All Time GOAT poll

the ambush said:
The clip is GSP right in the middle of his prime and battling Jason Miller to a decision win. Sums up a lot
Click to expand...

I mean, in the middle of his prime (way older than the green GSP from that fight) Anderson Silva was losing to guys much worse than Mayhem Miller, who was an elite grappler in his prime.
Better to completely dominate them and break their nose than tapping out to them, right?






Such a shame Anderson ducked GSP after bragging to Dana White that he could make 170 easily. <DCrying> what could have been...

Did he realize too late that his crazy steroids addiction prevented him from ever going back to WW?

‘When the guys test for the steroids, (they should have) no more fights, when you use the steroids, you use them for a long time. When you use the steroids for a long time, you have a problem. It’s a drug and it’s not good for the sport.’


‘(Steroids) make the sport bad,if you do the sport in a good light, you have a good life. That is my opinion.’


KARMA IS REAL??? <30>
 
chimpoehurricane said:
Gsp ducked Silva.

Gsp ducked Hendrix rematch. Tapped to strikes.

Started the crotch sniff era.

Koscheck had a busted eye socket and gsp played paddy cake for 25min.

Gsp ducked.



ohhhh.gif


You what sparky?
Click to expand...

Considering we found out just a few years later Anderson Silva was dirty. What exactly would a victory over GSP have meant in terms of legacy in retrospect? Probably not much.
 
Dbreiden83080 said:
Considering we found out just a few years later Anderson Silva was dirty. What exactly would a victory over GSP have meant in terms of legacy in retrospect? Probably not much.
Click to expand...

It didn't stop Bisping fighting hendo, Silva, vitro, among other juicers /gear /trt.

It's not an argument. There's was 0 proof back then. Dana simply says gsp didn't want it.

I swear the fans sounded similar at a gsp fight to when Kurt angle wrestles.
 
chimpoehurricane said:
It didn't stop Bisping fighting hendo, Silva, vitro, among other juicers /gear /trt.

It's not an argument. There's was 0 proof back then. Dana simply says gsp didn't want it.

I swear the fans sounded similar at a gsp fight to when Kurt angle wrestles.
Click to expand...
The exact same argument does now and has always applied to Anderson Silva and his refusal to fight Jones. He’s perfectly comfortable taking on somebody that is 4 inches shorter and 20 to 30 pounds lighter. But he wanted no piece of Jones whatsoever.

But in the GOAT Conversation both Jones and Silva have tainted reputations thanks to performance-enhancing drugs. GSP has no such issue. Thus his ranking.
 
chimpoehurricane said:
It's not an argument. There's was 0 proof back then. Dana simply says gsp didn't want it.
Click to expand...

Dana also said that Anderson didn't want it.

You Anderoid fiends always find a way to forget about that part...

(Plus, unlike... "others", GSP wasn't a Dana bootlicker, and White never forgave him for making his boy BJ quit on the stool, so anytime he could talk shit about him he would.)
 
Dbreiden83080 said:
The exact same argument does now and has always applied to Anderson Silva and his refusal to fight Jones. He’s perfectly comfortable taking on somebody that is 4 inches shorter and 20 to 30 pounds lighter. But he wanted no piece of Jones whatsoever.
Click to expand...

the difference is that, Silva didn't duck Jones then fight Glover.

Your bone head argument is flawed.

But in the GOAT Conversation both Jones and Silva have tainted reputations thanks to performance-enhancing drugs. GSP has no such issue. Thus his ranking.
Click to expand...


I don't disagree BUT ducking Hendriks rematch fleeing the sport, fighting Bisping at mw t's but ducked Silva, getting ktfo by Sera a LW that's a foot shorter and tapping to strikes leaves rooms for others to leap frog him for goat status.
 
chimpoehurricane said:
the difference is that, Silva didn't duck Jones then fight Glover
Click to expand...

Worse. Anderson ducked Jones then fought Bonnar at LHW {<jordan}


getting ktfo by Sera a LW that's a foot shorter
Click to expand...
Anderson got mangled by Luiz Azeredo who's 2 feet shorter, tapped to a choke (you know that every Gracie in the crowd were like <{clintugh}> ) from a 2 feet shorter losing record Takase, and tapped like a bongo against FW Ryo Chonan when he was 30 years old.
And he never avenged any of those loses.


In comparison, getting clipped behind the ear by a nothing-to-lose Serra was a massive upset, but not that humiliating considering he put on a flawless performance in the rematch.

Try all you want, there's a reason the scores look like that:

  1. GSP
    2,117 vote(s)
    34.9%

  2. Fedor
    1,584 vote(s)
    26.1%

  3. Silva
    533 vote(s)
    8.8%
<JonesDXSuckIt>
 
chimpoehurricane said:
the difference is that, Silva didn't duck Jones then fight Glover
Click to expand...

If you want to move up you call out the champ and move up.. Silva called out the champ down a weight class and when the topic of fighting Jones came up he said something like this

"We friend"


I don't disagree BUT ducking Hendriks rematch fleeing the sport, fighting Bisping at mw t's but ducked Silva, getting ktfo by Sera a LW that's a foot shorter and tapping to strikes leaves rooms for others to leap frog him for goat status.
Click to expand...

GSP has a few holes in the resume but he plugged those up in rematches. And again when his rep is untainted by outside and inside the cage controversies he enjoys the legacy that Jones and Silva do NOT..
 
the ambush said:
No reason for the name calling, kiddo. You and I just have a difference in opinion, it happens.

Just learn to grow up and accept it
Click to expand...

I thought Dickrider was super mid (I often called myself that here, or a nuthugger), sorry if it troubled you... <DCrying>
 
Dbreiden83080 said:
If you want to move up you call out the champ and move up.. Silva called out the champ down a weight class and when the topic of fighting Jones came up he said something like this

"We friend"




GSP has a few holes in the resume but he plugged those up in rematches. And again when his rep is untainted by outside and inside the cage controversies he enjoys the legacy that Jones and Silva do NOT..
Click to expand...

A lecacy that includes tapping to strikes of a LW a foot shorter, a drumming by Hendriks saved by corrupt judges, fleeing the sport, and returning to fight Bisping with one eye after a career long ducking Silva.

You wut? <Moves>
 
elvismma said:
Fedor or Gsp.
Click to expand...

Fedor ducked ufc, ducked brock, ducked Reem, and got 1punched rd1 by a mw.

Gsp hands down But room for others to leapfrog him due to ducking Silva, Hendrix rematch, and getting clobbered by a LW + tapping to strikes.

It leaves room for the next generation to leap frog him as GOAT.
 
chimpoehurricane said:
Fedor ducked ufc, ducked brock, ducked Reem, and got 1punched rd1 by a mw.

Gsp hands down But room for others to leapfrog him due to ducking Silva, Hendrix rematch, and getting clobbered by a LW + tapping to strikes.

It leaves room for the next generation to leap frog him as GOAT.
Click to expand...
He didn't ducked Silva, Gsp has no business in the middleweight division in the first place.
 
chimpoehurricane said:
Fedor ducked ufc, ducked brock, ducked Reem, and got 1punched rd1 by a mw.

Gsp hands down But room for others to leapfrog him due to ducking Silva, Hendrix rematch, and getting clobbered by a LW + tapping to strikes.

It leaves room for the next generation to leap frog him as GOAT.
Click to expand...
Dana is known for his business practices, and Fedor want none of it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,280,166
Messages
58,262,783
Members
175,985
Latest member
EddiesDirtyCouch

Share this page

Back
Top