Who is the brazillian MMA GOAT?

[Lucas Motta]

José Aldo- 29-7
9 title defenses

Anderson Silva- 34-11
10 UFC title defenses

Wanderlei SIlva- 35-14
4 Pride title defenses

Any other honorable mentions?

 

[Megatronlee]

Anderson

 

[TheMessiah]

Andergoat

 

[eiyuu]

Waldemar Santana

 

[L0ki]

GOAT is career spanning, so incorporates wins and losses.

It would've been Anderson, tho he kept fighting to the point of so many losses and he couldn't get a W over anyone on the roster.

He's still in there, tho his spot is now mixed in with Wand, Aldo, and I think Shogun should be on that list.

There's a chance that I'm unintentionally omitting someone that deserves to be on the list.

 

[DagOban**]

Anderson

Honorable mention : Antônio Rodrigo Nogueira

 

[mkt]

Anderson. Wand, Shogun, etc. never had a consistent run like his.

 

[Sweater of AV]

Big Nog

 

[Fight Professor]

Big Nog should be in the discussion as well. Just because Fedor exists it does not make him less of a Brazilian GOAT contender.

 

[Fight Professor]

Big Nog

I was late by a few seconds.

 

[Kos Fan]

Anderson 1
Aldo 2
Shogun 3

 

[danny23]

Amanda.

Steroid cheats shouldn’t qualify.

 

[Lucas Motta]

Anderson. Wand, Shogun, etc. never had a consistent run like his.

Wand had a 17 fight win streak whilst middleweight champion of PRIDE, with one draw with Cro Cop.

 

[HHJ]

I'd have to go w Aldo at this point.

 

[HHJ]

Also pride Champs rarely defended their titles but fought 3 times as much as ufc fighters so to judge wand on title defenses alone is very misleading

 

[mkt]

Wand had a 17 fight win streak whilst middleweight champion of PRIDE, with one draw with Cro Cop.

Almost completely against much smaller Japanese fighters while Wand was roided to the gills.

 

[Jorge Luis Borges]

Anderson Shilba.

 

[6 Pack Lapadat]

Anderson Silva is likely the GOAT. Do you want to add a guy to the convo like Royce who started it all, and for his day was dominant and consistently won? We are only here because of Royce, and he was a finisher who took on all comers.

 

[Lucas Motta]

Almost completely against much smaller Japanese fighters while Wand was roided to the gills.

The fact Wand was on roids doesn't mean much, are Jon Jones' title defenses irrelevant, even if he was on steroids? Chael Sonnen's entire career, Vitor Belfort's? I agree with you in regards to the quality of his opponents, but keep in mind he also fought some really tough guys, such as Rampage Jackson, Ricardo Arona, Cro Cop, etc.

 

[mkt]

Anderson Silva is likely the GOAT. Do you want to add a guy to the convo like Royce who started it all, and for his day was dominant and consistently won? We are only here because of Royce, and he was a finisher who took on all comers.

 

[6 Pack Lapadat]

Wand had a 17 fight win streak whilst middleweight champion of PRIDE, with one draw with Cro Cop.

And that draw was agreed if the fight went the distance it would be a draw. But most ppl agree Silva got the better of that fight comfortably.