd498]

Lmao at Jones fanboy still lurking in this thread, talking shit and pretending Jones is relevant in the GOAT talk..

They try so hard don’t they? It’s like they think by saying their dumb shit over and over again people will eventually go with it.