Who is the GOAT?

Who is the GOAT?

  • Fedor Emelianenko

  • Jon Jones

  • GSP

  • Mighty Mouse

  • Anderson Silva

  • Chuck Liddell

  • Tyron Woodley

  • Jose Aldo

  • Melvin Guillard


Results are only viewable after voting.
Gsp just had a big win and it’s still pretty close. Let’s see this poll in a year from now or after gsp loses.

Also Fedor still whooped Jon’s ass in votes so you’re still a dick hopping ball squisher

Even before bisping, GOATSP has the most top 5 wins ever at 17. At 36 comes out of retirement to choke unconscious 30-7 mw champion while fedor came out of retirement to fight 2-0 jaideep (now 2-3) despite having offers to come to the ufc to avenge his losses…these are the reasons he is the goat. And never a dick hopper, always said GSP is runner up goat if jones is no longer in the running due to peds. In all honesty fedora shouldn’t even be in the running for goat due to never being tested under usada and fishy 4-5 record in us! Cheers!
 
Damn GSP wins in dominating fashion! Love drinking the tears of my lil fedorists bichs @Claude @Summoning @moreorless87 @myjohnson9 @Typrune Goatley @Shaddows

The time is now!!!!!

It actually shows just how uneducated and fickle new fans like you are.

Just a few months ago you said Jones is the GOAT. Now that he pops and GSP beats the almighty Bisping, suddenly he is the GOAT?

LOL. Pathetic.

I guess the joke is on me though. You are obviously a troll account who wastes his time trying to rile people up. There is no way your IQ could actually be this low
 
It actually shows just how uneducated and fickle new fans like you are.

Just a few months ago you said Jones is the GOAT. Now that he pops and GSP beats the almighty Bisping, suddenly he is the GOAT?

LOL. Pathetic.

I guess the joke is on me though. You are obviously a troll account who wastes his time trying to rile people up. There is no way your IQ could actually be this low

Lol love drinking your tears you lil bich!!!

Jones is still goat if he is in running, if not than it’s gsp. Than it’s Aldo, mm, and fedor. Sorry I speak facts. In all himesty it’s unfair to exclude jones and include fedor in goat talks since fedor was never tested under usada and dishy 4-5 record in the states. Cheers!!!!
 
Fedor never popped for peds.
Fedor never greased.






Fedor.

Fedor held onto the ropes against Lindland.

Its official, there is no goat.

Oh wait there is one : GSP, since it was his corner who greased him. GSP himself commited no foul.
 
It actually shows just how uneducated and fickle new fans like you are.

Just a few months ago you said Jones is the GOAT. Now that he pops and GSP beats the almighty Bisping, suddenly he is the GOAT?

LOL. Pathetic.

I guess the joke is on me though. You are obviously a troll account who wastes his time trying to rile people up. There is no way your IQ could actually be this low

Umm so you see no reason for anyone to change their mind about who the goat is after one guy gets a belt in a higher weight class and the other guy test positive for the third time?
 
Damn GSP wins in dominating fashion! Love drinking the tears of my lil fedorists bichs @Claude @Summoning @moreorless87 @myjohnson9 @Typrune Goatley @Shaddows

The time is now!!!!!

And Jones only beat Guillard for 4 votes.
545393556.0.jpg


<36><36><36><36><36><36><36><36>

You should change your name to "GSPGOAT"
 
fedor was never tested under usada and dishy 4-5 record in the states. Cheers!!!!

What a fucking rookie thing to say.

Fedor won his first 4 fights in the USA.

He did not lose until his 11th year of fighting.

You literally know nothing about MMA
 
Umm so you see no reason for anyone to change their mind about who the goat is after one guy gets a belt in a higher weight class and the other guy test positive for the third time?
I see all that and that is what makes it funny.

I never considered Jones the GOAT. I told everyone he was roiding for a long time. I called it again when they faced off in the Octagon at 214. I laughed at how big Jones looked. I even made a thread here on sherdog asking about 214 drug test results a few days before he officially popped.

