Who is the GOAT?

[myjohnson9]

Good on gsp he’s a great fighter and deserves respect. However prime Fedor vs prime gsp and Fedor would push his shit in bro

 

[ThunderStruck]

GSP is awesome and a clear #2 for me. Him beating 38 year old Bisping was cool but it doesn't put him over the top for me. I still think Fedor was a more impressive fighter against bigger and more dangerous opposition and the fact Fedor didn't lose for 10 years.

This is all subjective of course. I personally have GSP at number one and Fedor as number 2. According to this poll though the perception has switched into GSP's favour. I'd be curious to see what the mma medias think though. I have the feeling they would give GSP the nod as well.

 

[ThunderStruck]

Prime Fedor is the GOAT...literally the greatest fighter in MMA for a decade. Period. GSP was the best WW. There were NO fighters Fedor wouldn't have been favorite against. There are levels to this shit.

He also fought against fighters that had a larger weight difference than GSP would have if he fought Fedor

and we know what would happen if Prime Fedor and Prime GSP fought openweight

GSP would get absolutely destroyed

What a ridiculous comparison. Of course an HW is bigger and stronger than a WW. Whats your point again?

 

[Tactitus]

Looks like the days of Fedor dominating these are over.

 

[ThunderStruck]

Even using that 1 criteria to make a claim It was still easier to get a top 5 ranking at WW. Fact is it was hard to crack the top 5 Hw 10 years ago and rankings weren’t set by the ufc.

Fedor has more top 10 wins, more finishes over top 10 fighters, a longer win streak, More wins over larger opponents, more wins over former ufc champs, more dominant wins over former ufc champs, never lost to former ufc champs, and has more finishes than gsp has wins.

All while beating guys at their own game

I vote fedor

Load of bullshit again.

 

[Akabignasty]

 

[Perrichet]

Poor Anderson. Less votes than Guillard

 

[JBJISGOAT]

Even using that 1 criteria to make a claim It was still easier to get a top 5 ranking at WW. Fact is it was hard to crack the top 5 Hw 10 years ago and rankings weren’t set by the ufc.

Fedor has more top 10 wins, more finishes over top 10 fighters, a longer win streak, More wins over larger opponents, more wins over former ufc champs, more dominant wins over former ufc champs, never lost to former ufc champs, and has more finishes than gsp has wins.

All while beating guys at their own game

I vote fedor

Lol you really have to justify your answer with that crap is hilarious. All I have to say is beat every guy he fought and most top 5 wins (clearly top 5 wins are better than top 10) ever.

Let me ask you this...how the fuck do you respect a fighter who has the option to come to the ufc and avenge his losses yet chooses to sign with Japan promo and fight fucking 2-0 jaideep (now 2-3)???

Than you shit on GSP for coming out of retirement same age as fedor did and fights 30-7 mw champ?? And fucking chokes that champ unconscious?? I know you are extremely biased but even you have to see bullshit in fedor on this one.

 

[JBJISGOAT]

What a fucking rookie thing to say.

Fedor won his first 4 fights in the USA.

He did not lose until his 11th year of fighting.

You literally know nothing about MMA

I know that GSP is winning this poll ez as fuck LOLZ. It doesn’t matter what anybody says on here tho because GSP could clear out the whole mw division and you wouldn’t change your mind. Your infantile mind would still come up with your same pathetic excuses and justifications “but but but he was undefeated 10 years fighting monsters like Zulu and hmc”…

 

[Blayt7hh]

Only racist assholes and Fedor/GSP nuthuggers for obvious reasons. They can't accept the fact that a non white fighter gets called GOAT

Is the obvious reason the 2 time failed PED tests?

 

[JBJISGOAT]

If you've ever popped positive (CHEATED), then you're out of the GOAT conversation IMHO.

But what if you were never tested?? It’s unfair to exclude jones because he popped hot and include fedor since he was never tested by usada…and don’t give me that bullshit sambo shit. If exclude jones than no fedor because he obv looked terrible in America under testing 4-5.

 

[Strychnine]

But what if you were never tested?? It’s unfair to exclude jones because he popped hot and include fedor since he was never tested by usada…and don’t give me that bullshit sambo shit. If exclude jones than no fedor because he obv looked terrible in America under testing 4-5.

If you get caught, you got caught.

You're out.

MM = GOAT anyways.

 

[myjohnson9]

But what if you were never tested?? It’s unfair to exclude jones because he popped hot and include fedor since he was never tested by usada…and don’t give me that bullshit sambo shit. If exclude jones than no fedor because he obv looked terrible in America under testing 4-5.

Fedor was tested in the Us and by USADA for his sambo tournaments before you or Dana ever knew what USADA was. He was the ONLY one being tested at the time

 

[ThunderStruck]

Fedor was tested in the Us and by USADA for his sambo tournaments before you or Dana ever knew what USADA was. He was the ONLY one being tested at the time

LOOLLLLLLLLLLL Sambo testing. Gave me a good laugh bro.

 

[Deleted member 501827]

The most surprising thing about this poll is Woodley got more votes than Chuck, like wtf

 

[Typrune Goatley]

But what if you were never tested?? It’s unfair to exclude jones because he popped hot and include fedor since he was never tested by usada…and don’t give me that bullshit sambo shit. If exclude jones than no fedor because he obv looked terrible in America under testing 4-5.

Once again, ignorant statement.

Fedor won his first 4 fights in the USA.

Fedor didn't lose until his 11th year.

98% of GSP's fights were pre-USADA as well.

 

[JBJISGOAT]

Fedor was tested in the Us and by USADA for his sambo tournaments before you or Dana ever knew what USADA was. He was the ONLY one being tested at the time

Lol here we go with the sambo bs. Fedora was never tested under mma for USADA purposes during his mythical 10 years of can crushing...therefore if you take out jones for ped usage than fedora can’t be considered due to not being tested. Sorry bud, no way you can spin this one.

 

[JBJISGOAT]

Lol you really have to justify your answer with that crap is hilarious. All I have to say is beat every guy he fought and most top 5 wins (clearly top 5 wins are better than top 10) ever.

Let me ask you this...how the fuck do you respect a fighter who has the option to come to the ufc and avenge his losses yet chooses to sign with Japan promo and fight fucking 2-0 jaideep (now 2-3)???

Than you shit on GSP for coming out of retirement same age as fedor did and fights 30-7 mw champ?? And fucking chokes that champ unconscious?? I know you are extremely biased but even you have to see bullshit in fedor on this one.

@myjohnson9 conveniently did answer my question here tho but respond to the other posts. Lolz.

 

[JBJISGOAT]

Once again, ignorant statement.

Fedor won his first 4 fights in the USA.

Fedor didn't lose until his 11th year.

98% of GSP's fights were pre-USADA as well.

Stop spamming posts bruh. GSP also never fought 0-1 fake pro wrasslers, hmc, Zulu, etc. he also didn’t fight with refs with earpieces and known org to fix fights. Ask rampage.

 

[chinarice]

Fedor would smash GSP in a fight so GOAT will always be the bigger fighter. I'd say you would have to be LHW and up to be considered GOAT.

That's not true and never has been the case in combat sports. Sugar Ray Robinson is considered the greatest boxer of all time and was not a HW. I get it, you like Fedor and don't care for GSP but your opinion does not = fact.