GSP is awesome and a clear #2 for me. Him beating 38 year old Bisping was cool but it doesn't put him over the top for me. I still think Fedor was a more impressive fighter against bigger and more dangerous opposition and the fact Fedor didn't lose for 10 years.
 
Fedor never finished at the highest level. GSP did.

Easy to knock over cans not full of soup.
If gsp fought the guys Fedor did he would’ve lost based on sheer size and strength disadvantage and he certainly would’ve lost rounds. Fedor had a longer streak and didn’t tap to strikes during it

Some people like blankets, but I’m a warm blooded man who likes aggression
 
Hughes finished BJJ black belts on the ground. And no, that's not how you pronounce it. I'm sure you can think of a racist equivalent pronunciation of a common name - how would you react to that?

Thinking about it, I still can't figure out how racism ties into Sherdog liking Fedor and GSP. Even in the Sherdog boxing subform, all of which have heard of the Klitschko's, the brothers are not considered greats despite being white. But you're saying that the only reason GSP and Fedor (two notoriously non-American fighters) are popular on Sherdog is because they're white ... you're inconsistent. If race was the issue, the Klitschko's would be as popular on Sherdog as Fedor and GSP are.

I'd say the difference is obvious; Fedor and GSP are popular not because of race, but because they are among the four best fighters. The Klitschko's, though as white as Fedor and GSP and similarly foreign, are unpopular because they're not among the best boxing HW's. In fact, given your argument for nationalism trumping race (ie your argument against the Klitschko's) you'd have to argue that Jones has a big initial advantage over Fedor, GSP, and Anderson.

And given that Fedor doesn't even speak English, everything else being neutral he should have the smallest following on Sherdog - suggesting the reason he has a good sized following is because he is a great fighter rather than racism.
Sherdog is full of Russians
 
Prime Fedor is the GOAT...literally the greatest fighter in MMA for a decade. Period. GSP was the best WW. There were NO fighters Fedor wouldn't have been favorite against. There are levels to this shit.

He also fought against fighters that had a larger weight difference than GSP would have if he fought Fedor

and we know what would happen if Prime Fedor and Prime GSP fought openweight

GSP would get absolutely destroyed
 
Even before bisping, GOATSP has the most top 5 wins ever at 17. At 36 comes out of retirement to choke unconscious 30-7 mw champion while fedor came out of retirement to fight 2-0 jaideep (now 2-3) despite having offers to come to the ufc to avenge his losses…these are the reasons he is the goat. And never a dick hopper, always said GSP is runner up goat if jones is no longer in the running due to peds. In all honesty fedora shouldn’t even be in the running for goat due to never being tested under usada and fishy 4-5 record in us! Cheers!

Even using that 1 criteria to make a claim It was still easier to get a top 5 ranking at WW. Fact is it was hard to crack the top 5 Hw 10 years ago and rankings weren’t set by the ufc.

Fedor has more top 10 wins, more finishes over top 10 fighters, a longer win streak, More wins over larger opponents, more wins over former ufc champs, more dominant wins over former ufc champs, never lost to former ufc champs, and has more finishes than gsp has wins.

All while beating guys at their own game

I vote fedor
 
I voted for Fedor when this thing went up, didn't think there would be such a huge gap between him and GSP, regardless of who won the vote


But it is also nice to see that his(GSP) hard work, commitment to keep improving his skill set, and the ability to game plan has him winning this poll, and appreciated buy the MMA fans

I feel if he defends that middleweight strap I too will be voting GSP from here on out

My reasoning for picking Fedor was that his fights were normally more exciting, plus fought at a heavier weight class, but I gotta admit I was on the edge of my seat with the Bisbing-GSP fight
 
If you've ever popped positive (CHEATED), then you're out of the GOAT conversation IMHO.
 
Back
Top